Cargando…
ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable
Background: To improve the control of hypertension in low- and middle-income countries, we trialed a community-based group program co-designed with local policy makers to fit within the framework of India's health system. Trained accredited social health activists (ASHAs), delivered the program...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8645590/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34881267 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2021.771822 |
_version_ | 1784610338568667136 |
---|---|
author | Riddell, Michaela A. Mini, G. K. Joshi, Rohina Thrift, Amanda G. Guggilla, Rama K. Evans, Roger G. Thankappan, Kavumpurathu R. Chalmers, Kate Chow, Clara K. Mahal, Ajay S. Kalyanram, Kartik Kartik, Kamakshi Suresh, Oduru Thomas, Nihal Maulik, Pallab K. Srikanth, Velandai K. Arabshahi, Simin Varma, Ravi P. D'Esposito, Fabrizio Oldenburg, Brian |
author_facet | Riddell, Michaela A. Mini, G. K. Joshi, Rohina Thrift, Amanda G. Guggilla, Rama K. Evans, Roger G. Thankappan, Kavumpurathu R. Chalmers, Kate Chow, Clara K. Mahal, Ajay S. Kalyanram, Kartik Kartik, Kamakshi Suresh, Oduru Thomas, Nihal Maulik, Pallab K. Srikanth, Velandai K. Arabshahi, Simin Varma, Ravi P. D'Esposito, Fabrizio Oldenburg, Brian |
author_sort | Riddell, Michaela A. |
collection | PubMed |
description | Background: To improve the control of hypertension in low- and middle-income countries, we trialed a community-based group program co-designed with local policy makers to fit within the framework of India's health system. Trained accredited social health activists (ASHAs), delivered the program, in three economically and developmentally diverse settings in rural India. We evaluated the program's implementation and scalability. Methods: Our mixed methods process evaluation was guided by the United Kingdom Medical Research Council guidelines for complex interventions. Meeting attendance reports, as well as blood pressure and weight measures of attendees and adherence to meeting content and use of meeting tools were used to evaluate the implementation process. Thematic analysis of separate focus group discussions with participants and ASHAs as well as meeting reports and participant evaluation were used to investigate the mechanisms of impact. Results: Fifteen ASHAs led 32 community-based groups in three rural settings in the states of Kerala and Andhra Pradesh, Southern India. Overall, the fidelity of intervention delivery was high. Six meetings were delivered over a 3-month period to each of the intervention groups. The mean number of meetings attended by participants at each site varied significantly, with participants in Rishi Valley attending fewer meetings [mean (SD) = 2.83 (1.68)] than participants in West Godavari (Tukeys test, p = 0.009) and Trivandrum (Tukeys test, p < 0.001) and participants in West Godavari [mean (SD) = 3.48 (1.72)] attending significantly fewer meetings than participants in Trivandrum [mean (SD) = 4.29 (1.76), Tukeys test, p < 0.001]. Culturally appropriate intervention resources and the training of ASHAs, and supportive supervision of them during the program were critical enablers to program implementation. Although highly motivated during the implementation of the program ASHA reported historical issues with timely remuneration and lack of supportive supervision. Conclusions: Culturally appropriate community-based group programs run by trained and supported ASHAs are a successful and potentially scalable model for improving the control of hypertension in rural India. However, consideration of issues related to unreliable/insufficient remuneration for ASHAs, supportive supervision and their formal role in the wider health workforce in India will be important to address in future program scale up. Trial Registration: Clinical Trial Registry of India [CTRI/2016/02/006678, Registered prospectively]. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8645590 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-86455902021-12-07 ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable Riddell, Michaela A. Mini, G. K. Joshi, Rohina Thrift, Amanda G. Guggilla, Rama K. Evans, Roger G. Thankappan, Kavumpurathu R. Chalmers, Kate Chow, Clara K. Mahal, Ajay S. Kalyanram, Kartik Kartik, Kamakshi Suresh, Oduru Thomas, Nihal Maulik, Pallab K. Srikanth, Velandai K. Arabshahi, Simin Varma, Ravi P. D'Esposito, Fabrizio Oldenburg, Brian Front Med (Lausanne) Medicine Background: To improve the control of hypertension in low- and middle-income countries, we trialed a community-based group program co-designed with local policy makers to fit within the framework of India's health system. Trained accredited social health activists (ASHAs), delivered the program, in three economically and developmentally diverse settings in rural India. We evaluated the program's implementation and scalability. Methods: Our mixed methods process evaluation was guided by the United Kingdom Medical Research Council guidelines for complex interventions. Meeting attendance reports, as well as blood pressure and weight measures of attendees and adherence to meeting content and use of meeting tools were used to evaluate the implementation process. Thematic analysis of separate focus group discussions with participants and ASHAs as well as meeting reports and participant evaluation were used to investigate the mechanisms of impact. Results: Fifteen ASHAs led 32 community-based groups in three rural settings in the states of Kerala and Andhra Pradesh, Southern India. Overall, the fidelity of intervention delivery was high. Six meetings were delivered over a 3-month period to each of the intervention groups. The mean number of meetings attended by participants at each site varied significantly, with participants in Rishi Valley attending fewer meetings [mean (SD) = 2.83 (1.68)] than participants in West Godavari (Tukeys test, p = 0.009) and Trivandrum (Tukeys test, p < 0.001) and participants in West Godavari [mean (SD) = 3.48 (1.72)] attending significantly fewer meetings than participants in Trivandrum [mean (SD) = 4.29 (1.76), Tukeys test, p < 0.001]. Culturally appropriate intervention resources and the training of ASHAs, and supportive supervision of them during the program were critical enablers to program implementation. Although highly motivated during the implementation of the program ASHA reported historical issues with timely remuneration and lack of supportive supervision. Conclusions: Culturally appropriate community-based group programs run by trained and supported ASHAs are a successful and potentially scalable model for improving the control of hypertension in rural India. However, consideration of issues related to unreliable/insufficient remuneration for ASHAs, supportive supervision and their formal role in the wider health workforce in India will be important to address in future program scale up. Trial Registration: Clinical Trial Registry of India [CTRI/2016/02/006678, Registered prospectively]. Frontiers Media S.A. 2021-11-22 /pmc/articles/PMC8645590/ /pubmed/34881267 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2021.771822 Text en Copyright © 2021 Riddell, Mini, Joshi, Thrift, Guggilla, Evans, Thankappan, Chalmers, Chow, Mahal, Kalyanram, Kartik, Suresh, Thomas, Maulik, Srikanth, Arabshahi, Varma, D'Esposito and Oldenburg. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms. |
spellingShingle | Medicine Riddell, Michaela A. Mini, G. K. Joshi, Rohina Thrift, Amanda G. Guggilla, Rama K. Evans, Roger G. Thankappan, Kavumpurathu R. Chalmers, Kate Chow, Clara K. Mahal, Ajay S. Kalyanram, Kartik Kartik, Kamakshi Suresh, Oduru Thomas, Nihal Maulik, Pallab K. Srikanth, Velandai K. Arabshahi, Simin Varma, Ravi P. D'Esposito, Fabrizio Oldenburg, Brian ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable |
title | ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable |
title_full | ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable |
title_fullStr | ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable |
title_full_unstemmed | ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable |
title_short | ASHA-Led Community-Based Groups to Support Control of Hypertension in Rural India Are Feasible and Potentially Scalable |
title_sort | asha-led community-based groups to support control of hypertension in rural india are feasible and potentially scalable |
topic | Medicine |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8645590/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34881267 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2021.771822 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT riddellmichaelaa ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT minigk ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT joshirohina ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT thriftamandag ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT guggillaramak ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT evansrogerg ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT thankappankavumpurathur ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT chalmerskate ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT chowclarak ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT mahalajays ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT kalyanramkartik ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT kartikkamakshi ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT sureshoduru ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT thomasnihal ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT maulikpallabk ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT srikanthvelandaik ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT arabshahisimin ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT varmaravip ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT despositofabrizio ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable AT oldenburgbrian ashaledcommunitybasedgroupstosupportcontrolofhypertensioninruralindiaarefeasibleandpotentiallyscalable |