Cargando…

Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review

BACKGROUND: While it has been suspected that different primary cancers have varying predilections for metastasis in certain brain regions, recent advances in neuroimaging and spatial modeling analytics have facilitated further exploration into this field. METHODS: A systematic electronic database se...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Cardinal, Tyler, Pangal, Dhiraj, Strickland, Ben A, Newton, Paul, Mahmoodifar, Saeedeh, Mason, Jeremy, Craig, David, Simon, Thomas, Tew, Ben Yi, Yu, Min, Yang, Wensha, Chang, Eric, Cabeen, Ryan P, Ruzevick, Jacob, Toga, Arthur W, Neman, Josh, Salhia, Bodour, Zada, Gabriel
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8739649/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35024611
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/noajnl/vdab170
_version_ 1784629147046248448
author Cardinal, Tyler
Pangal, Dhiraj
Strickland, Ben A
Newton, Paul
Mahmoodifar, Saeedeh
Mason, Jeremy
Craig, David
Simon, Thomas
Tew, Ben Yi
Yu, Min
Yang, Wensha
Chang, Eric
Cabeen, Ryan P
Ruzevick, Jacob
Toga, Arthur W
Neman, Josh
Salhia, Bodour
Zada, Gabriel
author_facet Cardinal, Tyler
Pangal, Dhiraj
Strickland, Ben A
Newton, Paul
Mahmoodifar, Saeedeh
Mason, Jeremy
Craig, David
Simon, Thomas
Tew, Ben Yi
Yu, Min
Yang, Wensha
Chang, Eric
Cabeen, Ryan P
Ruzevick, Jacob
Toga, Arthur W
Neman, Josh
Salhia, Bodour
Zada, Gabriel
author_sort Cardinal, Tyler
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: While it has been suspected that different primary cancers have varying predilections for metastasis in certain brain regions, recent advances in neuroimaging and spatial modeling analytics have facilitated further exploration into this field. METHODS: A systematic electronic database search for studies analyzing the distribution of brain metastases (BMs) from any primary systematic cancer published between January 1990 and July 2020 was conducted using PRISMA guidelines. RESULTS: Two authors independently reviewed 1957 abstracts, 46 of which underwent full-text analysis. A third author arbitrated both lists; 13 studies met inclusion/exclusion criteria. All were retrospective single- or multi-institution database reviews analyzing over 8227 BMs from 2599 patients with breast (8 studies), lung (7 studies), melanoma (5 studies), gastrointestinal (4 studies), renal (3 studies), and prostate (1 study) cancers. Breast, lung, and colorectal cancers tended to metastasize to more posterior/caudal topographic and vascular neuroanatomical regions, particularly the cerebellum, with notable differences based on subtype and receptor expression. HER-2-positive breast cancers were less likely to arise in the frontal lobes or subcortical region, while ER-positive and PR-positive breast metastases were less likely to arise in the occipital lobe or cerebellum. BM from lung adenocarcinoma tended to arise in the frontal lobes and squamous cell carcinoma in the cerebellum. Melanoma metastasized more to the frontal and temporal lobes. CONCLUSION: The observed topographical distribution of BM likely develops based on primary cancer type, molecular subtype, and genetic profile. Further studies analyzing this association and relationships to vascular distribution are merited to potentially improve patient treatment and outcomes.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8739649
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-87396492022-01-11 Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review Cardinal, Tyler Pangal, Dhiraj Strickland, Ben A Newton, Paul Mahmoodifar, Saeedeh Mason, Jeremy Craig, David Simon, Thomas Tew, Ben Yi Yu, Min Yang, Wensha Chang, Eric Cabeen, Ryan P Ruzevick, Jacob Toga, Arthur W Neman, Josh Salhia, Bodour Zada, Gabriel Neurooncol Adv Review BACKGROUND: While it has been suspected that different primary cancers have varying predilections for metastasis in certain brain regions, recent advances in neuroimaging and spatial modeling analytics have facilitated further exploration into this field. METHODS: A systematic electronic database search for studies analyzing the distribution of brain metastases (BMs) from any primary systematic cancer published between January 1990 and July 2020 was conducted using PRISMA guidelines. RESULTS: Two authors independently reviewed 1957 abstracts, 46 of which underwent full-text analysis. A third author arbitrated both lists; 13 studies met inclusion/exclusion criteria. All were retrospective single- or multi-institution database reviews analyzing over 8227 BMs from 2599 patients with breast (8 studies), lung (7 studies), melanoma (5 studies), gastrointestinal (4 studies), renal (3 studies), and prostate (1 study) cancers. Breast, lung, and colorectal cancers tended to metastasize to more posterior/caudal topographic and vascular neuroanatomical regions, particularly the cerebellum, with notable differences based on subtype and receptor expression. HER-2-positive breast cancers were less likely to arise in the frontal lobes or subcortical region, while ER-positive and PR-positive breast metastases were less likely to arise in the occipital lobe or cerebellum. BM from lung adenocarcinoma tended to arise in the frontal lobes and squamous cell carcinoma in the cerebellum. Melanoma metastasized more to the frontal and temporal lobes. CONCLUSION: The observed topographical distribution of BM likely develops based on primary cancer type, molecular subtype, and genetic profile. Further studies analyzing this association and relationships to vascular distribution are merited to potentially improve patient treatment and outcomes. Oxford University Press 2021-11-18 /pmc/articles/PMC8739649/ /pubmed/35024611 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/noajnl/vdab170 Text en © The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press, the Society for Neuro-Oncology and the European Association of Neuro-Oncology. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Review
Cardinal, Tyler
Pangal, Dhiraj
Strickland, Ben A
Newton, Paul
Mahmoodifar, Saeedeh
Mason, Jeremy
Craig, David
Simon, Thomas
Tew, Ben Yi
Yu, Min
Yang, Wensha
Chang, Eric
Cabeen, Ryan P
Ruzevick, Jacob
Toga, Arthur W
Neman, Josh
Salhia, Bodour
Zada, Gabriel
Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
title Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
title_full Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
title_fullStr Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
title_full_unstemmed Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
title_short Anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
title_sort anatomical and topographical variations in the distribution of brain metastases based on primary cancer origin and molecular subtypes: a systematic review
topic Review
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8739649/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35024611
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/noajnl/vdab170
work_keys_str_mv AT cardinaltyler anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT pangaldhiraj anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT stricklandbena anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT newtonpaul anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT mahmoodifarsaeedeh anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT masonjeremy anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT craigdavid anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT simonthomas anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT tewbenyi anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT yumin anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT yangwensha anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT changeric anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT cabeenryanp anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT ruzevickjacob anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT togaarthurw anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT nemanjosh anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT salhiabodour anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview
AT zadagabriel anatomicalandtopographicalvariationsinthedistributionofbrainmetastasesbasedonprimarycanceroriginandmolecularsubtypesasystematicreview