Cargando…

Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Liver fibrosis holds a relevant prognostic meaning in primary biliary cholangitis (PBC). Noninvasive fibrosis evaluation using vibration‐controlled transient elastography (VCTE) is routinely performed. However, there is limited evidence on its accuracy at diagnosis in PBC. We ai...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Cristoferi, Laura, Calvaruso, Vincenza, Overi, Diletta, Viganò, Mauro, Rigamonti, Cristina, Degasperi, Elisabetta, Cardinale, Vincenzo, Labanca, Sara, Zucchini, Nicola, Fichera, Anna, Di Marco, Vito, Leutner, Monica, Venere, Rosanna, Picciotto, Antonino, Lucà, Martina, Mulinacci, Giacomo, Palermo, Andrea, Gerussi, Alessio, D’Amato, Daphne, Elisabeth O’Donnell, Sarah, Cerini, Federica, De Benedittis, Carla, Malinverno, Federica, Ronca, Vincenzo, Mancuso, Clara, Cazzagon, Nora, Ciaccio, Antonio, Barisani, Donatella, Marzioni, Marco, Floreani, Annarosa, Alvaro, Domenico, Gaudio, Eugenio, Invernizzi, Pietro, Carpino, Guido, Nardi, Alessandra, Carbone, Marco
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8518641/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33724515
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/hep.31810
_version_ 1784584271137079296
author Cristoferi, Laura
Calvaruso, Vincenza
Overi, Diletta
Viganò, Mauro
Rigamonti, Cristina
Degasperi, Elisabetta
Cardinale, Vincenzo
Labanca, Sara
Zucchini, Nicola
Fichera, Anna
Di Marco, Vito
Leutner, Monica
Venere, Rosanna
Picciotto, Antonino
Lucà, Martina
Mulinacci, Giacomo
Palermo, Andrea
Gerussi, Alessio
D’Amato, Daphne
Elisabeth O’Donnell, Sarah
Cerini, Federica
De Benedittis, Carla
Malinverno, Federica
Ronca, Vincenzo
Mancuso, Clara
Cazzagon, Nora
Ciaccio, Antonio
Barisani, Donatella
Marzioni, Marco
Floreani, Annarosa
Alvaro, Domenico
Gaudio, Eugenio
Invernizzi, Pietro
Carpino, Guido
Nardi, Alessandra
Carbone, Marco
author_facet Cristoferi, Laura
Calvaruso, Vincenza
Overi, Diletta
Viganò, Mauro
Rigamonti, Cristina
Degasperi, Elisabetta
Cardinale, Vincenzo
Labanca, Sara
Zucchini, Nicola
Fichera, Anna
Di Marco, Vito
Leutner, Monica
Venere, Rosanna
Picciotto, Antonino
Lucà, Martina
Mulinacci, Giacomo
Palermo, Andrea
Gerussi, Alessio
D’Amato, Daphne
Elisabeth O’Donnell, Sarah
Cerini, Federica
De Benedittis, Carla
Malinverno, Federica
Ronca, Vincenzo
Mancuso, Clara
Cazzagon, Nora
Ciaccio, Antonio
Barisani, Donatella
Marzioni, Marco
Floreani, Annarosa
Alvaro, Domenico
Gaudio, Eugenio
Invernizzi, Pietro
Carpino, Guido
Nardi, Alessandra
Carbone, Marco
author_sort Cristoferi, Laura
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Liver fibrosis holds a relevant prognostic meaning in primary biliary cholangitis (PBC). Noninvasive fibrosis evaluation using vibration‐controlled transient elastography (VCTE) is routinely performed. However, there is limited evidence on its accuracy at diagnosis in PBC. We aimed to estimate the diagnostic accuracy of VCTE in assessing advanced fibrosis (AF) at disease presentation in PBC. APPROACH AND RESULTS: We collected data from 167 consecutive treatment‐naïve PBC patients who underwent liver biopsy (LB) at diagnosis at six Italian centers. VCTE examinations were completed within 12 weeks of LB. Biopsies were scored by two blinded expert pathologists, according to the Ludwig system. Diagnostic accuracy was estimated using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curves (AUROCs) for AF (Ludwig stage ≥III). Effects of biochemical and clinical parameters on liver stiffness measurement (LSM) were appraised. The derivation cohort consisted of 126 patients with valid LSM and LB; VCTE identified patients with AF with an AUROC of 0.89. LSM cutoffs ≤6.5 and >11.0 kPa enabled to exclude and confirm, respectively, AF (negative predictive value [NPV] = 0.94; positive predictive value [PPV] = 0.89; error rate = 5.6%). These values were externally validated in an independent cohort of 91 PBC patients (NPV = 0.93; PPV = 0.89; error rate = 8.6%). Multivariable analysis found that the only parameter affecting LSM was fibrosis stage. No association was found with BMI and liver biochemistry. CONCLUSIONS: In a multicenter study of treatment‐naïve PBC patients, we identified two cutoffs (LSM ≤6.5 and >11.0 kPa) able to discriminate at diagnosis the absence or presence, respectively, of AF in PBC patients, with external validation. In patients with LSM between these two cutoffs, VCTE is not reliable and liver biopsy should be evaluated for accurate disease staging. BMI and liver biochemistry did not affect LSMs.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8518641
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-85186412021-10-21 Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach Cristoferi, Laura Calvaruso, Vincenza Overi, Diletta Viganò, Mauro Rigamonti, Cristina Degasperi, Elisabetta Cardinale, Vincenzo Labanca, Sara Zucchini, Nicola Fichera, Anna Di Marco, Vito Leutner, Monica Venere, Rosanna Picciotto, Antonino Lucà, Martina Mulinacci, Giacomo Palermo, Andrea Gerussi, Alessio D’Amato, Daphne Elisabeth O’Donnell, Sarah Cerini, Federica De Benedittis, Carla Malinverno, Federica Ronca, Vincenzo Mancuso, Clara Cazzagon, Nora Ciaccio, Antonio Barisani, Donatella Marzioni, Marco Floreani, Annarosa Alvaro, Domenico Gaudio, Eugenio Invernizzi, Pietro Carpino, Guido Nardi, Alessandra Carbone, Marco Hepatology Original Articles BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Liver fibrosis holds a relevant prognostic meaning in primary biliary cholangitis (PBC). Noninvasive fibrosis evaluation using vibration‐controlled transient elastography (VCTE) is routinely performed. However, there is limited evidence on its accuracy at diagnosis in PBC. We aimed to estimate the diagnostic accuracy of VCTE in assessing advanced fibrosis (AF) at disease presentation in PBC. APPROACH AND RESULTS: We collected data from 167 consecutive treatment‐naïve PBC patients who underwent liver biopsy (LB) at diagnosis at six Italian centers. VCTE examinations were completed within 12 weeks of LB. Biopsies were scored by two blinded expert pathologists, according to the Ludwig system. Diagnostic accuracy was estimated using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curves (AUROCs) for AF (Ludwig stage ≥III). Effects of biochemical and clinical parameters on liver stiffness measurement (LSM) were appraised. The derivation cohort consisted of 126 patients with valid LSM and LB; VCTE identified patients with AF with an AUROC of 0.89. LSM cutoffs ≤6.5 and >11.0 kPa enabled to exclude and confirm, respectively, AF (negative predictive value [NPV] = 0.94; positive predictive value [PPV] = 0.89; error rate = 5.6%). These values were externally validated in an independent cohort of 91 PBC patients (NPV = 0.93; PPV = 0.89; error rate = 8.6%). Multivariable analysis found that the only parameter affecting LSM was fibrosis stage. No association was found with BMI and liver biochemistry. CONCLUSIONS: In a multicenter study of treatment‐naïve PBC patients, we identified two cutoffs (LSM ≤6.5 and >11.0 kPa) able to discriminate at diagnosis the absence or presence, respectively, of AF in PBC patients, with external validation. In patients with LSM between these two cutoffs, VCTE is not reliable and liver biopsy should be evaluated for accurate disease staging. BMI and liver biochemistry did not affect LSMs. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021-05-28 2021-09 /pmc/articles/PMC8518641/ /pubmed/33724515 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/hep.31810 Text en © 2021 The Authors. Hepatology published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
spellingShingle Original Articles
Cristoferi, Laura
Calvaruso, Vincenza
Overi, Diletta
Viganò, Mauro
Rigamonti, Cristina
Degasperi, Elisabetta
Cardinale, Vincenzo
Labanca, Sara
Zucchini, Nicola
Fichera, Anna
Di Marco, Vito
Leutner, Monica
Venere, Rosanna
Picciotto, Antonino
Lucà, Martina
Mulinacci, Giacomo
Palermo, Andrea
Gerussi, Alessio
D’Amato, Daphne
Elisabeth O’Donnell, Sarah
Cerini, Federica
De Benedittis, Carla
Malinverno, Federica
Ronca, Vincenzo
Mancuso, Clara
Cazzagon, Nora
Ciaccio, Antonio
Barisani, Donatella
Marzioni, Marco
Floreani, Annarosa
Alvaro, Domenico
Gaudio, Eugenio
Invernizzi, Pietro
Carpino, Guido
Nardi, Alessandra
Carbone, Marco
Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach
title Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach
title_full Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach
title_fullStr Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach
title_full_unstemmed Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach
title_short Accuracy of Transient Elastography in Assessing Fibrosis at Diagnosis in Naïve Patients With Primary Biliary Cholangitis: A Dual Cut‐Off Approach
title_sort accuracy of transient elastography in assessing fibrosis at diagnosis in naïve patients with primary biliary cholangitis: a dual cut‐off approach
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8518641/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33724515
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/hep.31810
work_keys_str_mv AT cristoferilaura accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT calvarusovincenza accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT overidiletta accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT viganomauro accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT rigamonticristina accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT degasperielisabetta accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT cardinalevincenzo accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT labancasara accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT zucchininicola accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT ficheraanna accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT dimarcovito accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT leutnermonica accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT venererosanna accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT picciottoantonino accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT lucamartina accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT mulinaccigiacomo accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT palermoandrea accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT gerussialessio accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT damatodaphne accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT elisabethodonnellsarah accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT cerinifederica accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT debenedittiscarla accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT malinvernofederica accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT roncavincenzo accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT mancusoclara accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT cazzagonnora accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT ciaccioantonio accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT barisanidonatella accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT marzionimarco accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT floreaniannarosa accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT alvarodomenico accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT gaudioeugenio accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT invernizzipietro accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT carpinoguido accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT nardialessandra accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT carbonemarco accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach
AT accuracyoftransientelastographyinassessingfibrosisatdiagnosisinnaivepatientswithprimarybiliarycholangitisadualcutoffapproach