Cargando…
Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2
Introduction: The current coronavirus disease- 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has caused a sudden increase in pneumonia cases, with a case-fatality rate of 10.9% in Mexico. Two inpatient groups have been defined, with different clinical evolution: cases of severe pneumonia and those with life-threatening...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
American Society of Hematology
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8330259/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1182/blood-2020-140631 |
_version_ | 1783732672160333824 |
---|---|
author | Pérez-Jacobo, Fernando Villela, Luis Villela Velásquez-Vega, Edgar Hernández, Jesús Otañez, Melani Arellano-Mendoza, Mónica Sosa-Camas, Rosa Manríquez-Bonillas, Víctor Bejar-Cornejo, Rubén Pérez, Fausto Chávez-Ochoa, Joanna Ramos-Vadillo, Bernardo Limón-Palafox, Mabel Jacobo-López, Karen Vázquez Hernández, Alondra Rosales Del Real, Ofelia Mondragón-Posadas, Lidia Pérez De la O, Alma Rodríguez-Morales, Pablo Millán Cureño, Ma. Luisa Gómez Meza, Martha Padilla-Ibarra, Cecilia Soto-Gaxiola, Alan Melgoza-Gonzáles, Edgar Hinojosa-Trujillo, Diana Reyes-Jiménez, Emilio Serrato-Félix, Marcos Martínez Arredondo, Hilario Lehmann Mendoza, Rodolfo |
author_facet | Pérez-Jacobo, Fernando Villela, Luis Villela Velásquez-Vega, Edgar Hernández, Jesús Otañez, Melani Arellano-Mendoza, Mónica Sosa-Camas, Rosa Manríquez-Bonillas, Víctor Bejar-Cornejo, Rubén Pérez, Fausto Chávez-Ochoa, Joanna Ramos-Vadillo, Bernardo Limón-Palafox, Mabel Jacobo-López, Karen Vázquez Hernández, Alondra Rosales Del Real, Ofelia Mondragón-Posadas, Lidia Pérez De la O, Alma Rodríguez-Morales, Pablo Millán Cureño, Ma. Luisa Gómez Meza, Martha Padilla-Ibarra, Cecilia Soto-Gaxiola, Alan Melgoza-Gonzáles, Edgar Hinojosa-Trujillo, Diana Reyes-Jiménez, Emilio Serrato-Félix, Marcos Martínez Arredondo, Hilario Lehmann Mendoza, Rodolfo |
author_sort | Pérez-Jacobo, Fernando |
collection | PubMed |
description | Introduction: The current coronavirus disease- 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has caused a sudden increase in pneumonia cases, with a case-fatality rate of 10.9% in Mexico. Two inpatient groups have been defined, with different clinical evolution: cases of severe pneumonia and those with life-threatening disease (Acute respiratory distress syndrome [ARDS], invasive mechanical ventilation [IMV] requirement, and multiorgan involvement). Currently, there is no effective treatment. Convalescent plasma (CP) has been used to treat another viral infections and outbreaks since the last century. The rationale is that neutralizing antibodies contained in CP suppress viremia and produce immunoregulation. However, an established therapeutic dose during this pandemic is lacking. Aim: To evaluate in a phase I trial the minimum effective dose of CP in severe and life-threatening disease patients and then carry out a phase II study to establish the effectiveness (overall survival at 30 days) comparing it with a non-randomized control group. Methods and design. Our study is an open-label, multicenter, non-randomized and started in May, 2020 and was approved by the ethics committee at HGE & HCN Pemex; respectively. CP donor selection: pre-donors who were infected by SARS-CoV-2 were evaluated on +30 day by serum titration (≥1:320 IgG antibody); then connected to apheresis machine to obtain 600 ml of CP that were fractionated in 200 ml bags and stored. Patients: Two groups were formed: severe and life-threating disease. CP was offered to patients who were admitted on two hospitals. Patients should meet the following criteria: SARS-CoV-2 positive for qRT- PCR, respiratory rate> 30 per minute or Kirby index <300 or IMV requirement; be older than 18 years; and sign the informed consent. Statistics: For demographic variables, the differences were evaluated with parametric or non-parametric analysis. For survival, Kaplan Meier curves were assessed for each group. A p value <0.05 was considered significant. Outcomes: A total of 110 CP bags have been transfused. The median serum IgG antibody titers were 1: 960. Dosing, phase 1. Severe group (n=14): 71% received two CP bags (400 ml) and 29% three CP bags (600 mL). Life-threatening disease group (n=10): 60% received 4 CP bags (800 ml) and 40% 3 CP bags (600 ml). Dose was established at 400 ml for the severe group and 800 ml for the life-threatening group. Security: CP infusions were well tolerated, with only 3 adverse events (2.72%) reported: one case of transfusion associated circulatory overload (TACO) that resolved with the use of loop diuretics as a serious adverse event; one fever episode (grade 1) and one case of rash (grade 1) after CP infusion. Phase II: The calculated n to be included in each arm (severe vs. life-threatening disease) is 68 and 52 patients, respectively. So far, we have included a total of 42 patients treated with CP. This entire cohort was compared with a historic group of COVID-19 patients who received other treatment strategies. Clinical characteristics on both plasma (PG) and control group (CG) are presented in table 1. We observed statistically significant differences on smoking habit, D-Dimer levels and ARDS severity between groups. The median overall follow- up was 24 days [PG 28 days vs. CG 21.5 days]. Overall Survival (OS) between PG and CG was 74% vs. 54% at 30-days respectively [HR=0.43 (C.I.95%=0.23 to 0.91, p=0.021); figure 1]. We analyzed OS by group stratification: COVID-19 severity (severe disease vs. life-threatening disease) and ARDS severity. We found no difference in OS between severe disease-PG and severe disease-CG; but we observed an OS difference between life-threatening-PG and life-threatening-CG [32% vs. 5.8% at 30-days; p=0.003]. ARDS-PG vs. ARDS-CG showed OS differences in moderate [59% vs. 25% at 30 days; p=0.01, respectively] and severe ARDS [63% vs. 0%; p=0.001, respectively]; however, there was not statistically significant difference between mild ARDS-PG and CG groups [89% vs. 86%; p=0.85, respectively]. Conclusion: This is the first phase I trial aiming to establish an effective CP dose for COVID-19 patients, at least in México. For severe and life-threatening disease, 2 and 4 CP bags were suggested. This treatment was secure, with <3% of adverse events reported. OS could be modified using certain doses based on disease severity and pa02/Fi02 index. We will continue to include patients until the calculated n is reached. [Figure: see text] DISCLOSURES: Villela:Roche: Other: advisory board, Speakers Bureau; amgen: Speakers Bureau. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8330259 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | American Society of Hematology |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-83302592021-08-03 Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 Pérez-Jacobo, Fernando Villela, Luis Villela Velásquez-Vega, Edgar Hernández, Jesús Otañez, Melani Arellano-Mendoza, Mónica Sosa-Camas, Rosa Manríquez-Bonillas, Víctor Bejar-Cornejo, Rubén Pérez, Fausto Chávez-Ochoa, Joanna Ramos-Vadillo, Bernardo Limón-Palafox, Mabel Jacobo-López, Karen Vázquez Hernández, Alondra Rosales Del Real, Ofelia Mondragón-Posadas, Lidia Pérez De la O, Alma Rodríguez-Morales, Pablo Millán Cureño, Ma. Luisa Gómez Meza, Martha Padilla-Ibarra, Cecilia Soto-Gaxiola, Alan Melgoza-Gonzáles, Edgar Hinojosa-Trujillo, Diana Reyes-Jiménez, Emilio Serrato-Félix, Marcos Martínez Arredondo, Hilario Lehmann Mendoza, Rodolfo Blood 401.Basic Science and Clinical Practice in Blood Transfusion Introduction: The current coronavirus disease- 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has caused a sudden increase in pneumonia cases, with a case-fatality rate of 10.9% in Mexico. Two inpatient groups have been defined, with different clinical evolution: cases of severe pneumonia and those with life-threatening disease (Acute respiratory distress syndrome [ARDS], invasive mechanical ventilation [IMV] requirement, and multiorgan involvement). Currently, there is no effective treatment. Convalescent plasma (CP) has been used to treat another viral infections and outbreaks since the last century. The rationale is that neutralizing antibodies contained in CP suppress viremia and produce immunoregulation. However, an established therapeutic dose during this pandemic is lacking. Aim: To evaluate in a phase I trial the minimum effective dose of CP in severe and life-threatening disease patients and then carry out a phase II study to establish the effectiveness (overall survival at 30 days) comparing it with a non-randomized control group. Methods and design. Our study is an open-label, multicenter, non-randomized and started in May, 2020 and was approved by the ethics committee at HGE & HCN Pemex; respectively. CP donor selection: pre-donors who were infected by SARS-CoV-2 were evaluated on +30 day by serum titration (≥1:320 IgG antibody); then connected to apheresis machine to obtain 600 ml of CP that were fractionated in 200 ml bags and stored. Patients: Two groups were formed: severe and life-threating disease. CP was offered to patients who were admitted on two hospitals. Patients should meet the following criteria: SARS-CoV-2 positive for qRT- PCR, respiratory rate> 30 per minute or Kirby index <300 or IMV requirement; be older than 18 years; and sign the informed consent. Statistics: For demographic variables, the differences were evaluated with parametric or non-parametric analysis. For survival, Kaplan Meier curves were assessed for each group. A p value <0.05 was considered significant. Outcomes: A total of 110 CP bags have been transfused. The median serum IgG antibody titers were 1: 960. Dosing, phase 1. Severe group (n=14): 71% received two CP bags (400 ml) and 29% three CP bags (600 mL). Life-threatening disease group (n=10): 60% received 4 CP bags (800 ml) and 40% 3 CP bags (600 ml). Dose was established at 400 ml for the severe group and 800 ml for the life-threatening group. Security: CP infusions were well tolerated, with only 3 adverse events (2.72%) reported: one case of transfusion associated circulatory overload (TACO) that resolved with the use of loop diuretics as a serious adverse event; one fever episode (grade 1) and one case of rash (grade 1) after CP infusion. Phase II: The calculated n to be included in each arm (severe vs. life-threatening disease) is 68 and 52 patients, respectively. So far, we have included a total of 42 patients treated with CP. This entire cohort was compared with a historic group of COVID-19 patients who received other treatment strategies. Clinical characteristics on both plasma (PG) and control group (CG) are presented in table 1. We observed statistically significant differences on smoking habit, D-Dimer levels and ARDS severity between groups. The median overall follow- up was 24 days [PG 28 days vs. CG 21.5 days]. Overall Survival (OS) between PG and CG was 74% vs. 54% at 30-days respectively [HR=0.43 (C.I.95%=0.23 to 0.91, p=0.021); figure 1]. We analyzed OS by group stratification: COVID-19 severity (severe disease vs. life-threatening disease) and ARDS severity. We found no difference in OS between severe disease-PG and severe disease-CG; but we observed an OS difference between life-threatening-PG and life-threatening-CG [32% vs. 5.8% at 30-days; p=0.003]. ARDS-PG vs. ARDS-CG showed OS differences in moderate [59% vs. 25% at 30 days; p=0.01, respectively] and severe ARDS [63% vs. 0%; p=0.001, respectively]; however, there was not statistically significant difference between mild ARDS-PG and CG groups [89% vs. 86%; p=0.85, respectively]. Conclusion: This is the first phase I trial aiming to establish an effective CP dose for COVID-19 patients, at least in México. For severe and life-threatening disease, 2 and 4 CP bags were suggested. This treatment was secure, with <3% of adverse events reported. OS could be modified using certain doses based on disease severity and pa02/Fi02 index. We will continue to include patients until the calculated n is reached. [Figure: see text] DISCLOSURES: Villela:Roche: Other: advisory board, Speakers Bureau; amgen: Speakers Bureau. American Society of Hematology 2020-11-05 2021-08-03 /pmc/articles/PMC8330259/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1182/blood-2020-140631 Text en Copyright © 2020 American Society of Hematology. Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website. Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active. |
spellingShingle | 401.Basic Science and Clinical Practice in Blood Transfusion Pérez-Jacobo, Fernando Villela, Luis Villela Velásquez-Vega, Edgar Hernández, Jesús Otañez, Melani Arellano-Mendoza, Mónica Sosa-Camas, Rosa Manríquez-Bonillas, Víctor Bejar-Cornejo, Rubén Pérez, Fausto Chávez-Ochoa, Joanna Ramos-Vadillo, Bernardo Limón-Palafox, Mabel Jacobo-López, Karen Vázquez Hernández, Alondra Rosales Del Real, Ofelia Mondragón-Posadas, Lidia Pérez De la O, Alma Rodríguez-Morales, Pablo Millán Cureño, Ma. Luisa Gómez Meza, Martha Padilla-Ibarra, Cecilia Soto-Gaxiola, Alan Melgoza-Gonzáles, Edgar Hinojosa-Trujillo, Diana Reyes-Jiménez, Emilio Serrato-Félix, Marcos Martínez Arredondo, Hilario Lehmann Mendoza, Rodolfo Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 |
title | Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 |
title_full | Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 |
title_fullStr | Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 |
title_full_unstemmed | Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 |
title_short | Phase I and Preliminary Results of a Phase II Study (TERAPLASCoV2) of Convalescent Plasma in Patients with Severe and Life-Threatening Pneumonia Caused By Sars-Cov-2 |
title_sort | phase i and preliminary results of a phase ii study (teraplascov2) of convalescent plasma in patients with severe and life-threatening pneumonia caused by sars-cov-2 |
topic | 401.Basic Science and Clinical Practice in Blood Transfusion |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8330259/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1182/blood-2020-140631 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT perezjacobofernando phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT villelaluisvillela phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT velasquezvegaedgar phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT hernandezjesus phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT otanezmelani phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT arellanomendozamonica phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT sosacamasrosa phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT manriquezbonillasvictor phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT bejarcornejoruben phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT perezfausto phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT chavezochoajoanna phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT ramosvadillobernardo phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT limonpalafoxmabel phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT jacobolopezkaren phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT vazquezhernandezalondra phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT rosalesdelrealofelia phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT mondragonposadaslidia phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT perezdelaoalma phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT rodriguezmoralespablo phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT millancurenomaluisa phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT gomezmezamartha phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT padillaibarracecilia phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT sotogaxiolaalan phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT melgozagonzalesedgar phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT hinojosatrujillodiana phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT reyesjimenezemilio phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT serratofelixmarcos phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT martinezarredondohilario phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 AT lehmannmendozarodolfo phaseiandpreliminaryresultsofaphaseiistudyteraplascov2ofconvalescentplasmainpatientswithsevereandlifethreateningpneumoniacausedbysarscov2 |