Cargando…

A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Dosiomics is born directly as an extension of radiomics: it entails extracting features from the patients’ three-dimensional (3D) radiotherapy dose distribution rather than from conventional medical images to obtain specific spatial and statistical information. Dosiomic studies, in a...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Placidi, Lorenzo, Gioscio, Eliana, Garibaldi, Cristina, Rancati, Tiziana, Fanizzi, Annarita, Maestri, Davide, Massafra, Raffaella, Menghi, Enrico, Mirandola, Alfredo, Reggiori, Giacomo, Sghedoni, Roberto, Tamborra, Pasquale, Comi, Stefania, Lenkowicz, Jacopo, Boldrini, Luca, Avanzo, Michele
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8345157/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34359737
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13153835
_version_ 1783734562672607232
author Placidi, Lorenzo
Gioscio, Eliana
Garibaldi, Cristina
Rancati, Tiziana
Fanizzi, Annarita
Maestri, Davide
Massafra, Raffaella
Menghi, Enrico
Mirandola, Alfredo
Reggiori, Giacomo
Sghedoni, Roberto
Tamborra, Pasquale
Comi, Stefania
Lenkowicz, Jacopo
Boldrini, Luca
Avanzo, Michele
author_facet Placidi, Lorenzo
Gioscio, Eliana
Garibaldi, Cristina
Rancati, Tiziana
Fanizzi, Annarita
Maestri, Davide
Massafra, Raffaella
Menghi, Enrico
Mirandola, Alfredo
Reggiori, Giacomo
Sghedoni, Roberto
Tamborra, Pasquale
Comi, Stefania
Lenkowicz, Jacopo
Boldrini, Luca
Avanzo, Michele
author_sort Placidi, Lorenzo
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Dosiomics is born directly as an extension of radiomics: it entails extracting features from the patients’ three-dimensional (3D) radiotherapy dose distribution rather than from conventional medical images to obtain specific spatial and statistical information. Dosiomic studies, in a multicentre setting, require assessing the features’ stability to dose calculation settings and the features’ capability in distinguishing different dose distributions. This study provides the first multicentre evaluation of the dosiomic features in terms of reproducibility, stability and sensitivity across various dose distributions obtained from multiple technologies and techniques and considering different dose calculation algorithms of TPS and two different resolutions of the dose grid. Harmonisation strategies to account for a possible variation in the dose distribution due to these confounding factors should be adopted when investigating a correlation between dosiomic features and clinical outcomes in multicentre studies. ABSTRACT: Dosiomics is a texture analysis method to produce dose features that encode the spatial 3D distribution of radiotherapy dose. Dosiomic studies, in a multicentre setting, require assessing the features’ stability to dose calculation settings and the features’ capability in distinguishing different dose distributions. Dose distributions were generated by eight Italian centres on a shared image dataset acquired on a dedicated phantom. Treatment planning protocols, in terms of planning target volume coverage and dose–volume constraints to the organs at risk, were shared among the centres to produce comparable dose distributions for measuring reproducibility/stability and sensitivity of dosiomic features. In addition, coefficient of variation (CV) was employed to evaluate the dosiomic features’ variation. We extracted 38,160 features from 30 different dose distributions from six regions of interest, grouped by four features’ families. A selected group of features (CV < 3 for the reproducibility/stability studies, CV > 1 for the sensitivity studies) were identified to support future multicentre studies, assuring both stable features when dose distributions variation is minimal and sensitive features when dose distribution variations need to be clearly identified. Dosiomic is a promising tool that could support multicentre studies, especially for predictive models, and encode the spatial and statistical characteristics of the 3D dose distribution.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8345157
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-83451572021-08-07 A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity Placidi, Lorenzo Gioscio, Eliana Garibaldi, Cristina Rancati, Tiziana Fanizzi, Annarita Maestri, Davide Massafra, Raffaella Menghi, Enrico Mirandola, Alfredo Reggiori, Giacomo Sghedoni, Roberto Tamborra, Pasquale Comi, Stefania Lenkowicz, Jacopo Boldrini, Luca Avanzo, Michele Cancers (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Dosiomics is born directly as an extension of radiomics: it entails extracting features from the patients’ three-dimensional (3D) radiotherapy dose distribution rather than from conventional medical images to obtain specific spatial and statistical information. Dosiomic studies, in a multicentre setting, require assessing the features’ stability to dose calculation settings and the features’ capability in distinguishing different dose distributions. This study provides the first multicentre evaluation of the dosiomic features in terms of reproducibility, stability and sensitivity across various dose distributions obtained from multiple technologies and techniques and considering different dose calculation algorithms of TPS and two different resolutions of the dose grid. Harmonisation strategies to account for a possible variation in the dose distribution due to these confounding factors should be adopted when investigating a correlation between dosiomic features and clinical outcomes in multicentre studies. ABSTRACT: Dosiomics is a texture analysis method to produce dose features that encode the spatial 3D distribution of radiotherapy dose. Dosiomic studies, in a multicentre setting, require assessing the features’ stability to dose calculation settings and the features’ capability in distinguishing different dose distributions. Dose distributions were generated by eight Italian centres on a shared image dataset acquired on a dedicated phantom. Treatment planning protocols, in terms of planning target volume coverage and dose–volume constraints to the organs at risk, were shared among the centres to produce comparable dose distributions for measuring reproducibility/stability and sensitivity of dosiomic features. In addition, coefficient of variation (CV) was employed to evaluate the dosiomic features’ variation. We extracted 38,160 features from 30 different dose distributions from six regions of interest, grouped by four features’ families. A selected group of features (CV < 3 for the reproducibility/stability studies, CV > 1 for the sensitivity studies) were identified to support future multicentre studies, assuring both stable features when dose distributions variation is minimal and sensitive features when dose distribution variations need to be clearly identified. Dosiomic is a promising tool that could support multicentre studies, especially for predictive models, and encode the spatial and statistical characteristics of the 3D dose distribution. MDPI 2021-07-30 /pmc/articles/PMC8345157/ /pubmed/34359737 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13153835 Text en © 2021 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Placidi, Lorenzo
Gioscio, Eliana
Garibaldi, Cristina
Rancati, Tiziana
Fanizzi, Annarita
Maestri, Davide
Massafra, Raffaella
Menghi, Enrico
Mirandola, Alfredo
Reggiori, Giacomo
Sghedoni, Roberto
Tamborra, Pasquale
Comi, Stefania
Lenkowicz, Jacopo
Boldrini, Luca
Avanzo, Michele
A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity
title A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity
title_full A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity
title_fullStr A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity
title_full_unstemmed A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity
title_short A Multicentre Evaluation of Dosiomics Features Reproducibility, Stability and Sensitivity
title_sort multicentre evaluation of dosiomics features reproducibility, stability and sensitivity
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8345157/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34359737
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13153835
work_keys_str_mv AT placidilorenzo amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT gioscioeliana amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT garibaldicristina amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT rancatitiziana amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT fanizziannarita amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT maestridavide amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT massafraraffaella amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT menghienrico amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT mirandolaalfredo amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT reggiorigiacomo amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT sghedoniroberto amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT tamborrapasquale amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT comistefania amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT lenkowiczjacopo amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT boldriniluca amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT avanzomichele amulticentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT placidilorenzo multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT gioscioeliana multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT garibaldicristina multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT rancatitiziana multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT fanizziannarita multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT maestridavide multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT massafraraffaella multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT menghienrico multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT mirandolaalfredo multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT reggiorigiacomo multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT sghedoniroberto multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT tamborrapasquale multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT comistefania multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT lenkowiczjacopo multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT boldriniluca multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity
AT avanzomichele multicentreevaluationofdosiomicsfeaturesreproducibilitystabilityandsensitivity