Cargando…

The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study

BACKGROUND: Vietnam is one of the first low- to middle-income countries to develop and implement a national-scale electronic immunization registry. This system was finalized into the National Immunization Information System (NIIS) and scaled up to a national-level system in 2017. As a result, immuni...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Duong, Hong, Dao, Sang, Dang, Huyen, Nguyen, Linh, Ngo, Tuan, Nguyen, Trung, Tran, Lan Anh, Nguyen, Doan, Rivera, Maya, Nguyen, Nga
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JMIR Publications 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8576599/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34694232
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/28096
_version_ 1784595910373670912
author Duong, Hong
Dao, Sang
Dang, Huyen
Nguyen, Linh
Ngo, Tuan
Nguyen, Trung
Tran, Lan Anh
Nguyen, Doan
Rivera, Maya
Nguyen, Nga
author_facet Duong, Hong
Dao, Sang
Dang, Huyen
Nguyen, Linh
Ngo, Tuan
Nguyen, Trung
Tran, Lan Anh
Nguyen, Doan
Rivera, Maya
Nguyen, Nga
author_sort Duong, Hong
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Vietnam is one of the first low- to middle-income countries to develop and implement a national-scale electronic immunization registry. This system was finalized into the National Immunization Information System (NIIS) and scaled up to a national-level system in 2017. As a result, immunization coverage and the timeliness of vaccinations have drastically improved. The time spent on planning and reporting vaccinations has drastically reduced; as a result, vaccination planning and reporting has become more accurate and effective. However, to date, end users have been tasked with managing both the NIIS and paper-based systems in parallel until a formal assessment of the readiness to fully transition to the NIIS is conducted. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to evaluate the readiness to move to an entirely digital NIIS in 2 provinces of Vietnam—Ha Noi and Son La. METHODS: All health facilities were surveyed to assess their infrastructure, capacity, and need for human resources. NIIS end users were observed and interviewed to evaluate their NIIS knowledge and skill sets. Data from immunization cards and facility paper-based logbooks were compared with data from the NIIS, and vaccine stocks at selected facilities were tallied and compared with data from the NIIS. RESULTS: Of the 990 health facilities evaluated, most used the NIIS to enter and track immunizations (987/990, 99.7%) and vaccine stocks (889/990, 90.8%). Most had stable electricity (971/990, 98.1%), at least 1 computer (986/990, 99.6%), and ≥2 trained NIIS end users (825/990, 83.3%). End users reported that the NIIS supported them in managing and reporting immunization data and saving them time (725/767, 94.5%). Although many end users were able to perform basic skills, almost half struggled with performing more complex tasks. Immunization data were compiled from the NIIS and immunization cards (338/378, 89.4%) and paper-based logbooks (254/269, 94.4%). However, only 54.5% (206/378) of immunization IDs matched, 57% (13/23) of Bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccination records were accurate, and 70% (21/30) of the facilities had consistent physical vaccine stock balances. The feedback received from NIIS end users suggests that more supportive supervision, frequent refresher training for strengthening their skill sets, and detailed standardized guides for improving data quality are needed. CONCLUSIONS: The readiness to transition to a digital system is promising; however, additional resources are required to address the timeliness, completeness, and accuracy of the data.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8576599
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-85765992021-11-24 The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study Duong, Hong Dao, Sang Dang, Huyen Nguyen, Linh Ngo, Tuan Nguyen, Trung Tran, Lan Anh Nguyen, Doan Rivera, Maya Nguyen, Nga JMIR Form Res Original Paper BACKGROUND: Vietnam is one of the first low- to middle-income countries to develop and implement a national-scale electronic immunization registry. This system was finalized into the National Immunization Information System (NIIS) and scaled up to a national-level system in 2017. As a result, immunization coverage and the timeliness of vaccinations have drastically improved. The time spent on planning and reporting vaccinations has drastically reduced; as a result, vaccination planning and reporting has become more accurate and effective. However, to date, end users have been tasked with managing both the NIIS and paper-based systems in parallel until a formal assessment of the readiness to fully transition to the NIIS is conducted. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to evaluate the readiness to move to an entirely digital NIIS in 2 provinces of Vietnam—Ha Noi and Son La. METHODS: All health facilities were surveyed to assess their infrastructure, capacity, and need for human resources. NIIS end users were observed and interviewed to evaluate their NIIS knowledge and skill sets. Data from immunization cards and facility paper-based logbooks were compared with data from the NIIS, and vaccine stocks at selected facilities were tallied and compared with data from the NIIS. RESULTS: Of the 990 health facilities evaluated, most used the NIIS to enter and track immunizations (987/990, 99.7%) and vaccine stocks (889/990, 90.8%). Most had stable electricity (971/990, 98.1%), at least 1 computer (986/990, 99.6%), and ≥2 trained NIIS end users (825/990, 83.3%). End users reported that the NIIS supported them in managing and reporting immunization data and saving them time (725/767, 94.5%). Although many end users were able to perform basic skills, almost half struggled with performing more complex tasks. Immunization data were compiled from the NIIS and immunization cards (338/378, 89.4%) and paper-based logbooks (254/269, 94.4%). However, only 54.5% (206/378) of immunization IDs matched, 57% (13/23) of Bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccination records were accurate, and 70% (21/30) of the facilities had consistent physical vaccine stock balances. The feedback received from NIIS end users suggests that more supportive supervision, frequent refresher training for strengthening their skill sets, and detailed standardized guides for improving data quality are needed. CONCLUSIONS: The readiness to transition to a digital system is promising; however, additional resources are required to address the timeliness, completeness, and accuracy of the data. JMIR Publications 2021-10-25 /pmc/articles/PMC8576599/ /pubmed/34694232 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/28096 Text en ©Hong Duong, Sang Dao, Huyen Dang, Linh Nguyen, Tuan Ngo, Trung Nguyen, Lan Anh Tran, Doan Nguyen, Maya Rivera, Nga Nguyen. Originally published in JMIR Formative Research (https://formative.jmir.org), 25.10.2021. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Formative Research, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://formative.jmir.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
spellingShingle Original Paper
Duong, Hong
Dao, Sang
Dang, Huyen
Nguyen, Linh
Ngo, Tuan
Nguyen, Trung
Tran, Lan Anh
Nguyen, Doan
Rivera, Maya
Nguyen, Nga
The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study
title The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study
title_full The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study
title_fullStr The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study
title_full_unstemmed The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study
title_short The Transition to an Entirely Digital Immunization Registry in Ha Noi Province and Son La Province, Vietnam: Readiness Assessment Study
title_sort transition to an entirely digital immunization registry in ha noi province and son la province, vietnam: readiness assessment study
topic Original Paper
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8576599/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34694232
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/28096
work_keys_str_mv AT duonghong thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT daosang thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT danghuyen thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyenlinh thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT ngotuan thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyentrung thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT tranlananh thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyendoan thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT riveramaya thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyennga thetransitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT duonghong transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT daosang transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT danghuyen transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyenlinh transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT ngotuan transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyentrung transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT tranlananh transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyendoan transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT riveramaya transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy
AT nguyennga transitiontoanentirelydigitalimmunizationregistryinhanoiprovinceandsonlaprovincevietnamreadinessassessmentstudy