Cargando…

A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland

AIMS: Recruitment into psychiatry is a major issue nationally. Northern Ireland (NI) consistently punching above it's weight with psychiatry recruitment - in a region that only attracts 31.8% of F2s to enter into any training programme, Core psychiatry has been consistently oversubscribed. Here...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Doris, Michael, Mitchell, Kathyrn, Hughes, Damien, Parks, Lorraine, Carragher, Angela
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cambridge University Press 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8771935/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2021.111
_version_ 1784635728649519104
author Doris, Michael
Mitchell, Kathyrn
Hughes, Damien
Parks, Lorraine
Carragher, Angela
author_facet Doris, Michael
Mitchell, Kathyrn
Hughes, Damien
Parks, Lorraine
Carragher, Angela
author_sort Doris, Michael
collection PubMed
description AIMS: Recruitment into psychiatry is a major issue nationally. Northern Ireland (NI) consistently punching above it's weight with psychiatry recruitment - in a region that only attracts 31.8% of F2s to enter into any training programme, Core psychiatry has been consistently oversubscribed. Here we look to examine the experiences of F2s in NI, including those who have had a placement in psychiatry and those who have not - what can we learn from NI? BACKGROUND: The exposure to psychiatry during the F2 year is a crucial time for recruitment to psychiatry. In NI, where there has been an 100% fill rate at core training level for many years, trainees and consultants have pointed towards a positive experience in the F2 year. METHOD: Questionnaires were given out at a sample of F2 Generic Skills sessions, gathering a range of quantitative and qualitative data. A representative sample of over half of current F2s wrote about there preconceptions and experiences of psychiatry, whether they had worked in it or not. An a priori approach was taken towards generating codes as part of a framework analysis from which 4 major themes were identified. RESULT: 93/148 F2 doctors who were approached responded to the survey of which 36.6% had experienced a Foundation placement in psychiatry. Major qualitative themes that emerged were exposure to psychiatry, the nature of working in psychiatry, being valued and stigma. Doctors who had an F2 placement were much more likely to be willing to pursue a career in it, regardless of whether they had been allocated a placement with psychiatry by choice or not. CONCLUSION: This survey adds to the literature that exposure to psychiatry in undergraduate and postgraduate level has a huge role in shaping attitudes towards the specialty of psychiatry, and indeed the likelihood of a foundation doctor going on to become a psychiatry trainee. Stigma in the medical profession towards mental illness and psychiatry remains prevalent.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8771935
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Cambridge University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-87719352022-01-31 A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland Doris, Michael Mitchell, Kathyrn Hughes, Damien Parks, Lorraine Carragher, Angela BJPsych Open Rapid-Fire Poster Presentations AIMS: Recruitment into psychiatry is a major issue nationally. Northern Ireland (NI) consistently punching above it's weight with psychiatry recruitment - in a region that only attracts 31.8% of F2s to enter into any training programme, Core psychiatry has been consistently oversubscribed. Here we look to examine the experiences of F2s in NI, including those who have had a placement in psychiatry and those who have not - what can we learn from NI? BACKGROUND: The exposure to psychiatry during the F2 year is a crucial time for recruitment to psychiatry. In NI, where there has been an 100% fill rate at core training level for many years, trainees and consultants have pointed towards a positive experience in the F2 year. METHOD: Questionnaires were given out at a sample of F2 Generic Skills sessions, gathering a range of quantitative and qualitative data. A representative sample of over half of current F2s wrote about there preconceptions and experiences of psychiatry, whether they had worked in it or not. An a priori approach was taken towards generating codes as part of a framework analysis from which 4 major themes were identified. RESULT: 93/148 F2 doctors who were approached responded to the survey of which 36.6% had experienced a Foundation placement in psychiatry. Major qualitative themes that emerged were exposure to psychiatry, the nature of working in psychiatry, being valued and stigma. Doctors who had an F2 placement were much more likely to be willing to pursue a career in it, regardless of whether they had been allocated a placement with psychiatry by choice or not. CONCLUSION: This survey adds to the literature that exposure to psychiatry in undergraduate and postgraduate level has a huge role in shaping attitudes towards the specialty of psychiatry, and indeed the likelihood of a foundation doctor going on to become a psychiatry trainee. Stigma in the medical profession towards mental illness and psychiatry remains prevalent. Cambridge University Press 2021-06-18 /pmc/articles/PMC8771935/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2021.111 Text en © The Author(s) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Rapid-Fire Poster Presentations
Doris, Michael
Mitchell, Kathyrn
Hughes, Damien
Parks, Lorraine
Carragher, Angela
A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland
title A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland
title_full A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland
title_fullStr A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland
title_full_unstemmed A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland
title_short A qualitative study of foundation year two (F2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in Northern Ireland
title_sort qualitative study of foundation year two (f2) doctor's attitudes towards psychiatry carried out in northern ireland
topic Rapid-Fire Poster Presentations
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8771935/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2021.111
work_keys_str_mv AT dorismichael aqualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT mitchellkathyrn aqualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT hughesdamien aqualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT parkslorraine aqualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT carragherangela aqualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT dorismichael qualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT mitchellkathyrn qualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT hughesdamien qualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT parkslorraine qualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland
AT carragherangela qualitativestudyoffoundationyeartwof2doctorsattitudestowardspsychiatrycarriedoutinnorthernireland