Cargando…
41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients
BACKGROUND: COVID-19 patients can remain positive by PCR-testing for several months. Pre-admission or pre-procedure testing can identify recovered asymptomatic patients who may no longer be contagious but would require precautions according to current CDC recommendations (10 days). This can result i...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8643758/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofab466.041 |
_version_ | 1784609926655508480 |
---|---|
author | Gohil, Shruti K Maurice, Annabelle De St Yokoe, Deborah S Yokoe, Deborah S Cohen, Stuart H Torriani, Francesca J Grein, Jonathan Robinson, Philip A Mabalot, Shannon C Pedrani, Paula Park, Jessica Platt, Richard Huang, Susan S |
author_facet | Gohil, Shruti K Maurice, Annabelle De St Yokoe, Deborah S Yokoe, Deborah S Cohen, Stuart H Torriani, Francesca J Grein, Jonathan Robinson, Philip A Mabalot, Shannon C Pedrani, Paula Park, Jessica Platt, Richard Huang, Susan S |
author_sort | Gohil, Shruti K |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: COVID-19 patients can remain positive by PCR-testing for several months. Pre-admission or pre-procedure testing can identify recovered asymptomatic patients who may no longer be contagious but would require precautions according to current CDC recommendations (10 days). This can result in unintended consequences, including procedure delays or transfer to appropriate care (e.g., psychiatric or post-trauma patients requiring admission to COVID-19 units instead of psychiatric or rehabilitation facilities, respectively). METHODS: We conducted a structured survey of healthcare epidemiologists and infection prevention experts from the SHEA Research Network between March-April, 2021. The 14-question survey, presented a series of COVID-19 PCR+ asymptomatic patient case scenarios and asked respondents if (1) they would consider the case recovered and not infectious, (2) if they have cleared precautions in such cases, and if so, (3) how many transmission events occurred after discontinuing precautions. The survey used one or a combination of 5 criteria: history of COVID-19 symptoms, history of exposure to a household member with COVID-19, COVID-19 PCR cycle threshold (CT), and IgG serology. Percentages were calculated among respondents for each question. RESULTS: Among 60 respondents, 56 (93%) were physicians, 51 (86%) were hospital epidemiologists, and 46 (77%) had >10y infection prevention experience. They represented facilities that cumulatively cared for >29,000 COVID-19 cases; 46 (77%) were academic, and 42 (69%) were large ( >400 beds). One-third to one-half would consider an incidentally found PCR+ case as recovered based on solo criteria, particularly those with two consecutive high CTs or COVID IgG positivity recovered (53-55%) (Table 1). When combining two criteria, half to four-fifths of respondents deemed PCR+ cases to be recovered (Table 2). Half of those had used those criteria to clear precautions (45-64%) and few to none experienced a subsequent transmission event resulting from clearance. CONCLUSION: The majority of healthcare epidemiologists consider a combination of clinical and diagnostic criteria as recovered and many have used these to clear precautions without high numbers of transmission. [Image: see text] [Image: see text] DISCLOSURES: Shruti K. Gohil, MD, MPH, Medline (Other Financial or Material Support, Co-Investigator in studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Molnycke (Other Financial or Material Support, Co-Investigator in studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Stryker (Sage) (Other Financial or Material Support, Co-Investigator in studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products) Deborah S. Yokoe, MD, MPH, Nothing to disclose Stuart H. Cohen, MD, Seres (Research Grant or Support) Jonathan Grein, MD, Gilead (Other Financial or Material Support, Speakers fees) Richard Platt, MD, MSc, Medline (Research Grant or Support, Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals received contributed antiseptic product)Molnlycke (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals received contributed antiseptic product) Susan S. Huang, MD, MPH, Medline (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Molnlycke (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Stryker (Sage) (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Xttrium (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products) |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8643758 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-86437582021-12-06 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients Gohil, Shruti K Maurice, Annabelle De St Yokoe, Deborah S Yokoe, Deborah S Cohen, Stuart H Torriani, Francesca J Grein, Jonathan Robinson, Philip A Mabalot, Shannon C Pedrani, Paula Park, Jessica Platt, Richard Huang, Susan S Open Forum Infect Dis Oral Abstracts BACKGROUND: COVID-19 patients can remain positive by PCR-testing for several months. Pre-admission or pre-procedure testing can identify recovered asymptomatic patients who may no longer be contagious but would require precautions according to current CDC recommendations (10 days). This can result in unintended consequences, including procedure delays or transfer to appropriate care (e.g., psychiatric or post-trauma patients requiring admission to COVID-19 units instead of psychiatric or rehabilitation facilities, respectively). METHODS: We conducted a structured survey of healthcare epidemiologists and infection prevention experts from the SHEA Research Network between March-April, 2021. The 14-question survey, presented a series of COVID-19 PCR+ asymptomatic patient case scenarios and asked respondents if (1) they would consider the case recovered and not infectious, (2) if they have cleared precautions in such cases, and if so, (3) how many transmission events occurred after discontinuing precautions. The survey used one or a combination of 5 criteria: history of COVID-19 symptoms, history of exposure to a household member with COVID-19, COVID-19 PCR cycle threshold (CT), and IgG serology. Percentages were calculated among respondents for each question. RESULTS: Among 60 respondents, 56 (93%) were physicians, 51 (86%) were hospital epidemiologists, and 46 (77%) had >10y infection prevention experience. They represented facilities that cumulatively cared for >29,000 COVID-19 cases; 46 (77%) were academic, and 42 (69%) were large ( >400 beds). One-third to one-half would consider an incidentally found PCR+ case as recovered based on solo criteria, particularly those with two consecutive high CTs or COVID IgG positivity recovered (53-55%) (Table 1). When combining two criteria, half to four-fifths of respondents deemed PCR+ cases to be recovered (Table 2). Half of those had used those criteria to clear precautions (45-64%) and few to none experienced a subsequent transmission event resulting from clearance. CONCLUSION: The majority of healthcare epidemiologists consider a combination of clinical and diagnostic criteria as recovered and many have used these to clear precautions without high numbers of transmission. [Image: see text] [Image: see text] DISCLOSURES: Shruti K. Gohil, MD, MPH, Medline (Other Financial or Material Support, Co-Investigator in studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Molnycke (Other Financial or Material Support, Co-Investigator in studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Stryker (Sage) (Other Financial or Material Support, Co-Investigator in studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products) Deborah S. Yokoe, MD, MPH, Nothing to disclose Stuart H. Cohen, MD, Seres (Research Grant or Support) Jonathan Grein, MD, Gilead (Other Financial or Material Support, Speakers fees) Richard Platt, MD, MSc, Medline (Research Grant or Support, Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals received contributed antiseptic product)Molnlycke (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals received contributed antiseptic product) Susan S. Huang, MD, MPH, Medline (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Molnlycke (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Stryker (Sage) (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products)Xttrium (Other Financial or Material Support, Conducted studies in which participating hospitals and nursing homes received contributed antiseptic and cleaning products) Oxford University Press 2021-12-04 /pmc/articles/PMC8643758/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofab466.041 Text en © The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Oral Abstracts Gohil, Shruti K Maurice, Annabelle De St Yokoe, Deborah S Yokoe, Deborah S Cohen, Stuart H Torriani, Francesca J Grein, Jonathan Robinson, Philip A Mabalot, Shannon C Pedrani, Paula Park, Jessica Platt, Richard Huang, Susan S 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients |
title | 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients |
title_full | 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients |
title_fullStr | 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients |
title_full_unstemmed | 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients |
title_short | 41. Assessing Past vs Present COVID-19 Infection: A Survey of Criteria for Discontinuing Precautions in Asymptomatic Patients |
title_sort | 41. assessing past vs present covid-19 infection: a survey of criteria for discontinuing precautions in asymptomatic patients |
topic | Oral Abstracts |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8643758/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofab466.041 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT gohilshrutik 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT mauriceannabelledest 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT yokoedeborahs 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT yokoedeborahs 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT cohenstuarth 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT torrianifrancescaj 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT greinjonathan 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT robinsonphilipa 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT mabalotshannonc 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT pedranipaula 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT parkjessica 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT plattrichard 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients AT huangsusans 41assessingpastvspresentcovid19infectionasurveyofcriteriafordiscontinuingprecautionsinasymptomaticpatients |