Cargando…
Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies
BACKGROUND: With the rapid rise in COVID 19 cases incomparable to the number of vaccinations available, there has been a demand to prioritize the older age groups receiving the vaccine as they have more risk of morbidity and mortality and thus better outcome from vaccination. MAIN BODY: Some studies...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8637024/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s43054-021-00086-8 |
_version_ | 1784608658581094400 |
---|---|
author | AbdelMassih, Antoine El Shershaby, Meryam Gaber, Hanya Habib, Menna Gamal, Nada Husseiny, Reem AlShehry, Nada Amin, Abeer Heikal, Bassant El-Husseiny, Nadine Moursi, Mai Ismail, Habiba-Allah Senoussy, Sara ElSharkawy, Reem AlZayat, Hebat Allah ElMahdy, Ghada Moawad, Hossameldin Genena, Ali ElKiki, Ahmed Reda, Mary Khalil, Mohamed Al Ramady, Reem Radwan, Noran Khaled-Ibn-ElWalid, Mariam Amin, Hager Hozaien, Rafeef Kamel, Aya Fouda, Raghda |
author_facet | AbdelMassih, Antoine El Shershaby, Meryam Gaber, Hanya Habib, Menna Gamal, Nada Husseiny, Reem AlShehry, Nada Amin, Abeer Heikal, Bassant El-Husseiny, Nadine Moursi, Mai Ismail, Habiba-Allah Senoussy, Sara ElSharkawy, Reem AlZayat, Hebat Allah ElMahdy, Ghada Moawad, Hossameldin Genena, Ali ElKiki, Ahmed Reda, Mary Khalil, Mohamed Al Ramady, Reem Radwan, Noran Khaled-Ibn-ElWalid, Mariam Amin, Hager Hozaien, Rafeef Kamel, Aya Fouda, Raghda |
author_sort | AbdelMassih, Antoine |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: With the rapid rise in COVID 19 cases incomparable to the number of vaccinations available, there has been a demand to prioritize the older age groups receiving the vaccine as they have more risk of morbidity and mortality and thus better outcome from vaccination. MAIN BODY: Some studies showed a lower seroconversion rate in older group patients; thus, we discuss the necessity to reprioritize vaccinations to younger age groups who have better seroconversion rates, but we may face some ethical dilemma that could hinder our hypothesis. Decreased seroconversion rates in adults are attributable to immuno-senescence which involves a decrease in humoral and cellular-mediated immunity with age. Despite this fact, there remains some ethical dilemma that can hinder widespread vaccination of younger generations, the most important of which is the unknown long-term effects of COVID-19 vaccines due their fast-tracking under the pressure of the pandemic. SHORT CONCLUSION: Prioritizing children vaccination against COVID-19 seems an interesting strategy that can help in containing the pandemic. Resolving some ethical dilemma needs to be done before implementing such strategy. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8637024 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Springer Berlin Heidelberg |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-86370242021-12-02 Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies AbdelMassih, Antoine El Shershaby, Meryam Gaber, Hanya Habib, Menna Gamal, Nada Husseiny, Reem AlShehry, Nada Amin, Abeer Heikal, Bassant El-Husseiny, Nadine Moursi, Mai Ismail, Habiba-Allah Senoussy, Sara ElSharkawy, Reem AlZayat, Hebat Allah ElMahdy, Ghada Moawad, Hossameldin Genena, Ali ElKiki, Ahmed Reda, Mary Khalil, Mohamed Al Ramady, Reem Radwan, Noran Khaled-Ibn-ElWalid, Mariam Amin, Hager Hozaien, Rafeef Kamel, Aya Fouda, Raghda Egypt Pediatric Association Gaz Review BACKGROUND: With the rapid rise in COVID 19 cases incomparable to the number of vaccinations available, there has been a demand to prioritize the older age groups receiving the vaccine as they have more risk of morbidity and mortality and thus better outcome from vaccination. MAIN BODY: Some studies showed a lower seroconversion rate in older group patients; thus, we discuss the necessity to reprioritize vaccinations to younger age groups who have better seroconversion rates, but we may face some ethical dilemma that could hinder our hypothesis. Decreased seroconversion rates in adults are attributable to immuno-senescence which involves a decrease in humoral and cellular-mediated immunity with age. Despite this fact, there remains some ethical dilemma that can hinder widespread vaccination of younger generations, the most important of which is the unknown long-term effects of COVID-19 vaccines due their fast-tracking under the pressure of the pandemic. SHORT CONCLUSION: Prioritizing children vaccination against COVID-19 seems an interesting strategy that can help in containing the pandemic. Resolving some ethical dilemma needs to be done before implementing such strategy. Springer Berlin Heidelberg 2021-12-02 2021 /pmc/articles/PMC8637024/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s43054-021-00086-8 Text en © The Author(s) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . |
spellingShingle | Review AbdelMassih, Antoine El Shershaby, Meryam Gaber, Hanya Habib, Menna Gamal, Nada Husseiny, Reem AlShehry, Nada Amin, Abeer Heikal, Bassant El-Husseiny, Nadine Moursi, Mai Ismail, Habiba-Allah Senoussy, Sara ElSharkawy, Reem AlZayat, Hebat Allah ElMahdy, Ghada Moawad, Hossameldin Genena, Ali ElKiki, Ahmed Reda, Mary Khalil, Mohamed Al Ramady, Reem Radwan, Noran Khaled-Ibn-ElWalid, Mariam Amin, Hager Hozaien, Rafeef Kamel, Aya Fouda, Raghda Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
title | Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
title_full | Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
title_fullStr | Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
title_full_unstemmed | Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
title_short | Should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? Game changing insights for COVID-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
title_sort | should we vaccinate the better seroconverters or the most vulnerable? game changing insights for covid-19 vaccine prioritization policies |
topic | Review |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8637024/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s43054-021-00086-8 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT abdelmassihantoine shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT elshershabymeryam shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT gaberhanya shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT habibmenna shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT gamalnada shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT husseinyreem shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT alshehrynada shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT aminabeer shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT heikalbassant shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT elhusseinynadine shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT moursimai shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT ismailhabibaallah shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT senoussysara shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT elsharkawyreem shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT alzayathebatallah shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT elmahdyghada shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT moawadhossameldin shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT genenaali shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT elkikiahmed shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT redamary shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT khalilmohamed shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT alramadyreem shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT radwannoran shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT khaledibnelwalidmariam shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT aminhager shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT hozaienrafeef shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT kamelaya shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies AT foudaraghda shouldwevaccinatethebetterseroconvertersorthemostvulnerablegamechanginginsightsforcovid19vaccineprioritizationpolicies |