Cargando…

Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents

1. Accurate biodiversity and population monitoring is a requirement for effective conservation decision making. Survey method bias is therefore a concern, particularly when research programs face logistical and cost limitations. 2. We employed point counts (PCs) and autonomous recording units (ARUs)...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Drake, Anna, de Zwaan, Devin R., Altamirano, Tomás A., Wilson, Scott, Hick, Kristina, Bravo, Camila, Ibarra, José Tomás, Martin, Kathy
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8258233/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34257921
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ece3.7678
_version_ 1783718463804538880
author Drake, Anna
de Zwaan, Devin R.
Altamirano, Tomás A.
Wilson, Scott
Hick, Kristina
Bravo, Camila
Ibarra, José Tomás
Martin, Kathy
author_facet Drake, Anna
de Zwaan, Devin R.
Altamirano, Tomás A.
Wilson, Scott
Hick, Kristina
Bravo, Camila
Ibarra, José Tomás
Martin, Kathy
author_sort Drake, Anna
collection PubMed
description 1. Accurate biodiversity and population monitoring is a requirement for effective conservation decision making. Survey method bias is therefore a concern, particularly when research programs face logistical and cost limitations. 2. We employed point counts (PCs) and autonomous recording units (ARUs) to survey avian biodiversity within comparable, high elevation, temperate mountain habitats at opposite ends of the Americas: nine mountains in British Columbia (BC), Canada, and 10 in southern Chile. We compared detected species richness against multiyear species inventories and examined method‐specific detection probability by family. By incorporating time costs, we assessed the performance and efficiency of single versus combined methods. 3. Species accumulation curves indicate ARUs can capture ~93% of species present in BC but only ~58% in Chile, despite Chilean mountain communities being less diverse. The avian community, rather than landscape composition, appears to drive this dramatic difference. Chilean communities contain less‐vocal species, which ARUs missed. Further, 6/13 families in BC were better detected by ARUs, while 11/11 families in Chile were better detected by PCs. Where survey conditions differentially impacted method performance, PCs mostly varied over the morning and with canopy cover in BC, while ARUs mostly varied seasonally in Chile. Within a single year of monitoring, neither method alone was predicted to capture the full avian community, with the exception of ARUs in the alpine and subalpine of BC. PCs contributed little to detected diversity in BC, but including this method resulted in negligible increases in total time costs. Combining PCs with ARUs in Chile significantly increased species detections, again, for little cost. 4. Combined methods were among the most efficient and accurate approaches to capturing diversity. We recommend conducting point counts, while ARUs are being deployed and retrieved in order to capture additional diversity with minimal additional effort and to flag methodological biases using a comparative framework.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8258233
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-82582332021-07-12 Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents Drake, Anna de Zwaan, Devin R. Altamirano, Tomás A. Wilson, Scott Hick, Kristina Bravo, Camila Ibarra, José Tomás Martin, Kathy Ecol Evol Original Research 1. Accurate biodiversity and population monitoring is a requirement for effective conservation decision making. Survey method bias is therefore a concern, particularly when research programs face logistical and cost limitations. 2. We employed point counts (PCs) and autonomous recording units (ARUs) to survey avian biodiversity within comparable, high elevation, temperate mountain habitats at opposite ends of the Americas: nine mountains in British Columbia (BC), Canada, and 10 in southern Chile. We compared detected species richness against multiyear species inventories and examined method‐specific detection probability by family. By incorporating time costs, we assessed the performance and efficiency of single versus combined methods. 3. Species accumulation curves indicate ARUs can capture ~93% of species present in BC but only ~58% in Chile, despite Chilean mountain communities being less diverse. The avian community, rather than landscape composition, appears to drive this dramatic difference. Chilean communities contain less‐vocal species, which ARUs missed. Further, 6/13 families in BC were better detected by ARUs, while 11/11 families in Chile were better detected by PCs. Where survey conditions differentially impacted method performance, PCs mostly varied over the morning and with canopy cover in BC, while ARUs mostly varied seasonally in Chile. Within a single year of monitoring, neither method alone was predicted to capture the full avian community, with the exception of ARUs in the alpine and subalpine of BC. PCs contributed little to detected diversity in BC, but including this method resulted in negligible increases in total time costs. Combining PCs with ARUs in Chile significantly increased species detections, again, for little cost. 4. Combined methods were among the most efficient and accurate approaches to capturing diversity. We recommend conducting point counts, while ARUs are being deployed and retrieved in order to capture additional diversity with minimal additional effort and to flag methodological biases using a comparative framework. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021-06-01 /pmc/articles/PMC8258233/ /pubmed/34257921 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ece3.7678 Text en © 2021 The Authors. Ecology and Evolution published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Original Research
Drake, Anna
de Zwaan, Devin R.
Altamirano, Tomás A.
Wilson, Scott
Hick, Kristina
Bravo, Camila
Ibarra, José Tomás
Martin, Kathy
Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
title Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
title_full Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
title_fullStr Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
title_full_unstemmed Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
title_short Combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
title_sort combining point counts and autonomous recording units improves avian survey efficacy across elevational gradients on two continents
topic Original Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8258233/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34257921
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ece3.7678
work_keys_str_mv AT drakeanna combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT dezwaandevinr combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT altamiranotomasa combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT wilsonscott combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT hickkristina combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT bravocamila combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT ibarrajosetomas combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents
AT martinkathy combiningpointcountsandautonomousrecordingunitsimprovesaviansurveyefficacyacrosselevationalgradientsontwocontinents