Is the open approach superior to the laparoscopic hernia repair in children? A retrospective comparative study

BACKGROUND: For many years now, inguinal hernia repair in children has been done either by the open approach or laparoscopically with laparoscopy having the edge in terms of cosmesis and postoperative pain. However, recent studies have called for a return of the open approach as it had a comparable result to laparoscopy with lesser cost. This study aims to compare the outcomes of the two approaches at our institution. METHODS: This is a retrospective analysis of the prospectively collected data of all patients aged between 6 months and 13 years who underwent open or laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair in the period between January 2017 and July 2019 at our institution. RESULTS: 155 patients were included in the study. 100 (64.5%) underwent open inguinal repair while 55 (35.5%) were done laparoscopically. There was no significant difference in the postoperative complications between the open and laparoscopic groups (P = 0.66). The overall mean operative time for the laparoscopic group and the open group is (45.7 ± 15.2, 45.5 ± 15.4 min, P = 0.83) respectively. However, a subgroup analysis showed a statistical difference in the operative time in bilateral hernias favoring the laparoscopic approach, (44 ± 13.2, 63.2 ± 26.4 min respectively, P = 0.049). Laparoscopy was also associated with shorter times to full recovery compared to the open group (4.7 days, 7.5 days, P = 0.013). Surprisingly, there was no difference in the cosmetic outcome between the two groups which is contrary to the published literature. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair in children is a feasible and reproducible procedure. It permits the evaluation of the contralateral groin without further incisions. In our study, laparoscopy was superior in terms of operative time in bilateral hernias and the time to recovery. Finally, an added benefit to laparoscopy is that it offers more training opportunities for fellows and residents to improve their laparoscopic skills.