Cargando…

Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity

OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether calcium derangement was a specific feature of COVID-19 that distinguishes it from other infective pneumonias, and its association with disease severity. DESIGN: A retrospective observational case–control study looking at serum calcium on adult patients with COVID-1...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Mehta, Meera, Ghani, Hakim, Chua, Felix, Draper, Adrian, Calmonson, Sam, Prabhakar, Meghna, Shah, Rijul, Navarra, Alessio, Vaghela, Tejal, Barlow, Andrew, Vancheeswaran, Rama
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BMJ Publishing Group 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8655344/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34876435
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2021-053810
_version_ 1784612052064534528
author Mehta, Meera
Ghani, Hakim
Chua, Felix
Draper, Adrian
Calmonson, Sam
Prabhakar, Meghna
Shah, Rijul
Navarra, Alessio
Vaghela, Tejal
Barlow, Andrew
Vancheeswaran, Rama
author_facet Mehta, Meera
Ghani, Hakim
Chua, Felix
Draper, Adrian
Calmonson, Sam
Prabhakar, Meghna
Shah, Rijul
Navarra, Alessio
Vaghela, Tejal
Barlow, Andrew
Vancheeswaran, Rama
author_sort Mehta, Meera
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether calcium derangement was a specific feature of COVID-19 that distinguishes it from other infective pneumonias, and its association with disease severity. DESIGN: A retrospective observational case–control study looking at serum calcium on adult patients with COVID-19, and community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) or viral pneumonia (VP). SETTING: A district general hospital on the outskirts of London, UK. PARTICIPANTS: 506 patients with COVID-19, 95 patients with CAP and 152 patients with VP. OUTCOME MEASURES: Baseline characteristics including hypocalcaemia in patients with COVID-19, CAP and VP were detailed. For patients with COVID-19, the impact of an abnormally low calcium level on the maximum level of hospital care, as a surrogate of COVID-19 severity, was evaluated. The primary outcome of maximal level of care was based on the WHO Clinical Progression Scale for COVID-19. RESULTS: Hypocalcaemia was a specific and common clinical finding in patients with COVID-19 that distinguished it from other respiratory infections. Calcium levels were significantly lower in those with severe disease. Ordinal regression of risk estimates for categorised care levels showed that baseline hypocalcaemia was incrementally associated with OR of 2.33 (95% CI 1.5 to 3.61) for higher level of care, superior to other variables that have previously been shown to predict worse COVID-19 outcome. Serial calcium levels showed improvement by days 7–9 of admission, only in survivors of COVID-19. CONCLUSION: Hypocalcaemia is specific to COVID-19 and may help distinguish it from other infective pneumonias. Hypocalcaemia may independently predict severe disease and warrants detailed prognostic investigation. The fact that decreased serum calcium is observed at the time of clinical presentation in COVID-19, but not other infective pneumonias, suggests that its early derangement is pathophysiological and may influence the deleterious evolution of this disease. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: 20/HRA/2344.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8655344
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher BMJ Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-86553442021-12-10 Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity Mehta, Meera Ghani, Hakim Chua, Felix Draper, Adrian Calmonson, Sam Prabhakar, Meghna Shah, Rijul Navarra, Alessio Vaghela, Tejal Barlow, Andrew Vancheeswaran, Rama BMJ Open Respiratory Medicine OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether calcium derangement was a specific feature of COVID-19 that distinguishes it from other infective pneumonias, and its association with disease severity. DESIGN: A retrospective observational case–control study looking at serum calcium on adult patients with COVID-19, and community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) or viral pneumonia (VP). SETTING: A district general hospital on the outskirts of London, UK. PARTICIPANTS: 506 patients with COVID-19, 95 patients with CAP and 152 patients with VP. OUTCOME MEASURES: Baseline characteristics including hypocalcaemia in patients with COVID-19, CAP and VP were detailed. For patients with COVID-19, the impact of an abnormally low calcium level on the maximum level of hospital care, as a surrogate of COVID-19 severity, was evaluated. The primary outcome of maximal level of care was based on the WHO Clinical Progression Scale for COVID-19. RESULTS: Hypocalcaemia was a specific and common clinical finding in patients with COVID-19 that distinguished it from other respiratory infections. Calcium levels were significantly lower in those with severe disease. Ordinal regression of risk estimates for categorised care levels showed that baseline hypocalcaemia was incrementally associated with OR of 2.33 (95% CI 1.5 to 3.61) for higher level of care, superior to other variables that have previously been shown to predict worse COVID-19 outcome. Serial calcium levels showed improvement by days 7–9 of admission, only in survivors of COVID-19. CONCLUSION: Hypocalcaemia is specific to COVID-19 and may help distinguish it from other infective pneumonias. Hypocalcaemia may independently predict severe disease and warrants detailed prognostic investigation. The fact that decreased serum calcium is observed at the time of clinical presentation in COVID-19, but not other infective pneumonias, suggests that its early derangement is pathophysiological and may influence the deleterious evolution of this disease. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: 20/HRA/2344. BMJ Publishing Group 2021-12-02 /pmc/articles/PMC8655344/ /pubmed/34876435 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2021-053810 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2021. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) .
spellingShingle Respiratory Medicine
Mehta, Meera
Ghani, Hakim
Chua, Felix
Draper, Adrian
Calmonson, Sam
Prabhakar, Meghna
Shah, Rijul
Navarra, Alessio
Vaghela, Tejal
Barlow, Andrew
Vancheeswaran, Rama
Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
title Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
title_full Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
title_fullStr Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
title_full_unstemmed Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
title_short Retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of COVID-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
title_sort retrospective case–control study to evaluate hypocalcaemia as a distinguishing feature of covid-19 compared with other infective pneumonias and its association with disease severity
topic Respiratory Medicine
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8655344/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34876435
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2021-053810
work_keys_str_mv AT mehtameera retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT ghanihakim retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT chuafelix retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT draperadrian retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT calmonsonsam retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT prabhakarmeghna retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT shahrijul retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT navarraalessio retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT vaghelatejal retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT barlowandrew retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity
AT vancheeswaranrama retrospectivecasecontrolstudytoevaluatehypocalcaemiaasadistinguishingfeatureofcovid19comparedwithotherinfectivepneumoniasanditsassociationwithdiseaseseverity