Cargando…

The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Due to the central role of magnetic resonance Imaging (MRI) in the management of patients with cancer, waiting lists exceed clinically relevant delays. For this reason, many research groups and MRI manufacturers develop algorithms as resampling and denoising models to allow faster ac...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Moummad, Ilyass, Jaudet, Cyril, Lechervy, Alexis, Valable, Samuel, Raboutet, Charlotte, Soilihi, Zamila, Thariat, Juliette, Falzone, Nadia, Lacroix, Joëlle, Batalla, Alain, Corroyer-Dulmont, Aurélien
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8750741/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35008198
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers14010036
_version_ 1784631530055794688
author Moummad, Ilyass
Jaudet, Cyril
Lechervy, Alexis
Valable, Samuel
Raboutet, Charlotte
Soilihi, Zamila
Thariat, Juliette
Falzone, Nadia
Lacroix, Joëlle
Batalla, Alain
Corroyer-Dulmont, Aurélien
author_facet Moummad, Ilyass
Jaudet, Cyril
Lechervy, Alexis
Valable, Samuel
Raboutet, Charlotte
Soilihi, Zamila
Thariat, Juliette
Falzone, Nadia
Lacroix, Joëlle
Batalla, Alain
Corroyer-Dulmont, Aurélien
author_sort Moummad, Ilyass
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Due to the central role of magnetic resonance Imaging (MRI) in the management of patients with cancer, waiting lists exceed clinically relevant delays. For this reason, many research groups and MRI manufacturers develop algorithms as resampling and denoising models to allow faster acquisition time without deterioration in image quality. Whereas these algorithms are available in all new MRI, it is not clear how they will impact image features as well as the validity of statistical model of radiomics which use deep images characteristics to predict treatment outcome. The aim of this study was to develop resampling and denoising deep learning (DL) models and evaluate their impact on radiomics from post-Gd-T1w-MRI brain images with brain metastases. We show that resampling and denoising DL models reconstruct low resolution and noised MRI images acquired quickly into high quality images. While fast acquisition loses most of the radiomic-features and invalidates predictive radiomic models, DL models restore these parameters. ABSTRACT: Background: Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is predominant in the therapeutic management of cancer patients, unfortunately, patients have to wait a long time to get an appointment for examination. Therefore, new MRI devices include deep-learning (DL) solutions to save acquisition time. However, the impact of these algorithms on intensity and texture parameters has been poorly studied. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of resampling and denoising DL models on radiomics. Methods: Resampling and denoising DL model was developed on 14,243 T1 brain images from 1.5T-MRI. Radiomics were extracted from 40 brain metastases from 11 patients (2049 images). A total of 104 texture features of DL images were compared to original images with paired t-test, Pearson correlation and concordance-correlation-coefficient (CCC). Results: When two times shorter image acquisition shows strong disparities with the originals concerning the radiomics, with significant differences and loss of correlation of 79.81% and 48.08%, respectively. Interestingly, DL models restore textures with 46.15% of unstable parameters and 25.96% of low CCC and without difference for the first-order intensity parameters. Conclusions: Resampling and denoising DL models reconstruct low resolution and noised MRI images acquired quickly into high quality images. While fast MRI acquisition loses most of the radiomic features, DL models restore these parameters.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8750741
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-87507412022-01-12 The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI Moummad, Ilyass Jaudet, Cyril Lechervy, Alexis Valable, Samuel Raboutet, Charlotte Soilihi, Zamila Thariat, Juliette Falzone, Nadia Lacroix, Joëlle Batalla, Alain Corroyer-Dulmont, Aurélien Cancers (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Due to the central role of magnetic resonance Imaging (MRI) in the management of patients with cancer, waiting lists exceed clinically relevant delays. For this reason, many research groups and MRI manufacturers develop algorithms as resampling and denoising models to allow faster acquisition time without deterioration in image quality. Whereas these algorithms are available in all new MRI, it is not clear how they will impact image features as well as the validity of statistical model of radiomics which use deep images characteristics to predict treatment outcome. The aim of this study was to develop resampling and denoising deep learning (DL) models and evaluate their impact on radiomics from post-Gd-T1w-MRI brain images with brain metastases. We show that resampling and denoising DL models reconstruct low resolution and noised MRI images acquired quickly into high quality images. While fast acquisition loses most of the radiomic-features and invalidates predictive radiomic models, DL models restore these parameters. ABSTRACT: Background: Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is predominant in the therapeutic management of cancer patients, unfortunately, patients have to wait a long time to get an appointment for examination. Therefore, new MRI devices include deep-learning (DL) solutions to save acquisition time. However, the impact of these algorithms on intensity and texture parameters has been poorly studied. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of resampling and denoising DL models on radiomics. Methods: Resampling and denoising DL model was developed on 14,243 T1 brain images from 1.5T-MRI. Radiomics were extracted from 40 brain metastases from 11 patients (2049 images). A total of 104 texture features of DL images were compared to original images with paired t-test, Pearson correlation and concordance-correlation-coefficient (CCC). Results: When two times shorter image acquisition shows strong disparities with the originals concerning the radiomics, with significant differences and loss of correlation of 79.81% and 48.08%, respectively. Interestingly, DL models restore textures with 46.15% of unstable parameters and 25.96% of low CCC and without difference for the first-order intensity parameters. Conclusions: Resampling and denoising DL models reconstruct low resolution and noised MRI images acquired quickly into high quality images. While fast MRI acquisition loses most of the radiomic features, DL models restore these parameters. MDPI 2021-12-22 /pmc/articles/PMC8750741/ /pubmed/35008198 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers14010036 Text en © 2021 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Moummad, Ilyass
Jaudet, Cyril
Lechervy, Alexis
Valable, Samuel
Raboutet, Charlotte
Soilihi, Zamila
Thariat, Juliette
Falzone, Nadia
Lacroix, Joëlle
Batalla, Alain
Corroyer-Dulmont, Aurélien
The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI
title The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI
title_full The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI
title_fullStr The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI
title_full_unstemmed The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI
title_short The Impact of Resampling and Denoising Deep Learning Algorithms on Radiomics in Brain Metastases MRI
title_sort impact of resampling and denoising deep learning algorithms on radiomics in brain metastases mri
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8750741/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35008198
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers14010036
work_keys_str_mv AT moummadilyass theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT jaudetcyril theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT lechervyalexis theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT valablesamuel theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT raboutetcharlotte theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT soilihizamila theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT thariatjuliette theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT falzonenadia theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT lacroixjoelle theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT batallaalain theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT corroyerdulmontaurelien theimpactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT moummadilyass impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT jaudetcyril impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT lechervyalexis impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT valablesamuel impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT raboutetcharlotte impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT soilihizamila impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT thariatjuliette impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT falzonenadia impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT lacroixjoelle impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT batallaalain impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri
AT corroyerdulmontaurelien impactofresamplinganddenoisingdeeplearningalgorithmsonradiomicsinbrainmetastasesmri