Cargando…

Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning

Seizure prediction is the grand challenge of epileptology. However, effort was devoted to prediction of focal seizures, while generalized seizures were regarded as stochastic events. Long-lasting local field potential (LFP) recordings containing several hundred generalized spike and wave discharges...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Budde, Björn, Maksimenko, Vladimir, Sarink, Kelvin, Seidenbecher, Thomas, van Luijtelaar, Gilles, Hahn, Tim, Pape, Hans-Christian, Lüttjohann, Annika
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Society for Neuroscience 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8856717/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34782347
http://dx.doi.org/10.1523/ENEURO.0160-21.2021
_version_ 1784653906173755392
author Budde, Björn
Maksimenko, Vladimir
Sarink, Kelvin
Seidenbecher, Thomas
van Luijtelaar, Gilles
Hahn, Tim
Pape, Hans-Christian
Lüttjohann, Annika
author_facet Budde, Björn
Maksimenko, Vladimir
Sarink, Kelvin
Seidenbecher, Thomas
van Luijtelaar, Gilles
Hahn, Tim
Pape, Hans-Christian
Lüttjohann, Annika
author_sort Budde, Björn
collection PubMed
description Seizure prediction is the grand challenge of epileptology. However, effort was devoted to prediction of focal seizures, while generalized seizures were regarded as stochastic events. Long-lasting local field potential (LFP) recordings containing several hundred generalized spike and wave discharges (SWDs), acquired at eight locations in the cortico-thalamic system of absence epileptic rats, were iteratively analyzed in all possible combinations of either two or three recording sites, by a wavelet-based algorithm, calculating the product of the wavelet-energy signaling increases in synchronicity. Sensitivity and false alarm rate of prediction were compared between various combinations, and wavelet spectra of true and false positive predictions were fed to a random forest machine learning algorithm to further differentiate between them. Wavelet analysis of intracortical and cortico-thalamic LFP traces showed a significantly smaller number of false alarms compared with intrathalamic combinations, while predictions based on recordings in Layers IV, V, and VI of the somatosensory-cortex significantly outreached all other combinations in terms of prediction sensitivity. In 24-h out-of-sample recordings of nine Genetic Absence Epilepsy Rats from Strasbourg (GAERS), containing diurnal fluctuations of SWD occurrence, classification of true and false positives by the trained random forest further reduced the false alarm rate by 71%, although at some trade-off between false alarms and sensitivity of prediction, as reflected in relatively low F1 score values. Results provide support for the cortical-focus theory of absence epilepsy and allow the conclusion that SWDs are predictable to some degree. The latter paves the way for the development of closed-loop SWD prediction-prevention systems. Suggestions for a possible translation to human data are outlined.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8856717
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Society for Neuroscience
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-88567172022-02-22 Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning Budde, Björn Maksimenko, Vladimir Sarink, Kelvin Seidenbecher, Thomas van Luijtelaar, Gilles Hahn, Tim Pape, Hans-Christian Lüttjohann, Annika eNeuro Research Article: New Research Seizure prediction is the grand challenge of epileptology. However, effort was devoted to prediction of focal seizures, while generalized seizures were regarded as stochastic events. Long-lasting local field potential (LFP) recordings containing several hundred generalized spike and wave discharges (SWDs), acquired at eight locations in the cortico-thalamic system of absence epileptic rats, were iteratively analyzed in all possible combinations of either two or three recording sites, by a wavelet-based algorithm, calculating the product of the wavelet-energy signaling increases in synchronicity. Sensitivity and false alarm rate of prediction were compared between various combinations, and wavelet spectra of true and false positive predictions were fed to a random forest machine learning algorithm to further differentiate between them. Wavelet analysis of intracortical and cortico-thalamic LFP traces showed a significantly smaller number of false alarms compared with intrathalamic combinations, while predictions based on recordings in Layers IV, V, and VI of the somatosensory-cortex significantly outreached all other combinations in terms of prediction sensitivity. In 24-h out-of-sample recordings of nine Genetic Absence Epilepsy Rats from Strasbourg (GAERS), containing diurnal fluctuations of SWD occurrence, classification of true and false positives by the trained random forest further reduced the false alarm rate by 71%, although at some trade-off between false alarms and sensitivity of prediction, as reflected in relatively low F1 score values. Results provide support for the cortical-focus theory of absence epilepsy and allow the conclusion that SWDs are predictable to some degree. The latter paves the way for the development of closed-loop SWD prediction-prevention systems. Suggestions for a possible translation to human data are outlined. Society for Neuroscience 2022-02-08 /pmc/articles/PMC8856717/ /pubmed/34782347 http://dx.doi.org/10.1523/ENEURO.0160-21.2021 Text en Copyright © 2022 Budde et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium provided that the original work is properly attributed.
spellingShingle Research Article: New Research
Budde, Björn
Maksimenko, Vladimir
Sarink, Kelvin
Seidenbecher, Thomas
van Luijtelaar, Gilles
Hahn, Tim
Pape, Hans-Christian
Lüttjohann, Annika
Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning
title Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning
title_full Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning
title_fullStr Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning
title_full_unstemmed Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning
title_short Seizure Prediction in Genetic Rat Models of Absence Epilepsy: Improved Performance through Multiple-Site Cortico-Thalamic Recordings Combined with Machine Learning
title_sort seizure prediction in genetic rat models of absence epilepsy: improved performance through multiple-site cortico-thalamic recordings combined with machine learning
topic Research Article: New Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8856717/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34782347
http://dx.doi.org/10.1523/ENEURO.0160-21.2021
work_keys_str_mv AT buddebjorn seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT maksimenkovladimir seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT sarinkkelvin seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT seidenbecherthomas seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT vanluijtelaargilles seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT hahntim seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT papehanschristian seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning
AT luttjohannannika seizurepredictioningeneticratmodelsofabsenceepilepsyimprovedperformancethroughmultiplesitecorticothalamicrecordingscombinedwithmachinelearning