Cargando…

Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics

AIMS: Application of advanced molecular pathology in rare tumours is hindered by low sample numbers, access to specialised expertise/technologies and tissue/assay QC and rapid reporting requirements. We assessed the feasibility of co‐ordinated real‐time centralised pathology review (CPR), encompassi...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Crosier, Stephen, Hicks, Debbie, Schwalbe, Edward C., Williamson, Daniel, Leigh Nicholson, Sarah, Smith, Amanda, Lindsey, Janet C., Michalski, Antony, Pizer, Barry, Bailey, Simon, Bown, Nick, Cuthbert, Gavin, Wharton, Stephen B., Jacques, Thomas S., Joshi, Abhijit, Clifford, Steven C.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8600954/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33826763
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/nan.12716
_version_ 1784601253990367232
author Crosier, Stephen
Hicks, Debbie
Schwalbe, Edward C.
Williamson, Daniel
Leigh Nicholson, Sarah
Smith, Amanda
Lindsey, Janet C.
Michalski, Antony
Pizer, Barry
Bailey, Simon
Bown, Nick
Cuthbert, Gavin
Wharton, Stephen B.
Jacques, Thomas S.
Joshi, Abhijit
Clifford, Steven C.
author_facet Crosier, Stephen
Hicks, Debbie
Schwalbe, Edward C.
Williamson, Daniel
Leigh Nicholson, Sarah
Smith, Amanda
Lindsey, Janet C.
Michalski, Antony
Pizer, Barry
Bailey, Simon
Bown, Nick
Cuthbert, Gavin
Wharton, Stephen B.
Jacques, Thomas S.
Joshi, Abhijit
Clifford, Steven C.
author_sort Crosier, Stephen
collection PubMed
description AIMS: Application of advanced molecular pathology in rare tumours is hindered by low sample numbers, access to specialised expertise/technologies and tissue/assay QC and rapid reporting requirements. We assessed the feasibility of co‐ordinated real‐time centralised pathology review (CPR), encompassing molecular diagnostics and contemporary genomics (RNA‐seq/DNA methylation‐array). METHODS: This nationwide trial in medulloblastoma (<80 UK diagnoses/year) introduced a national reference centre (NRC) and assessed its performance and reporting to World Health Organisation standards. Paired frozen/formalin‐fixed, paraffin‐embedded tumour material were co‐submitted from 135 patients (16 referral centres). RESULTS: Complete CPR diagnostics were successful for 88% (120/135). Inadequate sampling was the most common cause of failure; biomaterials were typically suitable for methylation‐array (129/135, 94%), but frozen tissues commonly fell below RNA‐seq QC requirements (53/135, 39%). Late reporting was most often due to delayed submission. CPR assigned or altered histological variant (vs local diagnosis) for 40/135 tumours (30%). Benchmarking/QC of specific biomarker assays impacted test results; fluorescent in‐situ hybridisation most accurately identified high‐risk MYC/MYCN amplification (20/135, 15%), while combined methods (CTNNB1/chr6 status, methylation‐array subgrouping) best defined favourable‐risk WNT tumours (14/135; 10%). Engagement of a specialist pathologist panel was essential for consensus assessment of histological variants and immunohistochemistry. Overall, CPR altered clinical risk‐status for 29% of patients. CONCLUSION: National real‐time CPR is feasible, delivering robust diagnostics to WHO criteria and assignment of clinical risk‐status, significantly altering clinical management. Recommendations and experience from our study are applicable to advanced molecular diagnostics systems, both local and centralised, across rare tumour types, enabling their application in biomarker‐driven routine diagnostics and clinical/research studies.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8600954
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-86009542021-11-23 Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics Crosier, Stephen Hicks, Debbie Schwalbe, Edward C. Williamson, Daniel Leigh Nicholson, Sarah Smith, Amanda Lindsey, Janet C. Michalski, Antony Pizer, Barry Bailey, Simon Bown, Nick Cuthbert, Gavin Wharton, Stephen B. Jacques, Thomas S. Joshi, Abhijit Clifford, Steven C. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol Original Articles AIMS: Application of advanced molecular pathology in rare tumours is hindered by low sample numbers, access to specialised expertise/technologies and tissue/assay QC and rapid reporting requirements. We assessed the feasibility of co‐ordinated real‐time centralised pathology review (CPR), encompassing molecular diagnostics and contemporary genomics (RNA‐seq/DNA methylation‐array). METHODS: This nationwide trial in medulloblastoma (<80 UK diagnoses/year) introduced a national reference centre (NRC) and assessed its performance and reporting to World Health Organisation standards. Paired frozen/formalin‐fixed, paraffin‐embedded tumour material were co‐submitted from 135 patients (16 referral centres). RESULTS: Complete CPR diagnostics were successful for 88% (120/135). Inadequate sampling was the most common cause of failure; biomaterials were typically suitable for methylation‐array (129/135, 94%), but frozen tissues commonly fell below RNA‐seq QC requirements (53/135, 39%). Late reporting was most often due to delayed submission. CPR assigned or altered histological variant (vs local diagnosis) for 40/135 tumours (30%). Benchmarking/QC of specific biomarker assays impacted test results; fluorescent in‐situ hybridisation most accurately identified high‐risk MYC/MYCN amplification (20/135, 15%), while combined methods (CTNNB1/chr6 status, methylation‐array subgrouping) best defined favourable‐risk WNT tumours (14/135; 10%). Engagement of a specialist pathologist panel was essential for consensus assessment of histological variants and immunohistochemistry. Overall, CPR altered clinical risk‐status for 29% of patients. CONCLUSION: National real‐time CPR is feasible, delivering robust diagnostics to WHO criteria and assignment of clinical risk‐status, significantly altering clinical management. Recommendations and experience from our study are applicable to advanced molecular diagnostics systems, both local and centralised, across rare tumour types, enabling their application in biomarker‐driven routine diagnostics and clinical/research studies. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021-05-02 2021-10 /pmc/articles/PMC8600954/ /pubmed/33826763 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/nan.12716 Text en © 2021 The Authors. Neuropathology and Applied Neurobiology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of British Neuropathological Society. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Original Articles
Crosier, Stephen
Hicks, Debbie
Schwalbe, Edward C.
Williamson, Daniel
Leigh Nicholson, Sarah
Smith, Amanda
Lindsey, Janet C.
Michalski, Antony
Pizer, Barry
Bailey, Simon
Bown, Nick
Cuthbert, Gavin
Wharton, Stephen B.
Jacques, Thomas S.
Joshi, Abhijit
Clifford, Steven C.
Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
title Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
title_full Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
title_fullStr Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
title_full_unstemmed Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
title_short Advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: A national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
title_sort advanced molecular pathology for rare tumours: a national feasibility study and model for centralised medulloblastoma diagnostics
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8600954/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33826763
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/nan.12716
work_keys_str_mv AT crosierstephen advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT hicksdebbie advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT schwalbeedwardc advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT williamsondaniel advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT leighnicholsonsarah advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT smithamanda advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT lindseyjanetc advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT michalskiantony advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT pizerbarry advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT baileysimon advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT bownnick advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT cuthbertgavin advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT whartonstephenb advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT jacquesthomass advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT joshiabhijit advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics
AT cliffordstevenc advancedmolecularpathologyforraretumoursanationalfeasibilitystudyandmodelforcentralisedmedulloblastomadiagnostics