Patent Landscape of Automated Systems for Personalized Health Management (ASHM): Features, Shortcomings, and Implications for Developing an Optimal ASHM

The current struggle of national health care systems against global epidemic of non-communicable diseases (NCD) is both clinically ineffective and cost ineffective. On the other hand, rapid development of systems biology, P4 medicine and new digital and communication technologies are good prerequisites for creating an affordable and scalable automated system for personalized health management (ASHM). The current practice of ASHM is better represented in patent literature (36 relevant documents found in Google Patents and USPTO) than in scientific papers (17 documents found in PubMed and Google Scholar). However, only a small fraction of publications disclose a complete self-sufficient system. Problems that authors of ASHM aim to address, methodological approaches, and the most important technical solutions are reviewed and discussed along with shortcomings and limitations. Technical solutions for ASHM currently commercialized or described in literature generally fail to enable practicable, scalable and affordable automated and individualized screening, monitoring, prevention and correction of human health conditions. They also fail to provide a decision support system to patients that would help effectively prevent major NCD and their complications, be accessible and cost effective, consider individual lifestyle factors and involve patients in management of their individual health. Based on analysis of the literature, models of health and care, we propose conceptual framework for developing an ASHM that would be free from the mentioned problems.