Cargando…

The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion

Milgram’s classical studies famously suggested a widespread willingness to obey authority, even to the point of inflicting harm. Important situational factors supporting obedience, such as proximity with the victim, have been established. Relatively little work has focused on how coercion affects in...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Caspar, Emilie A., Beyer, Frederike, Cleeremans, Axel, Haggard, Patrick
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8553174/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34710149
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258884
_version_ 1784591531243470848
author Caspar, Emilie A.
Beyer, Frederike
Cleeremans, Axel
Haggard, Patrick
author_facet Caspar, Emilie A.
Beyer, Frederike
Cleeremans, Axel
Haggard, Patrick
author_sort Caspar, Emilie A.
collection PubMed
description Milgram’s classical studies famously suggested a widespread willingness to obey authority, even to the point of inflicting harm. Important situational factors supporting obedience, such as proximity with the victim, have been established. Relatively little work has focused on how coercion affects individual cognition, or on identifying the cognitive factors that underlie inter-individual differences in the tendency to yield to coercion. Here, we used fMRI to investigate the neural systems associated with changes in volitional processes associated with sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion. Participants either freely chose, or were instructed by the experimenter, to give mildly painful electric shocks to another participant, or to refrain from doing so. We have previously shown that coercion reduces temporal binding, which has been proposed as an implicit proxy measure of sense of agency. We tested how reduced agency under coercion related to differences in neural activity between free choice and coercion. In contrast to previous studies and to participants performing the task outside the MRI scanner, on average there was no effect of coercion on agency for participants in the scanner. However, greater activity in the medial frontal gyrus was reliably associated with greater agency under coercion. A similar association was found using explicit responsibility ratings. Our findings suggest that medial frontal processes, perhaps related to volition during action planning and execution, may help to preserve a sense of accountability under coercion. Further, participants who administered more shocks under free choice showed reduced activity during free choice trials in brain areas associated with social cognition. Possibly, this might reflect participants cognitively distancing themselves from the recipient of the shocks under free choice, whereas this was not observed under coercion.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8553174
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-85531742021-10-29 The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion Caspar, Emilie A. Beyer, Frederike Cleeremans, Axel Haggard, Patrick PLoS One Research Article Milgram’s classical studies famously suggested a widespread willingness to obey authority, even to the point of inflicting harm. Important situational factors supporting obedience, such as proximity with the victim, have been established. Relatively little work has focused on how coercion affects individual cognition, or on identifying the cognitive factors that underlie inter-individual differences in the tendency to yield to coercion. Here, we used fMRI to investigate the neural systems associated with changes in volitional processes associated with sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion. Participants either freely chose, or were instructed by the experimenter, to give mildly painful electric shocks to another participant, or to refrain from doing so. We have previously shown that coercion reduces temporal binding, which has been proposed as an implicit proxy measure of sense of agency. We tested how reduced agency under coercion related to differences in neural activity between free choice and coercion. In contrast to previous studies and to participants performing the task outside the MRI scanner, on average there was no effect of coercion on agency for participants in the scanner. However, greater activity in the medial frontal gyrus was reliably associated with greater agency under coercion. A similar association was found using explicit responsibility ratings. Our findings suggest that medial frontal processes, perhaps related to volition during action planning and execution, may help to preserve a sense of accountability under coercion. Further, participants who administered more shocks under free choice showed reduced activity during free choice trials in brain areas associated with social cognition. Possibly, this might reflect participants cognitively distancing themselves from the recipient of the shocks under free choice, whereas this was not observed under coercion. Public Library of Science 2021-10-28 /pmc/articles/PMC8553174/ /pubmed/34710149 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258884 Text en © 2021 Caspar et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Caspar, Emilie A.
Beyer, Frederike
Cleeremans, Axel
Haggard, Patrick
The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
title The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
title_full The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
title_fullStr The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
title_full_unstemmed The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
title_short The obedient mind and the volitional brain: A neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
title_sort obedient mind and the volitional brain: a neural basis for preserved sense of agency and sense of responsibility under coercion
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8553174/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34710149
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258884
work_keys_str_mv AT casparemiliea theobedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT beyerfrederike theobedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT cleeremansaxel theobedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT haggardpatrick theobedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT casparemiliea obedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT beyerfrederike obedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT cleeremansaxel obedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion
AT haggardpatrick obedientmindandthevolitionalbrainaneuralbasisforpreservedsenseofagencyandsenseofresponsibilityundercoercion