Cargando…
The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment
While Spinal Cord Stimulation (SCS) provides satisfaction to almost 2/3 of Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome-Type 2 (PSPS-T2) patients implanted for refractory chronic back and/or leg pain, when not adequately addressed the back pain component, leaves patients in a therapeutic cul-de-sac. Peripheral N...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
MDPI
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8584602/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34768614 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm10215094 |
_version_ | 1784597489146396672 |
---|---|
author | Rigoard, Philippe Ounajim, Amine Goudman, Lisa Bouche, Benedicte Roulaud, Manuel Page, Philippe Lorgeoux, Bertille Baron, Sandrine Nivole, Kevin Many, Mathilde Adjali, Nihel Charrier, Elodie Rannou, Delphine Poupin, Laure Wood, Chantal David, Romain Héraud, Dylan Moens, Maartens Billot, Maxime |
author_facet | Rigoard, Philippe Ounajim, Amine Goudman, Lisa Bouche, Benedicte Roulaud, Manuel Page, Philippe Lorgeoux, Bertille Baron, Sandrine Nivole, Kevin Many, Mathilde Adjali, Nihel Charrier, Elodie Rannou, Delphine Poupin, Laure Wood, Chantal David, Romain Héraud, Dylan Moens, Maartens Billot, Maxime |
author_sort | Rigoard, Philippe |
collection | PubMed |
description | While Spinal Cord Stimulation (SCS) provides satisfaction to almost 2/3 of Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome-Type 2 (PSPS-T2) patients implanted for refractory chronic back and/or leg pain, when not adequately addressed the back pain component, leaves patients in a therapeutic cul-de-sac. Peripheral Nerve field Stimulation (PNfS) has shown interesting results addressing back pain in the same population. Far from placing these two techniques in opposition, we suggest that these approaches could be combined to better treat PSPS-T2 patients. We designed a RCT (CUMPNS), with a 12-month follow-up, to assess the potential added value of PNfS, as a salvage therapy, in PSPS-T2 patients experiencing a “Failed SCS Syndrome” in the back pain component. Fourteen patients were included in this study and randomized into 2 groups (“SCS + PNfS” group/n = 6 vs. “SCS only” group/n = 8). The primary objective of the study was to compare the percentage of back pain surface decrease after 3 months, using a computerized interface to obtain quantitative pain mappings, combined with multi-dimensional SCS outcomes. Back pain surface decreased significantly greater for the ”SCS + PNfS” group (80.2% ± 21.3%) compared to the “SCS only” group (13.2% ± 94.8%) (p = 0.012), highlighting the clinical interest of SCS + PNfS, in cases where SCS fails to address back pain. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8584602 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | MDPI |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-85846022021-11-12 The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment Rigoard, Philippe Ounajim, Amine Goudman, Lisa Bouche, Benedicte Roulaud, Manuel Page, Philippe Lorgeoux, Bertille Baron, Sandrine Nivole, Kevin Many, Mathilde Adjali, Nihel Charrier, Elodie Rannou, Delphine Poupin, Laure Wood, Chantal David, Romain Héraud, Dylan Moens, Maartens Billot, Maxime J Clin Med Article While Spinal Cord Stimulation (SCS) provides satisfaction to almost 2/3 of Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome-Type 2 (PSPS-T2) patients implanted for refractory chronic back and/or leg pain, when not adequately addressed the back pain component, leaves patients in a therapeutic cul-de-sac. Peripheral Nerve field Stimulation (PNfS) has shown interesting results addressing back pain in the same population. Far from placing these two techniques in opposition, we suggest that these approaches could be combined to better treat PSPS-T2 patients. We designed a RCT (CUMPNS), with a 12-month follow-up, to assess the potential added value of PNfS, as a salvage therapy, in PSPS-T2 patients experiencing a “Failed SCS Syndrome” in the back pain component. Fourteen patients were included in this study and randomized into 2 groups (“SCS + PNfS” group/n = 6 vs. “SCS only” group/n = 8). The primary objective of the study was to compare the percentage of back pain surface decrease after 3 months, using a computerized interface to obtain quantitative pain mappings, combined with multi-dimensional SCS outcomes. Back pain surface decreased significantly greater for the ”SCS + PNfS” group (80.2% ± 21.3%) compared to the “SCS only” group (13.2% ± 94.8%) (p = 0.012), highlighting the clinical interest of SCS + PNfS, in cases where SCS fails to address back pain. MDPI 2021-10-29 /pmc/articles/PMC8584602/ /pubmed/34768614 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm10215094 Text en © 2021 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). |
spellingShingle | Article Rigoard, Philippe Ounajim, Amine Goudman, Lisa Bouche, Benedicte Roulaud, Manuel Page, Philippe Lorgeoux, Bertille Baron, Sandrine Nivole, Kevin Many, Mathilde Adjali, Nihel Charrier, Elodie Rannou, Delphine Poupin, Laure Wood, Chantal David, Romain Héraud, Dylan Moens, Maartens Billot, Maxime The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment |
title | The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment |
title_full | The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment |
title_fullStr | The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment |
title_full_unstemmed | The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment |
title_short | The Added Value of Subcutaneous Peripheral Nerve Field Stimulation Combined with SCS, as Salvage Therapy, for Refractory Low Back Pain Component in Persistent Spinal Pain Syndrome Implanted Patients: A Randomized Controlled Study (CUMPNS Study) Based on 3D-Mapping Composite Pain Assessment |
title_sort | added value of subcutaneous peripheral nerve field stimulation combined with scs, as salvage therapy, for refractory low back pain component in persistent spinal pain syndrome implanted patients: a randomized controlled study (cumpns study) based on 3d-mapping composite pain assessment |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8584602/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34768614 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm10215094 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT rigoardphilippe theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT ounajimamine theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT goudmanlisa theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT bouchebenedicte theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT roulaudmanuel theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT pagephilippe theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT lorgeouxbertille theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT baronsandrine theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT nivolekevin theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT manymathilde theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT adjalinihel theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT charrierelodie theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT rannoudelphine theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT poupinlaure theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT woodchantal theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT davidromain theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT herauddylan theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT moensmaartens theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT billotmaxime theaddedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT rigoardphilippe addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT ounajimamine addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT goudmanlisa addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT bouchebenedicte addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT roulaudmanuel addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT pagephilippe addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT lorgeouxbertille addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT baronsandrine addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT nivolekevin addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT manymathilde addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT adjalinihel addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT charrierelodie addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT rannoudelphine addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT poupinlaure addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT woodchantal addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT davidromain addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT herauddylan addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT moensmaartens addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment AT billotmaxime addedvalueofsubcutaneousperipheralnervefieldstimulationcombinedwithscsassalvagetherapyforrefractorylowbackpaincomponentinpersistentspinalpainsyndromeimplantedpatientsarandomizedcontrolledstudycumpnsstudybasedon3dmappingcompositepainassessment |