Cargando…
Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations
BACKGROUND: Molecular tumor boards (MTBs) provide rational, genomics‐driven, patient‐tailored treatment recommendations. Worldwide, MTBs differ in terms of scope, composition, methods, and recommendations. This study aimed to assess differences in methods and agreement in treatment recommendations a...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8342588/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33111480 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/onco.13580 |
_version_ | 1783734102424289280 |
---|---|
author | Koopman, Bart Groen, Harry J.M. Ligtenberg, Marjolijn J.L. Grünberg, Katrien Monkhorst, Kim de Langen, Adrianus J. Boelens, Mirjam C. Paats, Marthe S. von der Thüsen, Jan H. Dinjens, Winand N.M. Solleveld, Nienke van Wezel, Tom Gelderblom, Hans Hendriks, Lizza E. Speel, Ernst‐Jan M. Theunissen, Tom E. Kroeze, Leonie I. Mehra, Niven Piet, Berber van der Wekken, Anthonie J. ter Elst, Arja Timens, Wim Willems, Stefan M. Meijers, Ruud W.J. de Leng, Wendy W.J. van Lindert, Anne S.R. Radonic, Teodora Hashemi, Sayed M.S. Heideman, Daniëlle A.M. Schuuring, Ed van Kempen, Léon C. |
author_facet | Koopman, Bart Groen, Harry J.M. Ligtenberg, Marjolijn J.L. Grünberg, Katrien Monkhorst, Kim de Langen, Adrianus J. Boelens, Mirjam C. Paats, Marthe S. von der Thüsen, Jan H. Dinjens, Winand N.M. Solleveld, Nienke van Wezel, Tom Gelderblom, Hans Hendriks, Lizza E. Speel, Ernst‐Jan M. Theunissen, Tom E. Kroeze, Leonie I. Mehra, Niven Piet, Berber van der Wekken, Anthonie J. ter Elst, Arja Timens, Wim Willems, Stefan M. Meijers, Ruud W.J. de Leng, Wendy W.J. van Lindert, Anne S.R. Radonic, Teodora Hashemi, Sayed M.S. Heideman, Daniëlle A.M. Schuuring, Ed van Kempen, Léon C. |
author_sort | Koopman, Bart |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Molecular tumor boards (MTBs) provide rational, genomics‐driven, patient‐tailored treatment recommendations. Worldwide, MTBs differ in terms of scope, composition, methods, and recommendations. This study aimed to assess differences in methods and agreement in treatment recommendations among MTBs from tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands. MATERIALS AND METHODS: MTBs from all tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands were invited to participate. A survey assessing scope, value, logistics, composition, decision‐making method, reporting, and registration of the MTBs was completed through on‐site interviews with members from each MTB. Targeted therapy recommendations were compared using 10 anonymized cases. Participating MTBs were asked to provide a treatment recommendation in accordance with their own methods. Agreement was based on which molecular alteration(s) was considered actionable with the next line of targeted therapy. RESULTS: Interviews with 24 members of eight MTBs revealed that all participating MTBs focused on rare or complex mutational cancer profiles, operated independently of cancer type–specific multidisciplinary teams, and consisted of at least (thoracic and/or medical) oncologists, pathologists, and clinical scientists in molecular pathology. Differences were the types of cancer discussed and the methods used to achieve a recommendation. Nevertheless, agreement among MTB recommendations, based on identified actionable molecular alteration(s), was high for the 10 evaluated cases (86%). CONCLUSION: MTBs associated with tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands are similar in setup and reach a high agreement in recommendations for rare or complex mutational cancer profiles. We propose a “Dutch MTB model” for an optimal, collaborative, and nationally aligned MTB workflow. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Interpretation of genomic analyses for optimal choice of target therapy for patients with cancer is becoming increasingly complex. A molecular tumor board (MTB) supports oncologists in rationalizing therapy options. However, there is no consensus on the most optimal setup for an MTB, which can affect the quality of recommendations. This study reveals that the eight MTBs associated with tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands are similar in setup and reach a high agreement in recommendations for rare or complex mutational profiles. The Dutch MTB model is based on a collaborative and nationally aligned workflow with interinstitutional collaboration and data sharing. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8342588 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | John Wiley & Sons, Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-83425882021-08-11 Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations Koopman, Bart Groen, Harry J.M. Ligtenberg, Marjolijn J.L. Grünberg, Katrien Monkhorst, Kim de Langen, Adrianus J. Boelens, Mirjam C. Paats, Marthe S. von der Thüsen, Jan H. Dinjens, Winand N.M. Solleveld, Nienke van Wezel, Tom Gelderblom, Hans Hendriks, Lizza E. Speel, Ernst‐Jan M. Theunissen, Tom E. Kroeze, Leonie I. Mehra, Niven Piet, Berber van der Wekken, Anthonie J. ter Elst, Arja Timens, Wim Willems, Stefan M. Meijers, Ruud W.J. de Leng, Wendy W.J. van Lindert, Anne S.R. Radonic, Teodora Hashemi, Sayed M.S. Heideman, Daniëlle A.M. Schuuring, Ed van Kempen, Léon C. Oncologist Cancer Diagnostics and Molecular Pathology BACKGROUND: Molecular tumor boards (MTBs) provide rational, genomics‐driven, patient‐tailored treatment recommendations. Worldwide, MTBs differ in terms of scope, composition, methods, and recommendations. This study aimed to assess differences in methods and agreement in treatment recommendations among MTBs from tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands. MATERIALS AND METHODS: MTBs from all tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands were invited to participate. A survey assessing scope, value, logistics, composition, decision‐making method, reporting, and registration of the MTBs was completed through on‐site interviews with members from each MTB. Targeted therapy recommendations were compared using 10 anonymized cases. Participating MTBs were asked to provide a treatment recommendation in accordance with their own methods. Agreement was based on which molecular alteration(s) was considered actionable with the next line of targeted therapy. RESULTS: Interviews with 24 members of eight MTBs revealed that all participating MTBs focused on rare or complex mutational cancer profiles, operated independently of cancer type–specific multidisciplinary teams, and consisted of at least (thoracic and/or medical) oncologists, pathologists, and clinical scientists in molecular pathology. Differences were the types of cancer discussed and the methods used to achieve a recommendation. Nevertheless, agreement among MTB recommendations, based on identified actionable molecular alteration(s), was high for the 10 evaluated cases (86%). CONCLUSION: MTBs associated with tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands are similar in setup and reach a high agreement in recommendations for rare or complex mutational cancer profiles. We propose a “Dutch MTB model” for an optimal, collaborative, and nationally aligned MTB workflow. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Interpretation of genomic analyses for optimal choice of target therapy for patients with cancer is becoming increasingly complex. A molecular tumor board (MTB) supports oncologists in rationalizing therapy options. However, there is no consensus on the most optimal setup for an MTB, which can affect the quality of recommendations. This study reveals that the eight MTBs associated with tertiary cancer referral centers in The Netherlands are similar in setup and reach a high agreement in recommendations for rare or complex mutational profiles. The Dutch MTB model is based on a collaborative and nationally aligned workflow with interinstitutional collaboration and data sharing. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2020-11-10 2021-08 /pmc/articles/PMC8342588/ /pubmed/33111480 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/onco.13580 Text en © 2020 The Authors. The Oncologist published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of AlphaMed Press. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made. |
spellingShingle | Cancer Diagnostics and Molecular Pathology Koopman, Bart Groen, Harry J.M. Ligtenberg, Marjolijn J.L. Grünberg, Katrien Monkhorst, Kim de Langen, Adrianus J. Boelens, Mirjam C. Paats, Marthe S. von der Thüsen, Jan H. Dinjens, Winand N.M. Solleveld, Nienke van Wezel, Tom Gelderblom, Hans Hendriks, Lizza E. Speel, Ernst‐Jan M. Theunissen, Tom E. Kroeze, Leonie I. Mehra, Niven Piet, Berber van der Wekken, Anthonie J. ter Elst, Arja Timens, Wim Willems, Stefan M. Meijers, Ruud W.J. de Leng, Wendy W.J. van Lindert, Anne S.R. Radonic, Teodora Hashemi, Sayed M.S. Heideman, Daniëlle A.M. Schuuring, Ed van Kempen, Léon C. Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations |
title | Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations |
title_full | Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations |
title_fullStr | Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations |
title_full_unstemmed | Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations |
title_short | Multicenter Comparison of Molecular Tumor Boards in The Netherlands: Definition, Composition, Methods, and Targeted Therapy Recommendations |
title_sort | multicenter comparison of molecular tumor boards in the netherlands: definition, composition, methods, and targeted therapy recommendations |
topic | Cancer Diagnostics and Molecular Pathology |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8342588/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33111480 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/onco.13580 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT koopmanbart multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT groenharryjm multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT ligtenbergmarjolijnjl multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT grunbergkatrien multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT monkhorstkim multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT delangenadrianusj multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT boelensmirjamc multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT paatsmarthes multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT vonderthusenjanh multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT dinjenswinandnm multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT solleveldnienke multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT vanwezeltom multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT gelderblomhans multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT hendrikslizzae multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT speelernstjanm multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT theunissentome multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT kroezeleoniei multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT mehraniven multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT pietberber multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT vanderwekkenanthoniej multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT terelstarja multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT timenswim multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT willemsstefanm multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT meijersruudwj multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT delengwendywj multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT vanlindertannesr multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT radonicteodora multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT hashemisayedms multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT heidemandanielleam multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT schuuringed multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations AT vankempenleonc multicentercomparisonofmoleculartumorboardsinthenetherlandsdefinitioncompositionmethodsandtargetedtherapyrecommendations |