Cargando…

Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence

Environmental monitoring in public spaces can be used to identify surfaces contaminated by persons with COVID-19 and inform appropriate infection mitigation responses. Research groups have reported detection of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) on surfaces days or weeks af...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Salido, Rodolfo A., Cantú, Victor J., Clark, Alex E., Leibel, Sandra L., Foroughishafiei, Anahid, Saha, Anushka, Hakim, Abbas, Nouri, Alhakam, Lastrella, Alma L., Castro-Martínez, Anelizze, Plascencia, Ashley, Kapadia, Bhavika, Xia, Bing, Ruiz, Christopher, Marotz, Clarisse A., Maunder, Daniel, Lawrence, Elijah S., Smoot, Elizabeth W., Eisner, Emily, Crescini, Evelyn S., Kohn, Laura, Vargas, Lizbeth Franco, Chacón, Marisol, Betty, Maryann, Machnicki, Michal, Wu, Min Yi, Baer, Nathan A., Belda-Ferre, Pedro, Hoff, Peter De, Seaver, Phoebe, Ostrander, R. Tyler, Tsai, Rebecca, Sathe, Shashank, Aigner, Stefan, Morgan, Sydney C., Ngo, Toan T., Barber, Tom, Cheung, Willi, Carlin, Aaron F., Yeo, Gene W., Laurent, Louise C., Fielding-Miller, Rebecca, Knight, Rob
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8312891/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34312621
http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/2021.07.16.452756
_version_ 1783729219423961088
author Salido, Rodolfo A.
Cantú, Victor J.
Clark, Alex E.
Leibel, Sandra L.
Foroughishafiei, Anahid
Saha, Anushka
Hakim, Abbas
Nouri, Alhakam
Lastrella, Alma L.
Castro-Martínez, Anelizze
Plascencia, Ashley
Kapadia, Bhavika
Xia, Bing
Ruiz, Christopher
Marotz, Clarisse A.
Maunder, Daniel
Lawrence, Elijah S.
Smoot, Elizabeth W.
Eisner, Emily
Crescini, Evelyn S.
Kohn, Laura
Vargas, Lizbeth Franco
Chacón, Marisol
Betty, Maryann
Machnicki, Michal
Wu, Min Yi
Baer, Nathan A.
Belda-Ferre, Pedro
Hoff, Peter De
Seaver, Phoebe
Ostrander, R. Tyler
Tsai, Rebecca
Sathe, Shashank
Aigner, Stefan
Morgan, Sydney C.
Ngo, Toan T.
Barber, Tom
Cheung, Willi
Carlin, Aaron F.
Yeo, Gene W.
Laurent, Louise C.
Fielding-Miller, Rebecca
Knight, Rob
author_facet Salido, Rodolfo A.
Cantú, Victor J.
Clark, Alex E.
Leibel, Sandra L.
Foroughishafiei, Anahid
Saha, Anushka
Hakim, Abbas
Nouri, Alhakam
Lastrella, Alma L.
Castro-Martínez, Anelizze
Plascencia, Ashley
Kapadia, Bhavika
Xia, Bing
Ruiz, Christopher
Marotz, Clarisse A.
Maunder, Daniel
Lawrence, Elijah S.
Smoot, Elizabeth W.
Eisner, Emily
Crescini, Evelyn S.
Kohn, Laura
Vargas, Lizbeth Franco
Chacón, Marisol
Betty, Maryann
Machnicki, Michal
Wu, Min Yi
Baer, Nathan A.
Belda-Ferre, Pedro
Hoff, Peter De
Seaver, Phoebe
Ostrander, R. Tyler
Tsai, Rebecca
Sathe, Shashank
Aigner, Stefan
Morgan, Sydney C.
Ngo, Toan T.
Barber, Tom
Cheung, Willi
Carlin, Aaron F.
Yeo, Gene W.
Laurent, Louise C.
Fielding-Miller, Rebecca
Knight, Rob
author_sort Salido, Rodolfo A.
collection PubMed
description Environmental monitoring in public spaces can be used to identify surfaces contaminated by persons with COVID-19 and inform appropriate infection mitigation responses. Research groups have reported detection of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) on surfaces days or weeks after the virus has been deposited, making it difficult to estimate when an infected individual may have shed virus onto a SARS-CoV-2 positive surface, which in turn complicates the process of establishing effective quarantine measures. In this study, we determined that reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) detection of viral RNA from heat-inactivated particles experiences minimal decay over seven days of monitoring on eight out of nine surfaces tested. The properties of the studied surfaces result in RT-qPCR signatures that can be segregated into two material categories, rough and smooth, where smooth surfaces have a lower limit of detection. RT-qPCR signal intensity (average quantification cycle (Cq)) can be correlated to surface viral load using only one linear regression model per material category. The same experiment was performed with infectious viral particles on one surface from each category, with essentially identical results. The stability of RT-qPCR viral signal demonstrates the need to clean monitored surfaces after sampling to establish temporal resolution. Additionally, these findings can be used to minimize the number of materials and time points tested and allow for the use of heat-inactivated viral particles when optimizing environmental monitoring methods.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8312891
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-83128912021-07-27 Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence Salido, Rodolfo A. Cantú, Victor J. Clark, Alex E. Leibel, Sandra L. Foroughishafiei, Anahid Saha, Anushka Hakim, Abbas Nouri, Alhakam Lastrella, Alma L. Castro-Martínez, Anelizze Plascencia, Ashley Kapadia, Bhavika Xia, Bing Ruiz, Christopher Marotz, Clarisse A. Maunder, Daniel Lawrence, Elijah S. Smoot, Elizabeth W. Eisner, Emily Crescini, Evelyn S. Kohn, Laura Vargas, Lizbeth Franco Chacón, Marisol Betty, Maryann Machnicki, Michal Wu, Min Yi Baer, Nathan A. Belda-Ferre, Pedro Hoff, Peter De Seaver, Phoebe Ostrander, R. Tyler Tsai, Rebecca Sathe, Shashank Aigner, Stefan Morgan, Sydney C. Ngo, Toan T. Barber, Tom Cheung, Willi Carlin, Aaron F. Yeo, Gene W. Laurent, Louise C. Fielding-Miller, Rebecca Knight, Rob bioRxiv Article Environmental monitoring in public spaces can be used to identify surfaces contaminated by persons with COVID-19 and inform appropriate infection mitigation responses. Research groups have reported detection of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) on surfaces days or weeks after the virus has been deposited, making it difficult to estimate when an infected individual may have shed virus onto a SARS-CoV-2 positive surface, which in turn complicates the process of establishing effective quarantine measures. In this study, we determined that reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) detection of viral RNA from heat-inactivated particles experiences minimal decay over seven days of monitoring on eight out of nine surfaces tested. The properties of the studied surfaces result in RT-qPCR signatures that can be segregated into two material categories, rough and smooth, where smooth surfaces have a lower limit of detection. RT-qPCR signal intensity (average quantification cycle (Cq)) can be correlated to surface viral load using only one linear regression model per material category. The same experiment was performed with infectious viral particles on one surface from each category, with essentially identical results. The stability of RT-qPCR viral signal demonstrates the need to clean monitored surfaces after sampling to establish temporal resolution. Additionally, these findings can be used to minimize the number of materials and time points tested and allow for the use of heat-inactivated viral particles when optimizing environmental monitoring methods. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory 2021-07-19 /pmc/articles/PMC8312891/ /pubmed/34312621 http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/2021.07.16.452756 Text en https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) , which allows reusers to copy and distribute the material in any medium or format in unadapted form only, for noncommercial purposes only, and only so long as attribution is given to the creator.
spellingShingle Article
Salido, Rodolfo A.
Cantú, Victor J.
Clark, Alex E.
Leibel, Sandra L.
Foroughishafiei, Anahid
Saha, Anushka
Hakim, Abbas
Nouri, Alhakam
Lastrella, Alma L.
Castro-Martínez, Anelizze
Plascencia, Ashley
Kapadia, Bhavika
Xia, Bing
Ruiz, Christopher
Marotz, Clarisse A.
Maunder, Daniel
Lawrence, Elijah S.
Smoot, Elizabeth W.
Eisner, Emily
Crescini, Evelyn S.
Kohn, Laura
Vargas, Lizbeth Franco
Chacón, Marisol
Betty, Maryann
Machnicki, Michal
Wu, Min Yi
Baer, Nathan A.
Belda-Ferre, Pedro
Hoff, Peter De
Seaver, Phoebe
Ostrander, R. Tyler
Tsai, Rebecca
Sathe, Shashank
Aigner, Stefan
Morgan, Sydney C.
Ngo, Toan T.
Barber, Tom
Cheung, Willi
Carlin, Aaron F.
Yeo, Gene W.
Laurent, Louise C.
Fielding-Miller, Rebecca
Knight, Rob
Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence
title Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence
title_full Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence
title_fullStr Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence
title_full_unstemmed Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence
title_short Comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious SARS-CoV-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable RT-qPCR viral signal intensity and persistence
title_sort comparison of heat-inactivated and infectious sars-cov-2 across indoor surface materials shows comparable rt-qpcr viral signal intensity and persistence
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8312891/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34312621
http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/2021.07.16.452756
work_keys_str_mv AT salidorodolfoa comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT cantuvictorj comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT clarkalexe comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT leibelsandral comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT foroughishafieianahid comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT sahaanushka comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT hakimabbas comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT nourialhakam comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT lastrellaalmal comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT castromartinezanelizze comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT plascenciaashley comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT kapadiabhavika comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT xiabing comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT ruizchristopher comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT marotzclarissea comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT maunderdaniel comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT lawrenceelijahs comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT smootelizabethw comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT eisneremily comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT crescinievelyns comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT kohnlaura comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT vargaslizbethfranco comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT chaconmarisol comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT bettymaryann comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT machnickimichal comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT wuminyi comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT baernathana comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT beldaferrepedro comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT hoffpeterde comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT seaverphoebe comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT ostranderrtyler comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT tsairebecca comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT satheshashank comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT aignerstefan comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT morgansydneyc comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT ngotoant comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT barbertom comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT cheungwilli comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT carlinaaronf comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT yeogenew comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT laurentlouisec comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT fieldingmillerrebecca comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence
AT knightrob comparisonofheatinactivatedandinfectioussarscov2acrossindoorsurfacematerialsshowscomparablertqpcrviralsignalintensityandpersistence