Cargando…

Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain

We report a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies that assessed the antinociceptive efficacy of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators on pain-associated behavioural outcomes in animal models of pathological or injury-related persistent pain. In April...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Soliman, Nadia, Haroutounian, Simon, Hohmann, Andrea G., Krane, Elliot, Liao, Jing, Macleod, Malcolm, Segelcke, Daniel, Sena, Christopher, Thomas, James, Vollert, Jan, Wever, Kimberley, Alaverdyan, Harutyun, Barakat, Ahmed, Barthlow, Tyler, Bozer, Amber L. Harris, Davidson, Alexander, Diaz-delCastillo, Marta, Dolgorukova, Antonina, Ferdousi, Mehnaz I., Healy, Catherine, Hong, Simon, Hopkins, Mary, James, Arul, Leake, Hayley B., Malewicz, Nathalie M., Mansfield, Michael, Mardon, Amelia K., Mattimoe, Darragh, McLoone, Daniel P., Noes-Holt, Gith, Pogatzki-Zahn, Esther M., Power, Emer, Pradier, Bruno, Romanos-Sirakis, Eleny, Segelcke, Astra, Vinagre, Rafael, Yanes, Julio A., Zhang, Jingwen, Zhang, Xue Ying, Finn, David P., Rice, Andrew S.C.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Wolters Kluwer 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8216112/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33729209
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002269
_version_ 1783710357020213248
author Soliman, Nadia
Haroutounian, Simon
Hohmann, Andrea G.
Krane, Elliot
Liao, Jing
Macleod, Malcolm
Segelcke, Daniel
Sena, Christopher
Thomas, James
Vollert, Jan
Wever, Kimberley
Alaverdyan, Harutyun
Barakat, Ahmed
Barthlow, Tyler
Bozer, Amber L. Harris
Davidson, Alexander
Diaz-delCastillo, Marta
Dolgorukova, Antonina
Ferdousi, Mehnaz I.
Healy, Catherine
Hong, Simon
Hopkins, Mary
James, Arul
Leake, Hayley B.
Malewicz, Nathalie M.
Mansfield, Michael
Mardon, Amelia K.
Mattimoe, Darragh
McLoone, Daniel P.
Noes-Holt, Gith
Pogatzki-Zahn, Esther M.
Power, Emer
Pradier, Bruno
Romanos-Sirakis, Eleny
Segelcke, Astra
Vinagre, Rafael
Yanes, Julio A.
Zhang, Jingwen
Zhang, Xue Ying
Finn, David P.
Rice, Andrew S.C.
author_facet Soliman, Nadia
Haroutounian, Simon
Hohmann, Andrea G.
Krane, Elliot
Liao, Jing
Macleod, Malcolm
Segelcke, Daniel
Sena, Christopher
Thomas, James
Vollert, Jan
Wever, Kimberley
Alaverdyan, Harutyun
Barakat, Ahmed
Barthlow, Tyler
Bozer, Amber L. Harris
Davidson, Alexander
Diaz-delCastillo, Marta
Dolgorukova, Antonina
Ferdousi, Mehnaz I.
Healy, Catherine
Hong, Simon
Hopkins, Mary
James, Arul
Leake, Hayley B.
Malewicz, Nathalie M.
Mansfield, Michael
Mardon, Amelia K.
Mattimoe, Darragh
McLoone, Daniel P.
Noes-Holt, Gith
Pogatzki-Zahn, Esther M.
Power, Emer
Pradier, Bruno
Romanos-Sirakis, Eleny
Segelcke, Astra
Vinagre, Rafael
Yanes, Julio A.
Zhang, Jingwen
Zhang, Xue Ying
Finn, David P.
Rice, Andrew S.C.
author_sort Soliman, Nadia
collection PubMed
description We report a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies that assessed the antinociceptive efficacy of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators on pain-associated behavioural outcomes in animal models of pathological or injury-related persistent pain. In April 2019, we systematically searched 3 online databases and used crowd science and machine learning to identify studies for inclusion. We calculated a standardised mean difference effect size for each comparison and performed a random-effects meta-analysis. We assessed the impact of study design characteristics and reporting of mitigations to reduce the risk of bias. We meta-analysed 374 studies in which 171 interventions were assessed for antinociceptive efficacy in rodent models of pathological or injury-related pain. Most experiments were conducted in male animals (86%). Antinociceptive efficacy was most frequently measured by attenuation of hypersensitivity to evoked limb withdrawal. Selective cannabinoid type 1, cannabinoid type 2, nonselective cannabinoid receptor agonists (including delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol) and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-alpha agonists (predominantly palmitoylethanolamide) significantly attenuated pain-associated behaviours in a broad range of inflammatory and neuropathic pain models. Fatty acid amide hydrolase inhibitors, monoacylglycerol lipase inhibitors, and cannabidiol significantly attenuated pain-associated behaviours in neuropathic pain models but yielded mixed results in inflammatory pain models. The reporting of criteria to reduce the risk of bias was low; therefore, the studies have an unclear risk of bias. The value of future studies could be enhanced by improving the reporting of methodological criteria, the clinical relevance of the models, and behavioural assessments. Notwithstanding, the evidence supports the hypothesis of cannabinoid-induced analgesia.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8216112
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Wolters Kluwer
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-82161122021-06-24 Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain Soliman, Nadia Haroutounian, Simon Hohmann, Andrea G. Krane, Elliot Liao, Jing Macleod, Malcolm Segelcke, Daniel Sena, Christopher Thomas, James Vollert, Jan Wever, Kimberley Alaverdyan, Harutyun Barakat, Ahmed Barthlow, Tyler Bozer, Amber L. Harris Davidson, Alexander Diaz-delCastillo, Marta Dolgorukova, Antonina Ferdousi, Mehnaz I. Healy, Catherine Hong, Simon Hopkins, Mary James, Arul Leake, Hayley B. Malewicz, Nathalie M. Mansfield, Michael Mardon, Amelia K. Mattimoe, Darragh McLoone, Daniel P. Noes-Holt, Gith Pogatzki-Zahn, Esther M. Power, Emer Pradier, Bruno Romanos-Sirakis, Eleny Segelcke, Astra Vinagre, Rafael Yanes, Julio A. Zhang, Jingwen Zhang, Xue Ying Finn, David P. Rice, Andrew S.C. Pain Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis We report a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies that assessed the antinociceptive efficacy of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators on pain-associated behavioural outcomes in animal models of pathological or injury-related persistent pain. In April 2019, we systematically searched 3 online databases and used crowd science and machine learning to identify studies for inclusion. We calculated a standardised mean difference effect size for each comparison and performed a random-effects meta-analysis. We assessed the impact of study design characteristics and reporting of mitigations to reduce the risk of bias. We meta-analysed 374 studies in which 171 interventions were assessed for antinociceptive efficacy in rodent models of pathological or injury-related pain. Most experiments were conducted in male animals (86%). Antinociceptive efficacy was most frequently measured by attenuation of hypersensitivity to evoked limb withdrawal. Selective cannabinoid type 1, cannabinoid type 2, nonselective cannabinoid receptor agonists (including delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol) and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-alpha agonists (predominantly palmitoylethanolamide) significantly attenuated pain-associated behaviours in a broad range of inflammatory and neuropathic pain models. Fatty acid amide hydrolase inhibitors, monoacylglycerol lipase inhibitors, and cannabidiol significantly attenuated pain-associated behaviours in neuropathic pain models but yielded mixed results in inflammatory pain models. The reporting of criteria to reduce the risk of bias was low; therefore, the studies have an unclear risk of bias. The value of future studies could be enhanced by improving the reporting of methodological criteria, the clinical relevance of the models, and behavioural assessments. Notwithstanding, the evidence supports the hypothesis of cannabinoid-induced analgesia. Wolters Kluwer 2021-07 2021-03-15 /pmc/articles/PMC8216112/ /pubmed/33729209 http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002269 Text en Copyright © 2021 The Author(s). Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. on behalf of the International Association for the Study of Pain. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives License 4.0 (CCBY-NC-ND) (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) , where it is permissible to download and share the work provided it is properly cited. The work cannot be changed in any way or used commercially without permission from the journal.
spellingShingle Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Soliman, Nadia
Haroutounian, Simon
Hohmann, Andrea G.
Krane, Elliot
Liao, Jing
Macleod, Malcolm
Segelcke, Daniel
Sena, Christopher
Thomas, James
Vollert, Jan
Wever, Kimberley
Alaverdyan, Harutyun
Barakat, Ahmed
Barthlow, Tyler
Bozer, Amber L. Harris
Davidson, Alexander
Diaz-delCastillo, Marta
Dolgorukova, Antonina
Ferdousi, Mehnaz I.
Healy, Catherine
Hong, Simon
Hopkins, Mary
James, Arul
Leake, Hayley B.
Malewicz, Nathalie M.
Mansfield, Michael
Mardon, Amelia K.
Mattimoe, Darragh
McLoone, Daniel P.
Noes-Holt, Gith
Pogatzki-Zahn, Esther M.
Power, Emer
Pradier, Bruno
Romanos-Sirakis, Eleny
Segelcke, Astra
Vinagre, Rafael
Yanes, Julio A.
Zhang, Jingwen
Zhang, Xue Ying
Finn, David P.
Rice, Andrew S.C.
Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
title Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
title_full Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
title_fullStr Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
title_full_unstemmed Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
title_short Systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
title_sort systematic review and meta-analysis of cannabinoids, cannabis-based medicines, and endocannabinoid system modulators tested for antinociceptive effects in animal models of injury-related or pathological persistent pain
topic Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8216112/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33729209
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002269
work_keys_str_mv AT solimannadia systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT haroutouniansimon systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT hohmannandreag systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT kraneelliot systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT liaojing systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT macleodmalcolm systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT segelckedaniel systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT senachristopher systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT thomasjames systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT vollertjan systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT weverkimberley systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT alaverdyanharutyun systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT barakatahmed systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT barthlowtyler systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT bozeramberlharris systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT davidsonalexander systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT diazdelcastillomarta systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT dolgorukovaantonina systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT ferdousimehnazi systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT healycatherine systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT hongsimon systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT hopkinsmary systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT jamesarul systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT leakehayleyb systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT malewicznathaliem systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT mansfieldmichael systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT mardonameliak systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT mattimoedarragh systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT mcloonedanielp systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT noesholtgith systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT pogatzkizahnestherm systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT poweremer systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT pradierbruno systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT romanossirakiseleny systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT segelckeastra systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT vinagrerafael systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT yanesjulioa systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT zhangjingwen systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT zhangxueying systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT finndavidp systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain
AT riceandrewsc systematicreviewandmetaanalysisofcannabinoidscannabisbasedmedicinesandendocannabinoidsystemmodulatorstestedforantinociceptiveeffectsinanimalmodelsofinjuryrelatedorpathologicalpersistentpain