Cargando…

A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis

This paper concerns a new methodology for accuracy assessment of GPS (Global Positioning System) verified experimentally with LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) data alignment at continent scale for autonomous driving safety analysis. Accuracy of an autonomous driving vehicle positioning within a l...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Bedkowski, Janusz, Nowak, Hubert, Kubiak, Blazej, Studzinski, Witold, Janeczek, Maciej, Karas, Szymon, Kopaczewski, Adam, Makosiej, Przemyslaw, Koszuk, Jaroslaw, Pec, Michal, Miksa, Krzysztof
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8434143/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34502581
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/s21175691
_version_ 1783751528602927104
author Bedkowski, Janusz
Nowak, Hubert
Kubiak, Blazej
Studzinski, Witold
Janeczek, Maciej
Karas, Szymon
Kopaczewski, Adam
Makosiej, Przemyslaw
Koszuk, Jaroslaw
Pec, Michal
Miksa, Krzysztof
author_facet Bedkowski, Janusz
Nowak, Hubert
Kubiak, Blazej
Studzinski, Witold
Janeczek, Maciej
Karas, Szymon
Kopaczewski, Adam
Makosiej, Przemyslaw
Koszuk, Jaroslaw
Pec, Michal
Miksa, Krzysztof
author_sort Bedkowski, Janusz
collection PubMed
description This paper concerns a new methodology for accuracy assessment of GPS (Global Positioning System) verified experimentally with LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) data alignment at continent scale for autonomous driving safety analysis. Accuracy of an autonomous driving vehicle positioning within a lane on the road is one of the key safety considerations and the main focus of this paper. The accuracy of GPS positioning is checked by comparing it with mobile mapping tracks in the recorded high-definition source. The aim of the comparison is to see if the GPS positioning remains accurate up to the dimensions of the lane where the vehicle is driving. The goal is to align all the available LiDAR car trajectories to confirm the of accuracy of GNSS + INS (Global Navigation Satellite System + Inertial Navigation System). For this reason, the use of LiDAR metric measurements for data alignment implemented using SLAM (Simultaneous Localization and Mapping) was investigated, assuring no systematic drift by applying GNSS+INS constraints. The methodology was verified experimentally using arbitrarily chosen measurement instruments (NovAtel GNSS + INS, Velodyne HDL32 LiDAR) mounted onto mobile mapping systems. The accuracy was assessed and confirmed by the alignment of 32,785 trajectories with a total length of 1,159,956.9 km and a total of 186.4 × 10 [Formula: see text] optimized parameters (six degrees of freedom of poses) that cover the United States region in the 2016–2019 period. The alignment improves the trajectories; thus the final map is consistent. The proposed methodology extends the existing methods of global positioning system accuracy assessment, focusing on realistic environmental and driving conditions. The impact of global positioning system accuracy on autonomous car safety is discussed. It is shown that 99% of the assessed data satisfy the safety requirements (driving within lanes of 3.6 m) for Mid-Size (width 1.85 m, length 4.87 m) vehicles and 95% for Six-Wheel Pickup (width 2.03–2.43 m, length 5.32–6.76 m). The conclusion is that this methodology has great potential for global positioning accuracy assessment at the global scale for autonomous driving applications. LiDAR data alignment is introduced as a novel approach to GNSS + INS accuracy confirmation. Further research is needed to solve the identified challenges.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8434143
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-84341432021-09-12 A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis Bedkowski, Janusz Nowak, Hubert Kubiak, Blazej Studzinski, Witold Janeczek, Maciej Karas, Szymon Kopaczewski, Adam Makosiej, Przemyslaw Koszuk, Jaroslaw Pec, Michal Miksa, Krzysztof Sensors (Basel) Case Report This paper concerns a new methodology for accuracy assessment of GPS (Global Positioning System) verified experimentally with LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) data alignment at continent scale for autonomous driving safety analysis. Accuracy of an autonomous driving vehicle positioning within a lane on the road is one of the key safety considerations and the main focus of this paper. The accuracy of GPS positioning is checked by comparing it with mobile mapping tracks in the recorded high-definition source. The aim of the comparison is to see if the GPS positioning remains accurate up to the dimensions of the lane where the vehicle is driving. The goal is to align all the available LiDAR car trajectories to confirm the of accuracy of GNSS + INS (Global Navigation Satellite System + Inertial Navigation System). For this reason, the use of LiDAR metric measurements for data alignment implemented using SLAM (Simultaneous Localization and Mapping) was investigated, assuring no systematic drift by applying GNSS+INS constraints. The methodology was verified experimentally using arbitrarily chosen measurement instruments (NovAtel GNSS + INS, Velodyne HDL32 LiDAR) mounted onto mobile mapping systems. The accuracy was assessed and confirmed by the alignment of 32,785 trajectories with a total length of 1,159,956.9 km and a total of 186.4 × 10 [Formula: see text] optimized parameters (six degrees of freedom of poses) that cover the United States region in the 2016–2019 period. The alignment improves the trajectories; thus the final map is consistent. The proposed methodology extends the existing methods of global positioning system accuracy assessment, focusing on realistic environmental and driving conditions. The impact of global positioning system accuracy on autonomous car safety is discussed. It is shown that 99% of the assessed data satisfy the safety requirements (driving within lanes of 3.6 m) for Mid-Size (width 1.85 m, length 4.87 m) vehicles and 95% for Six-Wheel Pickup (width 2.03–2.43 m, length 5.32–6.76 m). The conclusion is that this methodology has great potential for global positioning accuracy assessment at the global scale for autonomous driving applications. LiDAR data alignment is introduced as a novel approach to GNSS + INS accuracy confirmation. Further research is needed to solve the identified challenges. MDPI 2021-08-24 /pmc/articles/PMC8434143/ /pubmed/34502581 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/s21175691 Text en © 2021 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Case Report
Bedkowski, Janusz
Nowak, Hubert
Kubiak, Blazej
Studzinski, Witold
Janeczek, Maciej
Karas, Szymon
Kopaczewski, Adam
Makosiej, Przemyslaw
Koszuk, Jaroslaw
Pec, Michal
Miksa, Krzysztof
A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis
title A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis
title_full A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis
title_fullStr A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis
title_full_unstemmed A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis
title_short A Novel Approach to Global Positioning System Accuracy Assessment, Verified on LiDAR Alignment of One Million Kilometers at a Continent Scale, as a Foundation for Autonomous DRIVING Safety Analysis
title_sort novel approach to global positioning system accuracy assessment, verified on lidar alignment of one million kilometers at a continent scale, as a foundation for autonomous driving safety analysis
topic Case Report
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8434143/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34502581
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/s21175691
work_keys_str_mv AT bedkowskijanusz anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT nowakhubert anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT kubiakblazej anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT studzinskiwitold anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT janeczekmaciej anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT karasszymon anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT kopaczewskiadam anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT makosiejprzemyslaw anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT koszukjaroslaw anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT pecmichal anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT miksakrzysztof anovelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT bedkowskijanusz novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT nowakhubert novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT kubiakblazej novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT studzinskiwitold novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT janeczekmaciej novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT karasszymon novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT kopaczewskiadam novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT makosiejprzemyslaw novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT koszukjaroslaw novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT pecmichal novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis
AT miksakrzysztof novelapproachtoglobalpositioningsystemaccuracyassessmentverifiedonlidaralignmentofonemillionkilometersatacontinentscaleasafoundationforautonomousdrivingsafetyanalysis