Cargando…

Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany

Cohort-independent robust mortality prediction model in patients with COVID-19 infection is not yet established. To build up a reliable, interpretable mortality prediction model with strong foresight, we have performed an international, bi-institutional study from China (Wuhan cohort, collected from...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Bai, Tao, Zhu, Xue, Zhou, Xiang, Grathwohl, Denise, Yang, Pengshuo, Zha, Yuguo, Jin, Yu, Chong, Hui, Yu, Qingyang, Isberner, Nora, Wang, Dongke, Zhang, Lei, Kortüm, K. Martin, Song, Jun, Rasche, Leo, Einsele, Hermann, Ning, Kang, Hou, Xiaohua
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8446629/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34541519
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/frai.2021.672050
_version_ 1784568922135068672
author Bai, Tao
Zhu, Xue
Zhou, Xiang
Grathwohl, Denise
Yang, Pengshuo
Zha, Yuguo
Jin, Yu
Chong, Hui
Yu, Qingyang
Isberner, Nora
Wang, Dongke
Zhang, Lei
Kortüm, K. Martin
Song, Jun
Rasche, Leo
Einsele, Hermann
Ning, Kang
Hou, Xiaohua
author_facet Bai, Tao
Zhu, Xue
Zhou, Xiang
Grathwohl, Denise
Yang, Pengshuo
Zha, Yuguo
Jin, Yu
Chong, Hui
Yu, Qingyang
Isberner, Nora
Wang, Dongke
Zhang, Lei
Kortüm, K. Martin
Song, Jun
Rasche, Leo
Einsele, Hermann
Ning, Kang
Hou, Xiaohua
author_sort Bai, Tao
collection PubMed
description Cohort-independent robust mortality prediction model in patients with COVID-19 infection is not yet established. To build up a reliable, interpretable mortality prediction model with strong foresight, we have performed an international, bi-institutional study from China (Wuhan cohort, collected from January to March) and Germany (Würzburg cohort, collected from March to September). A Random Forest-based machine learning approach was applied to 1,352 patients from the Wuhan cohort, generating a mortality prediction model based on their clinical features. The results showed that five clinical features at admission, including lymphocyte (%), neutrophil count, C-reactive protein, lactate dehydrogenase, and α-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase, could be used for mortality prediction of COVID-19 patients with more than 91% accuracy and 99% AUC. Additionally, the time-series analysis revealed that the predictive model based on these clinical features is very robust over time when patients are in the hospital, indicating the strong association of these five clinical features with the progression of treatment as well. Moreover, for different preexisting diseases, this model also demonstrated high predictive power. Finally, the mortality prediction model has been applied to the independent Würzburg cohort, resulting in high prediction accuracy (with above 90% accuracy and 85% AUC) as well, indicating the robustness of the model in different cohorts. In summary, this study has established the mortality prediction model that allowed early classification of COVID-19 patients, not only at admission but also along the treatment timeline, not only cohort-independent but also highly interpretable. This model represents a valuable tool for triaging and optimizing the resources in COVID-19 patients.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8446629
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-84466292021-09-18 Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany Bai, Tao Zhu, Xue Zhou, Xiang Grathwohl, Denise Yang, Pengshuo Zha, Yuguo Jin, Yu Chong, Hui Yu, Qingyang Isberner, Nora Wang, Dongke Zhang, Lei Kortüm, K. Martin Song, Jun Rasche, Leo Einsele, Hermann Ning, Kang Hou, Xiaohua Front Artif Intell Artificial Intelligence Cohort-independent robust mortality prediction model in patients with COVID-19 infection is not yet established. To build up a reliable, interpretable mortality prediction model with strong foresight, we have performed an international, bi-institutional study from China (Wuhan cohort, collected from January to March) and Germany (Würzburg cohort, collected from March to September). A Random Forest-based machine learning approach was applied to 1,352 patients from the Wuhan cohort, generating a mortality prediction model based on their clinical features. The results showed that five clinical features at admission, including lymphocyte (%), neutrophil count, C-reactive protein, lactate dehydrogenase, and α-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase, could be used for mortality prediction of COVID-19 patients with more than 91% accuracy and 99% AUC. Additionally, the time-series analysis revealed that the predictive model based on these clinical features is very robust over time when patients are in the hospital, indicating the strong association of these five clinical features with the progression of treatment as well. Moreover, for different preexisting diseases, this model also demonstrated high predictive power. Finally, the mortality prediction model has been applied to the independent Würzburg cohort, resulting in high prediction accuracy (with above 90% accuracy and 85% AUC) as well, indicating the robustness of the model in different cohorts. In summary, this study has established the mortality prediction model that allowed early classification of COVID-19 patients, not only at admission but also along the treatment timeline, not only cohort-independent but also highly interpretable. This model represents a valuable tool for triaging and optimizing the resources in COVID-19 patients. Frontiers Media S.A. 2021-09-03 /pmc/articles/PMC8446629/ /pubmed/34541519 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/frai.2021.672050 Text en Copyright © 2021 Bai, Zhu, Zhou, Grathwohl, Yang, Zha, Jin, Chong, Yu, Isberner, Wang, Zhang, Kortüm, Song, Rasche, Einsele, Ning and Hou. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Artificial Intelligence
Bai, Tao
Zhu, Xue
Zhou, Xiang
Grathwohl, Denise
Yang, Pengshuo
Zha, Yuguo
Jin, Yu
Chong, Hui
Yu, Qingyang
Isberner, Nora
Wang, Dongke
Zhang, Lei
Kortüm, K. Martin
Song, Jun
Rasche, Leo
Einsele, Hermann
Ning, Kang
Hou, Xiaohua
Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany
title Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany
title_full Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany
title_fullStr Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany
title_full_unstemmed Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany
title_short Reliable and Interpretable Mortality Prediction With Strong Foresight in COVID-19 Patients: An International Study From China and Germany
title_sort reliable and interpretable mortality prediction with strong foresight in covid-19 patients: an international study from china and germany
topic Artificial Intelligence
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8446629/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34541519
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/frai.2021.672050
work_keys_str_mv AT baitao reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT zhuxue reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT zhouxiang reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT grathwohldenise reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT yangpengshuo reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT zhayuguo reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT jinyu reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT chonghui reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT yuqingyang reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT isbernernora reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT wangdongke reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT zhanglei reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT kortumkmartin reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT songjun reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT rascheleo reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT einselehermann reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT ningkang reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany
AT houxiaohua reliableandinterpretablemortalitypredictionwithstrongforesightincovid19patientsaninternationalstudyfromchinaandgermany