Cargando…

Individual versus general structured feedback to improve agreement in grant peer review: a randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND: Vast sums are distributed based on grant peer review, but studies show that interrater reliability is often low. In this study, we tested the effect of receiving two short individual feedback reports compared to one short general feedback report on the agreement between reviewers. METHOD...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales:	Hesselberg, Jan-Ole, Fostervold, Knut Inge, Ulleberg, Pål, Svege, Ida
Formato:	Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:	English
Publicado:	BioMed Central 2021
Materias:	Research
Acceso en línea:	https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8485516/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34593049 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s41073-021-00115-5

Ejemplares similares

Ranking versus rating in peer review of research grant applications
por: Tamblyn, Robyn, et al.
Publicado: (2023)

Grant writing and grant peer review as questionable research practices
por: Conix, Stijn, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Transparent Peer Review of Grant Applications
por: Lee, Jung Hun, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Revised Model agreements for the granting of the status of associate member
Publicado: (2013)

Grant Review Feedback: Appropriateness and Usefulness
por: Gallo, Stephen A., et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Improving Grant Application Peer Review for the NIEHS
por: Schwartz, David A., et al.
Publicado: (2006)

peer review of grant funding – the Australian perspective
por: Cappai, Roberto
Publicado: (2015)

General Grant's Disease
Publicado: (1885)

Recollections of General Grant
Publicado: (1890)

General Grant’s Condition
por: Abbott, Frank
Publicado: (1885)

The Case of General Grant
Publicado: (1885)

Teleconference versus Face-to-Face Scientific Peer Review of Grant Application: Effects on Review Outcomes
por: Gallo, Stephen A., et al.
Publicado: (2013)

Grant Peer Review: Improving Inter-Rater Reliability with Training
por: Sattler, David N., et al.
Publicado: (2015)

General Grant—Cancer of the Tongue
Publicado: (1885)

General Grant’s Last Days
Publicado: (1885)

Heterogeneity of Inter-Rater Reliabilities of Grant Peer Reviews and Its Determinants: A General Estimating Equations Approach
por: Mutz, Rüdiger, et al.
Publicado: (2012)

NIH peer review percentile scores are poorly predictive of grant productivity
por: Fang, Ferric C, et al.
Publicado: (2016)

Development and Reliability of a Clinician-rated Instrument to Evaluate Function in Individuals with Shoulder Pain: A Preliminary Study
por: Rol, Yngve, et al.
Publicado: (2013)

Put your feet up: The impact of personality traits, job pressure, and social support on the need for recovery after work
por: Fostervold, Knut Inge, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

Peer Review of Grant Applications: Criteria Used and Qualitative Study of Reviewer Practices
por: Abdoul, Hendy, et al.
Publicado: (2012)

What do we know about grant peer review in the health sciences?
por: Guthrie, Susan, et al.
Publicado: (2018)

What makes an effective grants peer reviewer? An exploratory study of the necessary skills
por: Steiner Davis, Miriam L. E., et al.
Publicado: (2020)

An experimental test of the effects of redacting grant applicant identifiers on peer review outcomes
por: Nakamura, Richard K, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Impact of an institutional grant award on early career investigator applicants and peer reviewers
por: Mughal, Amreen, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Healthcare system intervention for prevention of birth injuries – process evaluation of self-assessment, peer review, feedback and agreement for change
por: Nyström, Monica E, et al.
Publicado: (2012)

Working Group on the Scientific and Geographical Enlargement of CERN - Model Agreements for the Granting of Associate Member Status
Publicado: (2010)

Working Group on the Scientific and Geographical Enlargement of CERN - Model Agreements for the Granting of Associate Member Status
Publicado: (2010)

Feedback as dialogue for faculty: From peer review to peer‐to‐peer coaching
por: Margalit, Noam, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

Peer Review of Grant Applications: A Simple Method to Identify Proposals with Discordant Reviews
por: Giraudeau, Bruno, et al.
Publicado: (2011)

The leaky pipeline in research grant peer review and funding decisions: challenges and future directions
por: Sato, Sayaka, et al.
Publicado: (2020)

General Agreement
Publicado: (1921)

It's Money! Real-World Grant Experience through a Student-Run, Peer-Reviewed Program
por: Dumanis, Sonya B., et al.
Publicado: (2013)

‘Are you siding with a personality or the grant proposal?’: observations on how peer review panels function
por: Coveney, John, et al.
Publicado: (2017)

Dr. James A. S. Grant (Grant-Bey)
Publicado: (1896)

Amendment to the agreement between CERN and Ukraine concerning the granting of the status of Associate Member at CERN Extension of the deadline for the notification of the completion of the internal approval procedures of the agreement by Ukraine
Publicado: (2015)

Time-dependent improvement in functional outcome following Oxford medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty: A prospective longitudinal multicenter study involving 96 patients
por: Nerhus, Tor Kjetil, et al.
Publicado: (2012)

The art of feedback and reflection for peer observation /
Publicado: (2017)

Memorandum - external grants and contract award (ERC grants)
por: Granier, Cecile
Publicado: (2019)

Assessment of Virtual Peer Learning by Peer Feedback: A Pilot Project
por: Uthraraj, Nachappa Sivanesan, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

Does Gender Matter in Grant Peer Review?: An Empirical Investigation Using the Example of the Austrian Science Fund
por: Mutz, Rüdiger, et al.
Publicado: (2012)

Cannot write session to /tmp/vufind_sessions/sess_ticgeh1b2kkvg1t67ji75pchh4