Cargando…
Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards
The ‘Sepsis Six’ bundle was promoted as a deliverable tool outside of the critical care settings, but there is very little data available on the progress and change of sepsis care outside the critical care environment in the UK. Our aim was to compare the yearly prevalence, outcome and the Sepsis Si...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Nature Publishing Group UK
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8355110/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34376757 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-95648-6 |
_version_ | 1783736705295056896 |
---|---|
author | Kopczynska, Maja Unwin, Harry Pugh, Richard J. Sharif, Ben Chandy, Thomas Davies, Daniel J. Shield, Matthew E. Purchase, David E. Tilley, Samuel C. Poacher, Arwel Oliva, Lewis Willis, Sam Ray, Isabelle E. Hui, John Ng C. Payne, Bethany C. Wardle, Eilis F. Andrew, Fiona Chan, Hei Man Priscilla Barrington, Jack Hale, Jay Hawkins, Joanna Nicholas, Jess K. Wirt, Lara E. Thomas, Lowri H. Walker, Megan Pan, Myat P. Ray, Tallulah Asim, Umair H. Maidman, Victoria Atiyah, Zeid Nasser, Zain M. Tan, Zhao Xuan Tan, Laura J. P. Szakmany, Tamas |
author_facet | Kopczynska, Maja Unwin, Harry Pugh, Richard J. Sharif, Ben Chandy, Thomas Davies, Daniel J. Shield, Matthew E. Purchase, David E. Tilley, Samuel C. Poacher, Arwel Oliva, Lewis Willis, Sam Ray, Isabelle E. Hui, John Ng C. Payne, Bethany C. Wardle, Eilis F. Andrew, Fiona Chan, Hei Man Priscilla Barrington, Jack Hale, Jay Hawkins, Joanna Nicholas, Jess K. Wirt, Lara E. Thomas, Lowri H. Walker, Megan Pan, Myat P. Ray, Tallulah Asim, Umair H. Maidman, Victoria Atiyah, Zeid Nasser, Zain M. Tan, Zhao Xuan Tan, Laura J. P. Szakmany, Tamas |
author_sort | Kopczynska, Maja |
collection | PubMed |
description | The ‘Sepsis Six’ bundle was promoted as a deliverable tool outside of the critical care settings, but there is very little data available on the progress and change of sepsis care outside the critical care environment in the UK. Our aim was to compare the yearly prevalence, outcome and the Sepsis Six bundle compliance in patients at risk of mortality from sepsis in non-intensive care environments. Patients with a National Early Warning Score (NEWS) of 3 or above and suspected or proven infection were enrolled into four yearly 24-h point prevalence studies, carried out in fourteen hospitals across Wales from 2016 to 2019. We followed up patients to 30 days between 2016–2019 and to 90 days between 2017 and 2019. Out of the 26,947 patients screened 1651 fulfilled inclusion criteria and were recruited. The full ‘Sepsis Six’ care bundle was completed on 223 (14.0%) occasions, with no significant difference between the years. On 190 (11.5%) occasions none of the bundle elements were completed. There was no significant correlation between bundle element compliance, NEWS or year of study. One hundred and seventy (10.7%) patients were seen by critical care outreach; the ‘Sepsis Six’ bundle was completed significantly more often in this group (54/170, 32.0%) than for patients who were not reviewed by critical care outreach (168/1385, 11.6%; p < 0.0001). Overall survival to 30 days was 81.7% (1349/1651), with a mean survival time of 26.5 days (95% CI 26.1–26.9) with no difference between each year of study. 90-day survival for years 2017–2019 was 74.7% (949/1271), with no difference between the years. In multivariate regression we identified older age, heart failure, recent chemotherapy, higher frailty score and do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation orders as significantly associated with increased 30-day mortality. Our data suggests that despite efforts to increase sepsis awareness within the NHS, there is poor compliance with the sepsis care bundles and no change in the high mortality over the study period. Further research is needed to determine which time-sensitive ward-based interventions can reduce mortality in patients with sepsis and how can these results be embedded to routine clinical practice. Trial registration Defining Sepsis on the Wards ISRCTN 86502304 https://doi.org/10.1186/ISRCTN86502304 prospectively registered 09/05/2016. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8355110 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Nature Publishing Group UK |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-83551102021-08-11 Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards Kopczynska, Maja Unwin, Harry Pugh, Richard J. Sharif, Ben Chandy, Thomas Davies, Daniel J. Shield, Matthew E. Purchase, David E. Tilley, Samuel C. Poacher, Arwel Oliva, Lewis Willis, Sam Ray, Isabelle E. Hui, John Ng C. Payne, Bethany C. Wardle, Eilis F. Andrew, Fiona Chan, Hei Man Priscilla Barrington, Jack Hale, Jay Hawkins, Joanna Nicholas, Jess K. Wirt, Lara E. Thomas, Lowri H. Walker, Megan Pan, Myat P. Ray, Tallulah Asim, Umair H. Maidman, Victoria Atiyah, Zeid Nasser, Zain M. Tan, Zhao Xuan Tan, Laura J. P. Szakmany, Tamas Sci Rep Article The ‘Sepsis Six’ bundle was promoted as a deliverable tool outside of the critical care settings, but there is very little data available on the progress and change of sepsis care outside the critical care environment in the UK. Our aim was to compare the yearly prevalence, outcome and the Sepsis Six bundle compliance in patients at risk of mortality from sepsis in non-intensive care environments. Patients with a National Early Warning Score (NEWS) of 3 or above and suspected or proven infection were enrolled into four yearly 24-h point prevalence studies, carried out in fourteen hospitals across Wales from 2016 to 2019. We followed up patients to 30 days between 2016–2019 and to 90 days between 2017 and 2019. Out of the 26,947 patients screened 1651 fulfilled inclusion criteria and were recruited. The full ‘Sepsis Six’ care bundle was completed on 223 (14.0%) occasions, with no significant difference between the years. On 190 (11.5%) occasions none of the bundle elements were completed. There was no significant correlation between bundle element compliance, NEWS or year of study. One hundred and seventy (10.7%) patients were seen by critical care outreach; the ‘Sepsis Six’ bundle was completed significantly more often in this group (54/170, 32.0%) than for patients who were not reviewed by critical care outreach (168/1385, 11.6%; p < 0.0001). Overall survival to 30 days was 81.7% (1349/1651), with a mean survival time of 26.5 days (95% CI 26.1–26.9) with no difference between each year of study. 90-day survival for years 2017–2019 was 74.7% (949/1271), with no difference between the years. In multivariate regression we identified older age, heart failure, recent chemotherapy, higher frailty score and do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation orders as significantly associated with increased 30-day mortality. Our data suggests that despite efforts to increase sepsis awareness within the NHS, there is poor compliance with the sepsis care bundles and no change in the high mortality over the study period. Further research is needed to determine which time-sensitive ward-based interventions can reduce mortality in patients with sepsis and how can these results be embedded to routine clinical practice. Trial registration Defining Sepsis on the Wards ISRCTN 86502304 https://doi.org/10.1186/ISRCTN86502304 prospectively registered 09/05/2016. Nature Publishing Group UK 2021-08-10 /pmc/articles/PMC8355110/ /pubmed/34376757 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-95648-6 Text en © The Author(s) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . |
spellingShingle | Article Kopczynska, Maja Unwin, Harry Pugh, Richard J. Sharif, Ben Chandy, Thomas Davies, Daniel J. Shield, Matthew E. Purchase, David E. Tilley, Samuel C. Poacher, Arwel Oliva, Lewis Willis, Sam Ray, Isabelle E. Hui, John Ng C. Payne, Bethany C. Wardle, Eilis F. Andrew, Fiona Chan, Hei Man Priscilla Barrington, Jack Hale, Jay Hawkins, Joanna Nicholas, Jess K. Wirt, Lara E. Thomas, Lowri H. Walker, Megan Pan, Myat P. Ray, Tallulah Asim, Umair H. Maidman, Victoria Atiyah, Zeid Nasser, Zain M. Tan, Zhao Xuan Tan, Laura J. P. Szakmany, Tamas Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
title | Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
title_full | Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
title_fullStr | Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
title_full_unstemmed | Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
title_short | Four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in Wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
title_sort | four consecutive yearly point-prevalence studies in wales indicate lack of improvement in sepsis care on the wards |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8355110/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34376757 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-95648-6 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT kopczynskamaja fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT unwinharry fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT pughrichardj fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT sharifben fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT chandythomas fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT daviesdanielj fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT shieldmatthewe fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT purchasedavide fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT tilleysamuelc fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT poacherarwel fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT olivalewis fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT willissam fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT rayisabellee fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT huijohnngc fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT paynebethanyc fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT wardleeilisf fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT andrewfiona fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT chanheimanpriscilla fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT barringtonjack fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT halejay fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT hawkinsjoanna fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT nicholasjessk fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT wirtlarae fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT thomaslowrih fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT walkermegan fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT panmyatp fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT raytallulah fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT asimumairh fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT maidmanvictoria fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT atiyahzeid fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT nasserzainm fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT tanzhaoxuan fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT tanlaurajp fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT szakmanytamas fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards AT fourconsecutiveyearlypointprevalencestudiesinwalesindicatelackofimprovementinsepsiscareonthewards |