Cargando…
The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system
PURPOSE: Island blocking occurs in single‐isocenter multiple‐target (SIMT) stereotactic radiotherapy (SRS) whenever targets share multi‐leaf collimator (MLC) leaf pairs. This study investigated the effect on plan quality and delivery, of reducing island blocking through collimator angle optimization...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8425912/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34288376 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/acm2.13360 |
_version_ | 1783749938380800000 |
---|---|
author | Pudsey, Lauren M. M. Cutajar, Dean Wallace, Alex Saba, Anastasia Schmidt, Laurel Bece, Andrej Clark, Catherine Yamada, Yoshiya Biasi, Giordano Rosenfeld, Anatoly Poder, Joel |
author_facet | Pudsey, Lauren M. M. Cutajar, Dean Wallace, Alex Saba, Anastasia Schmidt, Laurel Bece, Andrej Clark, Catherine Yamada, Yoshiya Biasi, Giordano Rosenfeld, Anatoly Poder, Joel |
author_sort | Pudsey, Lauren M. M. |
collection | PubMed |
description | PURPOSE: Island blocking occurs in single‐isocenter multiple‐target (SIMT) stereotactic radiotherapy (SRS) whenever targets share multi‐leaf collimator (MLC) leaf pairs. This study investigated the effect on plan quality and delivery, of reducing island blocking through collimator angle optimization (CAO). In addition, the effect of jaw tracking in this context was also investigated. METHODS: For CAO, an algorithm was created that selects the collimator angle resulting in the lowest level of island blocking, for each beam in any given plan. Then, four volume‐modulated arc therapy (VMAT) SIMT SRS plans each were generated for 10 retrospective patients: two CAO plans, with and without jaw tracking, and two plans with manually selected collimator angles, with and without jaw tracking. Plans were then assessed and compared using typical quality assurance procedures. RESULTS: There were no substantial differences between plans with and without CAO. Jaw tracking produced statistically significant reduction in low‐dose level parameters; healthy brain V10% and mean dose were reduced by 9.66% and 15.58%, respectively. However, quantitative values (108 cc for V10% and 0.35 Gy for mean dose) were relatively small in relation to clinical relevance. Though there were no statistically significant changes in plan deliverability, there was a notable trend of plans with jaw tracking having lower gamma analysis pass rates. CONCLUSION: These findings suggest that CAO has limited benefit in VMAT SIMT SRS of 2–6 targets when using a low‐dose penalty to the healthy brain during plan optimization in Eclipse. As clinical benefits of jaw tracking were found to be minimal and plan deliverability was potentially reduced, a cautious approach would be to exclude jaw tracking in SIMT SRS plans. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8425912 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-84259122021-09-13 The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system Pudsey, Lauren M. M. Cutajar, Dean Wallace, Alex Saba, Anastasia Schmidt, Laurel Bece, Andrej Clark, Catherine Yamada, Yoshiya Biasi, Giordano Rosenfeld, Anatoly Poder, Joel J Appl Clin Med Phys Radiation Oncology Physics PURPOSE: Island blocking occurs in single‐isocenter multiple‐target (SIMT) stereotactic radiotherapy (SRS) whenever targets share multi‐leaf collimator (MLC) leaf pairs. This study investigated the effect on plan quality and delivery, of reducing island blocking through collimator angle optimization (CAO). In addition, the effect of jaw tracking in this context was also investigated. METHODS: For CAO, an algorithm was created that selects the collimator angle resulting in the lowest level of island blocking, for each beam in any given plan. Then, four volume‐modulated arc therapy (VMAT) SIMT SRS plans each were generated for 10 retrospective patients: two CAO plans, with and without jaw tracking, and two plans with manually selected collimator angles, with and without jaw tracking. Plans were then assessed and compared using typical quality assurance procedures. RESULTS: There were no substantial differences between plans with and without CAO. Jaw tracking produced statistically significant reduction in low‐dose level parameters; healthy brain V10% and mean dose were reduced by 9.66% and 15.58%, respectively. However, quantitative values (108 cc for V10% and 0.35 Gy for mean dose) were relatively small in relation to clinical relevance. Though there were no statistically significant changes in plan deliverability, there was a notable trend of plans with jaw tracking having lower gamma analysis pass rates. CONCLUSION: These findings suggest that CAO has limited benefit in VMAT SIMT SRS of 2–6 targets when using a low‐dose penalty to the healthy brain during plan optimization in Eclipse. As clinical benefits of jaw tracking were found to be minimal and plan deliverability was potentially reduced, a cautious approach would be to exclude jaw tracking in SIMT SRS plans. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021-07-19 /pmc/articles/PMC8425912/ /pubmed/34288376 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/acm2.13360 Text en © 2021 The Authors. Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of American Association of Physicists in Medicine. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Radiation Oncology Physics Pudsey, Lauren M. M. Cutajar, Dean Wallace, Alex Saba, Anastasia Schmidt, Laurel Bece, Andrej Clark, Catherine Yamada, Yoshiya Biasi, Giordano Rosenfeld, Anatoly Poder, Joel The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system |
title | The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system |
title_full | The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system |
title_fullStr | The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system |
title_full_unstemmed | The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system |
title_short | The use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for VMAT‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the Varian Eclipse treatment planning system |
title_sort | use of collimator angle optimization and jaw tracking for vmat‐based single‐isocenter multiple‐target stereotactic radiosurgery for up to six targets in the varian eclipse treatment planning system |
topic | Radiation Oncology Physics |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8425912/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34288376 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/acm2.13360 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT pudseylaurenmm theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT cutajardean theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT wallacealex theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT sabaanastasia theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT schmidtlaurel theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT beceandrej theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT clarkcatherine theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT yamadayoshiya theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT biasigiordano theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT rosenfeldanatoly theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT poderjoel theuseofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT pudseylaurenmm useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT cutajardean useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT wallacealex useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT sabaanastasia useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT schmidtlaurel useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT beceandrej useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT clarkcatherine useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT yamadayoshiya useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT biasigiordano useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT rosenfeldanatoly useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem AT poderjoel useofcollimatorangleoptimizationandjawtrackingforvmatbasedsingleisocentermultipletargetstereotacticradiosurgeryforuptosixtargetsinthevarianeclipsetreatmentplanningsystem |