Cargando…

Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing

BACKGROUND: Characterization of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) has been integrated into clinical practice. Although labs have standardized validation procedures to develop single locus tests, the efficacy of on‐site plasma‐based next‐generation sequencing (NGS) assays still needs to be proved. MATERI...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Al Zoughbi, Wael, Fox, Jesse, Beg, Shaham, Papp, Eniko, Hissong, Erika, Ohara, Kentaro, Keefer, Laurel, Sigouros, Michael, Kane, Troy, Bockelman, Daniel, Nichol, Donna, Patchell, Emily, Bareja, Rohan, Karandikar, Aanavi, Alnajar, Hussein, Cerqueira, Gustavo, Guthrie, Violeta Beleva, Verner, Ellen, Manohar, Jyothi, Greco, Noah, Wilkes, David, Tagawa, Scott, Malbari, Murtaza S., Holcomb, Kevin, Eng, Kenneth Wha, Shah, Manish, Altorki, Nasser K., Sboner, Andrea, Nanus, David, Faltas, Bishoy, Sternberg, Cora N., Simmons, John, Houvras, Yariv, Molina, Ana M., Angiuoli, Samuel, Elemento, Olivier, Mosquera, Juan Miguel
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8571755/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34286887
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/onco.13905
_version_ 1784595088306864128
author Al Zoughbi, Wael
Fox, Jesse
Beg, Shaham
Papp, Eniko
Hissong, Erika
Ohara, Kentaro
Keefer, Laurel
Sigouros, Michael
Kane, Troy
Bockelman, Daniel
Nichol, Donna
Patchell, Emily
Bareja, Rohan
Karandikar, Aanavi
Alnajar, Hussein
Cerqueira, Gustavo
Guthrie, Violeta Beleva
Verner, Ellen
Manohar, Jyothi
Greco, Noah
Wilkes, David
Tagawa, Scott
Malbari, Murtaza S.
Holcomb, Kevin
Eng, Kenneth Wha
Shah, Manish
Altorki, Nasser K.
Sboner, Andrea
Nanus, David
Faltas, Bishoy
Sternberg, Cora N.
Simmons, John
Houvras, Yariv
Molina, Ana M.
Angiuoli, Samuel
Elemento, Olivier
Mosquera, Juan Miguel
author_facet Al Zoughbi, Wael
Fox, Jesse
Beg, Shaham
Papp, Eniko
Hissong, Erika
Ohara, Kentaro
Keefer, Laurel
Sigouros, Michael
Kane, Troy
Bockelman, Daniel
Nichol, Donna
Patchell, Emily
Bareja, Rohan
Karandikar, Aanavi
Alnajar, Hussein
Cerqueira, Gustavo
Guthrie, Violeta Beleva
Verner, Ellen
Manohar, Jyothi
Greco, Noah
Wilkes, David
Tagawa, Scott
Malbari, Murtaza S.
Holcomb, Kevin
Eng, Kenneth Wha
Shah, Manish
Altorki, Nasser K.
Sboner, Andrea
Nanus, David
Faltas, Bishoy
Sternberg, Cora N.
Simmons, John
Houvras, Yariv
Molina, Ana M.
Angiuoli, Samuel
Elemento, Olivier
Mosquera, Juan Miguel
author_sort Al Zoughbi, Wael
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Characterization of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) has been integrated into clinical practice. Although labs have standardized validation procedures to develop single locus tests, the efficacy of on‐site plasma‐based next‐generation sequencing (NGS) assays still needs to be proved. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, we profiled DNA from matched tissue and plasma samples from 75 patients with cancer. We applied an NGS test that detects clinically relevant alterations in 33 genes and microsatellite instability (MSI) to analyze plasma cell‐free DNA (cfDNA). RESULTS: The concordance between alterations detected in both tissue and plasma samples was higher in patients with metastatic disease. The NGS test detected 77% of sequence alterations, amplifications, and fusions that were found in metastatic samples compared with 45% of those alterations found in the primary tumor samples (p = .00005). There was 87% agreement on MSI status between the NGS test and tumor tissue results. In three patients, MSI‐high ctDNA correlated with response to immunotherapy. In addition, the NGS test revealed an FGFR2 amplification that was not detected in tumor tissue from a patient with metastatic gastric cancer, emphasizing the importance of profiling plasma samples in patients with advanced cancer. CONCLUSION: Our validation experience of a plasma‐based NGS assay advances current knowledge about translating cfDNA testing into clinical practice and supports the application of plasma assays in the management of oncology patients with metastatic disease. With an in‐house method that minimizes the need for invasive procedures, on‐site cfDNA testing supplements tissue biopsy to guide precision therapy and is entitled to become a routine practice. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: This study proposes a solution for decentralized liquid biopsy testing based on validation of a next‐generation sequencing (NGS) test that detects four classes of genomic alterations in blood: sequence mutations (single nucleotide substitutions or insertions and deletions), fusions, amplifications, and microsatellite instability (MSI). Although there are reference labs that perform single‐site comprehensive liquid biopsy testing, the targeted assay this study validated can be established locally in any lab with capacity to offer clinical molecular pathology assays. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first report that validates evaluating an on‐site plasma‐based NGS test that detects the MSI status along with common sequence alterations encountered in solid tumors.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8571755
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-85717552021-11-10 Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing Al Zoughbi, Wael Fox, Jesse Beg, Shaham Papp, Eniko Hissong, Erika Ohara, Kentaro Keefer, Laurel Sigouros, Michael Kane, Troy Bockelman, Daniel Nichol, Donna Patchell, Emily Bareja, Rohan Karandikar, Aanavi Alnajar, Hussein Cerqueira, Gustavo Guthrie, Violeta Beleva Verner, Ellen Manohar, Jyothi Greco, Noah Wilkes, David Tagawa, Scott Malbari, Murtaza S. Holcomb, Kevin Eng, Kenneth Wha Shah, Manish Altorki, Nasser K. Sboner, Andrea Nanus, David Faltas, Bishoy Sternberg, Cora N. Simmons, John Houvras, Yariv Molina, Ana M. Angiuoli, Samuel Elemento, Olivier Mosquera, Juan Miguel Oncologist Cancer Diagnostics and Molecular Pathology BACKGROUND: Characterization of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) has been integrated into clinical practice. Although labs have standardized validation procedures to develop single locus tests, the efficacy of on‐site plasma‐based next‐generation sequencing (NGS) assays still needs to be proved. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, we profiled DNA from matched tissue and plasma samples from 75 patients with cancer. We applied an NGS test that detects clinically relevant alterations in 33 genes and microsatellite instability (MSI) to analyze plasma cell‐free DNA (cfDNA). RESULTS: The concordance between alterations detected in both tissue and plasma samples was higher in patients with metastatic disease. The NGS test detected 77% of sequence alterations, amplifications, and fusions that were found in metastatic samples compared with 45% of those alterations found in the primary tumor samples (p = .00005). There was 87% agreement on MSI status between the NGS test and tumor tissue results. In three patients, MSI‐high ctDNA correlated with response to immunotherapy. In addition, the NGS test revealed an FGFR2 amplification that was not detected in tumor tissue from a patient with metastatic gastric cancer, emphasizing the importance of profiling plasma samples in patients with advanced cancer. CONCLUSION: Our validation experience of a plasma‐based NGS assay advances current knowledge about translating cfDNA testing into clinical practice and supports the application of plasma assays in the management of oncology patients with metastatic disease. With an in‐house method that minimizes the need for invasive procedures, on‐site cfDNA testing supplements tissue biopsy to guide precision therapy and is entitled to become a routine practice. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: This study proposes a solution for decentralized liquid biopsy testing based on validation of a next‐generation sequencing (NGS) test that detects four classes of genomic alterations in blood: sequence mutations (single nucleotide substitutions or insertions and deletions), fusions, amplifications, and microsatellite instability (MSI). Although there are reference labs that perform single‐site comprehensive liquid biopsy testing, the targeted assay this study validated can be established locally in any lab with capacity to offer clinical molecular pathology assays. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first report that validates evaluating an on‐site plasma‐based NGS test that detects the MSI status along with common sequence alterations encountered in solid tumors. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2021-08-04 2021-11 /pmc/articles/PMC8571755/ /pubmed/34286887 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/onco.13905 Text en © 2021 AlphaMed Press. Open access.
spellingShingle Cancer Diagnostics and Molecular Pathology
Al Zoughbi, Wael
Fox, Jesse
Beg, Shaham
Papp, Eniko
Hissong, Erika
Ohara, Kentaro
Keefer, Laurel
Sigouros, Michael
Kane, Troy
Bockelman, Daniel
Nichol, Donna
Patchell, Emily
Bareja, Rohan
Karandikar, Aanavi
Alnajar, Hussein
Cerqueira, Gustavo
Guthrie, Violeta Beleva
Verner, Ellen
Manohar, Jyothi
Greco, Noah
Wilkes, David
Tagawa, Scott
Malbari, Murtaza S.
Holcomb, Kevin
Eng, Kenneth Wha
Shah, Manish
Altorki, Nasser K.
Sboner, Andrea
Nanus, David
Faltas, Bishoy
Sternberg, Cora N.
Simmons, John
Houvras, Yariv
Molina, Ana M.
Angiuoli, Samuel
Elemento, Olivier
Mosquera, Juan Miguel
Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing
title Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing
title_full Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing
title_fullStr Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing
title_full_unstemmed Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing
title_short Validation of a Circulating Tumor DNA‐Based Next‐Generation Sequencing Assay in a Cohort of Patients with Solid tumors: A Proposed Solution for Decentralized Plasma Testing
title_sort validation of a circulating tumor dna‐based next‐generation sequencing assay in a cohort of patients with solid tumors: a proposed solution for decentralized plasma testing
topic Cancer Diagnostics and Molecular Pathology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8571755/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34286887
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/onco.13905
work_keys_str_mv AT alzoughbiwael validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT foxjesse validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT begshaham validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT pappeniko validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT hissongerika validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT oharakentaro validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT keeferlaurel validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT sigourosmichael validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT kanetroy validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT bockelmandaniel validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT nicholdonna validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT patchellemily validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT barejarohan validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT karandikaraanavi validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT alnajarhussein validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT cerqueiragustavo validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT guthrievioletabeleva validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT vernerellen validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT manoharjyothi validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT greconoah validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT wilkesdavid validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT tagawascott validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT malbarimurtazas validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT holcombkevin validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT engkennethwha validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT shahmanish validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT altorkinasserk validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT sbonerandrea validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT nanusdavid validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT faltasbishoy validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT sternbergcoran validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT simmonsjohn validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT houvrasyariv validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT molinaanam validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT angiuolisamuel validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT elementoolivier validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting
AT mosquerajuanmiguel validationofacirculatingtumordnabasednextgenerationsequencingassayinacohortofpatientswithsolidtumorsaproposedsolutionfordecentralizedplasmatesting