Cargando…

A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves

BACKGROUND: Manual axon histomorphometry (AH) is time- and resource-intensive, which has inspired many attempts at automation. However, there has been little investigation on implementation of automated programs for widespread use. Ideally such a program should be able to perform AH across imaging m...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Wong, Alison L., Hricz, Nicholas, Malapati, Harsha, von Guionneau, Nicholas, Wong, Michael, Harris, Thomas, Boudreau, Mathieu, Cohen-Adad, Julien, Tuffaha, Sami
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8263263/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34234376
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0248323
_version_ 1783719354362232832
author Wong, Alison L.
Hricz, Nicholas
Malapati, Harsha
von Guionneau, Nicholas
Wong, Michael
Harris, Thomas
Boudreau, Mathieu
Cohen-Adad, Julien
Tuffaha, Sami
author_facet Wong, Alison L.
Hricz, Nicholas
Malapati, Harsha
von Guionneau, Nicholas
Wong, Michael
Harris, Thomas
Boudreau, Mathieu
Cohen-Adad, Julien
Tuffaha, Sami
author_sort Wong, Alison L.
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Manual axon histomorphometry (AH) is time- and resource-intensive, which has inspired many attempts at automation. However, there has been little investigation on implementation of automated programs for widespread use. Ideally such a program should be able to perform AH across imaging modalities and nerve states. AxonDeepSeg (ADS) is an open source deep learning program that has previously been validated in electron microscopy. We evaluated the robustness of ADS for peripheral nerve axonal histomorphometry in light micrographs prepared using two different methods. METHODS: Axon histomorphometry using ADS and manual analysis (gold-standard) was performed on light micrographs of naïve or regenerating rat median nerve cross-sections prepared with either toluidine-resin or osmium-paraffin embedding protocols. The parameters of interest included axon count, axon diameter, myelin thickness, and g-ratio. RESULTS: Manual and automatic ADS axon counts demonstrated good agreement in naïve nerves and moderate agreement on regenerating nerves. There were small but consistent differences in measured axon diameter, myelin thickness and g-ratio; however, absolute differences were small. Both methods appropriately identified differences between naïve and regenerating nerves. ADS was faster than manual axon analysis. CONCLUSIONS: Without any algorithm retraining, ADS was able to appropriately identify critical differences between naïve and regenerating nerves and work with different sample preparation methods of peripheral nerve light micrographs. While there were differences between absolute values between manual and ADS, ADS performed consistently and required much less time. ADS is an accessible and robust tool for AH that can provide consistent analysis across protocols and nerve states.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8263263
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-82632632021-07-19 A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves Wong, Alison L. Hricz, Nicholas Malapati, Harsha von Guionneau, Nicholas Wong, Michael Harris, Thomas Boudreau, Mathieu Cohen-Adad, Julien Tuffaha, Sami PLoS One Research Article BACKGROUND: Manual axon histomorphometry (AH) is time- and resource-intensive, which has inspired many attempts at automation. However, there has been little investigation on implementation of automated programs for widespread use. Ideally such a program should be able to perform AH across imaging modalities and nerve states. AxonDeepSeg (ADS) is an open source deep learning program that has previously been validated in electron microscopy. We evaluated the robustness of ADS for peripheral nerve axonal histomorphometry in light micrographs prepared using two different methods. METHODS: Axon histomorphometry using ADS and manual analysis (gold-standard) was performed on light micrographs of naïve or regenerating rat median nerve cross-sections prepared with either toluidine-resin or osmium-paraffin embedding protocols. The parameters of interest included axon count, axon diameter, myelin thickness, and g-ratio. RESULTS: Manual and automatic ADS axon counts demonstrated good agreement in naïve nerves and moderate agreement on regenerating nerves. There were small but consistent differences in measured axon diameter, myelin thickness and g-ratio; however, absolute differences were small. Both methods appropriately identified differences between naïve and regenerating nerves. ADS was faster than manual axon analysis. CONCLUSIONS: Without any algorithm retraining, ADS was able to appropriately identify critical differences between naïve and regenerating nerves and work with different sample preparation methods of peripheral nerve light micrographs. While there were differences between absolute values between manual and ADS, ADS performed consistently and required much less time. ADS is an accessible and robust tool for AH that can provide consistent analysis across protocols and nerve states. Public Library of Science 2021-07-07 /pmc/articles/PMC8263263/ /pubmed/34234376 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0248323 Text en © 2021 Wong et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Wong, Alison L.
Hricz, Nicholas
Malapati, Harsha
von Guionneau, Nicholas
Wong, Michael
Harris, Thomas
Boudreau, Mathieu
Cohen-Adad, Julien
Tuffaha, Sami
A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
title A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
title_full A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
title_fullStr A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
title_full_unstemmed A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
title_short A simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
title_sort simple and robust method for automating analysis of naïve and regenerating peripheral nerves
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8263263/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34234376
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0248323
work_keys_str_mv AT wongalisonl asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT hricznicholas asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT malapatiharsha asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT vonguionneaunicholas asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT wongmichael asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT harristhomas asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT boudreaumathieu asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT cohenadadjulien asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT tuffahasami asimpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT wongalisonl simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT hricznicholas simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT malapatiharsha simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT vonguionneaunicholas simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT wongmichael simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT harristhomas simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT boudreaumathieu simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT cohenadadjulien simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves
AT tuffahasami simpleandrobustmethodforautomatinganalysisofnaiveandregeneratingperipheralnerves