Cargando…
A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities
As society has moved past the initial phase of the COVID-19 crisis that relied on broad-spectrum shutdowns as a stopgap method, industries and institutions have faced the daunting question of how to return to a stabilized state of activities and more fully reopen the economy. A core problem is how t...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8360595/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34383766 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254798 |
_version_ | 1783737776710090752 |
---|---|
author | Poole, Sarah F. Gronsbell, Jessica Winter, Dale Nickels, Stefanie Levy, Roie Fu, Bin Burq, Maximilien Saeb, Sohrab Edwards, Matthew D. Behr, Michael K. Kumaresan, Vignesh Macalalad, Alexander R. Shah, Sneh Prevost, Michelle Snoad, Nigel Brenner, Michael P. Myers, Lance J. Varghese, Paul Califf, Robert M. Washington, Vindell Lee, Vivian S. Fromer, Menachem |
author_facet | Poole, Sarah F. Gronsbell, Jessica Winter, Dale Nickels, Stefanie Levy, Roie Fu, Bin Burq, Maximilien Saeb, Sohrab Edwards, Matthew D. Behr, Michael K. Kumaresan, Vignesh Macalalad, Alexander R. Shah, Sneh Prevost, Michelle Snoad, Nigel Brenner, Michael P. Myers, Lance J. Varghese, Paul Califf, Robert M. Washington, Vindell Lee, Vivian S. Fromer, Menachem |
author_sort | Poole, Sarah F. |
collection | PubMed |
description | As society has moved past the initial phase of the COVID-19 crisis that relied on broad-spectrum shutdowns as a stopgap method, industries and institutions have faced the daunting question of how to return to a stabilized state of activities and more fully reopen the economy. A core problem is how to return people to their workplaces and educational institutions in a manner that is safe, ethical, grounded in science, and takes into account the unique factors and needs of each organization and community. In this paper, we introduce an epidemiological model (the “Community-Workplace” model) that accounts for SARS-CoV-2 transmission within the workplace, within the surrounding community, and between them. We use this multi-group deterministic compartmental model to consider various testing strategies that, together with symptom screening, exposure tracking, and nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPI) such as mask wearing and physical distancing, aim to reduce disease spread in the workplace. Our framework is designed to be adaptable to a variety of specific workplace environments to support planning efforts as reopenings continue. Using this model, we consider a number of case studies, including an office workplace, a factory floor, and a university campus. Analysis of these cases illustrates that continuous testing can help a workplace avoid an outbreak by reducing undetected infectiousness even in high-contact environments. We find that a university setting, where individuals spend more time on campus and have a higher contact load, requires more testing to remain safe, compared to a factory or office setting. Under the modeling assumptions, we find that maintaining a prevalence below 3% can be achieved in an office setting by testing its workforce every two weeks, whereas achieving this same goal for a university could require as much as fourfold more testing (i.e., testing the entire campus population twice a week). Our model also simulates the dynamics of reduced spread that result from the introduction of mitigation measures when test results reveal the early stages of a workplace outbreak. We use this to show that a vigilant university that has the ability to quickly react to outbreaks can be justified in implementing testing at the same rate as a lower-risk office workplace. Finally, we quantify the devastating impact that an outbreak in a small-town college could have on the surrounding community, which supports the notion that communities can be better protected by supporting their local places of business in preventing onsite spread of disease. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8360595 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-83605952021-08-13 A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities Poole, Sarah F. Gronsbell, Jessica Winter, Dale Nickels, Stefanie Levy, Roie Fu, Bin Burq, Maximilien Saeb, Sohrab Edwards, Matthew D. Behr, Michael K. Kumaresan, Vignesh Macalalad, Alexander R. Shah, Sneh Prevost, Michelle Snoad, Nigel Brenner, Michael P. Myers, Lance J. Varghese, Paul Califf, Robert M. Washington, Vindell Lee, Vivian S. Fromer, Menachem PLoS One Research Article As society has moved past the initial phase of the COVID-19 crisis that relied on broad-spectrum shutdowns as a stopgap method, industries and institutions have faced the daunting question of how to return to a stabilized state of activities and more fully reopen the economy. A core problem is how to return people to their workplaces and educational institutions in a manner that is safe, ethical, grounded in science, and takes into account the unique factors and needs of each organization and community. In this paper, we introduce an epidemiological model (the “Community-Workplace” model) that accounts for SARS-CoV-2 transmission within the workplace, within the surrounding community, and between them. We use this multi-group deterministic compartmental model to consider various testing strategies that, together with symptom screening, exposure tracking, and nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPI) such as mask wearing and physical distancing, aim to reduce disease spread in the workplace. Our framework is designed to be adaptable to a variety of specific workplace environments to support planning efforts as reopenings continue. Using this model, we consider a number of case studies, including an office workplace, a factory floor, and a university campus. Analysis of these cases illustrates that continuous testing can help a workplace avoid an outbreak by reducing undetected infectiousness even in high-contact environments. We find that a university setting, where individuals spend more time on campus and have a higher contact load, requires more testing to remain safe, compared to a factory or office setting. Under the modeling assumptions, we find that maintaining a prevalence below 3% can be achieved in an office setting by testing its workforce every two weeks, whereas achieving this same goal for a university could require as much as fourfold more testing (i.e., testing the entire campus population twice a week). Our model also simulates the dynamics of reduced spread that result from the introduction of mitigation measures when test results reveal the early stages of a workplace outbreak. We use this to show that a vigilant university that has the ability to quickly react to outbreaks can be justified in implementing testing at the same rate as a lower-risk office workplace. Finally, we quantify the devastating impact that an outbreak in a small-town college could have on the surrounding community, which supports the notion that communities can be better protected by supporting their local places of business in preventing onsite spread of disease. Public Library of Science 2021-08-12 /pmc/articles/PMC8360595/ /pubmed/34383766 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254798 Text en © 2021 Poole et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Poole, Sarah F. Gronsbell, Jessica Winter, Dale Nickels, Stefanie Levy, Roie Fu, Bin Burq, Maximilien Saeb, Sohrab Edwards, Matthew D. Behr, Michael K. Kumaresan, Vignesh Macalalad, Alexander R. Shah, Sneh Prevost, Michelle Snoad, Nigel Brenner, Michael P. Myers, Lance J. Varghese, Paul Califf, Robert M. Washington, Vindell Lee, Vivian S. Fromer, Menachem A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
title | A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
title_full | A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
title_fullStr | A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
title_full_unstemmed | A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
title_short | A holistic approach for suppression of COVID-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
title_sort | holistic approach for suppression of covid-19 spread in workplaces and universities |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8360595/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34383766 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254798 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT poolesarahf aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT gronsbelljessica aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT winterdale aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT nickelsstefanie aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT levyroie aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT fubin aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT burqmaximilien aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT saebsohrab aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT edwardsmatthewd aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT behrmichaelk aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT kumaresanvignesh aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT macalaladalexanderr aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT shahsneh aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT prevostmichelle aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT snoadnigel aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT brennermichaelp aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT myerslancej aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT varghesepaul aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT califfrobertm aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT washingtonvindell aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT leevivians aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT fromermenachem aholisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT poolesarahf holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT gronsbelljessica holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT winterdale holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT nickelsstefanie holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT levyroie holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT fubin holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT burqmaximilien holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT saebsohrab holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT edwardsmatthewd holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT behrmichaelk holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT kumaresanvignesh holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT macalaladalexanderr holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT shahsneh holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT prevostmichelle holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT snoadnigel holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT brennermichaelp holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT myerslancej holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT varghesepaul holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT califfrobertm holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT washingtonvindell holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT leevivians holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities AT fromermenachem holisticapproachforsuppressionofcovid19spreadinworkplacesanduniversities |