Cargando…

A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza

Autopsies of patients who have died from COVID‐19 have been crucial in delineating patterns of injury associated with SARS‐CoV‐2 infection. Despite their utility, comprehensive autopsy studies are somewhat lacking relative to the global burden of disease, and very few comprehensive studies contextua...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: McMullen, Phillip, Pytel, Peter, Snyder, Alexis, Smith, Heather, Vickery, Jasmine, Brainer, James, Guzy, Robert, Wu, David, Schoettler, Nathan, Adegunsoye, Ayodeji, Sperling, Anne, Hart, John, Alpert, Lindsay, Chang, Anthony, Gurbuxani, Sandeep, Krausz, Thomas, Husain, Aliya N, Mueller, Jeffrey
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8239851/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33960723
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cjp2.220
_version_ 1783715115527307264
author McMullen, Phillip
Pytel, Peter
Snyder, Alexis
Smith, Heather
Vickery, Jasmine
Brainer, James
Guzy, Robert
Wu, David
Schoettler, Nathan
Adegunsoye, Ayodeji
Sperling, Anne
Hart, John
Alpert, Lindsay
Chang, Anthony
Gurbuxani, Sandeep
Krausz, Thomas
Husain, Aliya N
Mueller, Jeffrey
author_facet McMullen, Phillip
Pytel, Peter
Snyder, Alexis
Smith, Heather
Vickery, Jasmine
Brainer, James
Guzy, Robert
Wu, David
Schoettler, Nathan
Adegunsoye, Ayodeji
Sperling, Anne
Hart, John
Alpert, Lindsay
Chang, Anthony
Gurbuxani, Sandeep
Krausz, Thomas
Husain, Aliya N
Mueller, Jeffrey
author_sort McMullen, Phillip
collection PubMed
description Autopsies of patients who have died from COVID‐19 have been crucial in delineating patterns of injury associated with SARS‐CoV‐2 infection. Despite their utility, comprehensive autopsy studies are somewhat lacking relative to the global burden of disease, and very few comprehensive studies contextualize the findings to other fatal viral infections. We developed a novel autopsy protocol in order to perform postmortem examinations on victims of COVID‐19 and herein describe detailed clinical information, gross findings, and histologic features observed in the first 16 complete COVID‐19 autopsies. We also critically evaluated the role of ancillary studies used to establish a diagnosis of COVID‐19 at autopsy, including immunohistochemistry (IHC), in situ hybridization (ISH), and electron microscopy (EM). IHC and ISH targeting SARS‐CoV‐2 were comparable in terms of the location and number of infected cells in lung tissue; however, nonspecific staining of bacteria was seen occasionally with IHC. EM was unrevealing in blindly sampled tissues. We then compared the clinical and histologic features present in this series to six archival cases of fatal seasonal influenza and six archival cases of pandemic influenza from the fourth wave of the ‘Spanish Flu’ in the winter of 1920. In addition to routine histology, the inflammatory infiltrates in the lungs of COVID‐19 and seasonal influenza victims were compared using quantitative IHC. Our results demonstrate that the clinical and histologic features of COVID‐19 are similar to those seen in fatal cases of influenza, and the two diseases tend to overlap histologically. There was no significant difference in the composition of the inflammatory infiltrate in COVID‐19 and influenza at sites of acute lung injury at the time of autopsy. Our study underscores the relatively nonspecific clinical features and pathologic changes shared between severe cases of COVID‐19 and influenza, while also providing important caveats to ancillary methods of viral detection.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8239851
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-82398512021-06-29 A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza McMullen, Phillip Pytel, Peter Snyder, Alexis Smith, Heather Vickery, Jasmine Brainer, James Guzy, Robert Wu, David Schoettler, Nathan Adegunsoye, Ayodeji Sperling, Anne Hart, John Alpert, Lindsay Chang, Anthony Gurbuxani, Sandeep Krausz, Thomas Husain, Aliya N Mueller, Jeffrey J Pathol Clin Res Original Articles Autopsies of patients who have died from COVID‐19 have been crucial in delineating patterns of injury associated with SARS‐CoV‐2 infection. Despite their utility, comprehensive autopsy studies are somewhat lacking relative to the global burden of disease, and very few comprehensive studies contextualize the findings to other fatal viral infections. We developed a novel autopsy protocol in order to perform postmortem examinations on victims of COVID‐19 and herein describe detailed clinical information, gross findings, and histologic features observed in the first 16 complete COVID‐19 autopsies. We also critically evaluated the role of ancillary studies used to establish a diagnosis of COVID‐19 at autopsy, including immunohistochemistry (IHC), in situ hybridization (ISH), and electron microscopy (EM). IHC and ISH targeting SARS‐CoV‐2 were comparable in terms of the location and number of infected cells in lung tissue; however, nonspecific staining of bacteria was seen occasionally with IHC. EM was unrevealing in blindly sampled tissues. We then compared the clinical and histologic features present in this series to six archival cases of fatal seasonal influenza and six archival cases of pandemic influenza from the fourth wave of the ‘Spanish Flu’ in the winter of 1920. In addition to routine histology, the inflammatory infiltrates in the lungs of COVID‐19 and seasonal influenza victims were compared using quantitative IHC. Our results demonstrate that the clinical and histologic features of COVID‐19 are similar to those seen in fatal cases of influenza, and the two diseases tend to overlap histologically. There was no significant difference in the composition of the inflammatory infiltrate in COVID‐19 and influenza at sites of acute lung injury at the time of autopsy. Our study underscores the relatively nonspecific clinical features and pathologic changes shared between severe cases of COVID‐19 and influenza, while also providing important caveats to ancillary methods of viral detection. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2021-05-07 /pmc/articles/PMC8239851/ /pubmed/33960723 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cjp2.220 Text en © 2021 The Authors. The Journal of Pathology: Clinical Research published by The Pathological Society of Great Britain and Ireland & John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made.
spellingShingle Original Articles
McMullen, Phillip
Pytel, Peter
Snyder, Alexis
Smith, Heather
Vickery, Jasmine
Brainer, James
Guzy, Robert
Wu, David
Schoettler, Nathan
Adegunsoye, Ayodeji
Sperling, Anne
Hart, John
Alpert, Lindsay
Chang, Anthony
Gurbuxani, Sandeep
Krausz, Thomas
Husain, Aliya N
Mueller, Jeffrey
A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
title A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
title_full A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
title_fullStr A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
title_full_unstemmed A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
title_short A series of COVID‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
title_sort series of covid‐19 autopsies with clinical and pathologic comparisons to both seasonal and pandemic influenza
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8239851/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33960723
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cjp2.220
work_keys_str_mv AT mcmullenphillip aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT pytelpeter aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT snyderalexis aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT smithheather aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT vickeryjasmine aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT brainerjames aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT guzyrobert aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT wudavid aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT schoettlernathan aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT adegunsoyeayodeji aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT sperlinganne aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT hartjohn aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT alpertlindsay aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT changanthony aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT gurbuxanisandeep aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT krauszthomas aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT husainaliyan aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT muellerjeffrey aseriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT mcmullenphillip seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT pytelpeter seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT snyderalexis seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT smithheather seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT vickeryjasmine seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT brainerjames seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT guzyrobert seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT wudavid seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT schoettlernathan seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT adegunsoyeayodeji seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT sperlinganne seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT hartjohn seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT alpertlindsay seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT changanthony seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT gurbuxanisandeep seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT krauszthomas seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT husainaliyan seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza
AT muellerjeffrey seriesofcovid19autopsieswithclinicalandpathologiccomparisonstobothseasonalandpandemicinfluenza