Cargando…
The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study
The aim of this study was to investigate the COVID-19 vaccination acceptance rate and its determinants among healthcare workers in a multicenter study. This was a cross-sectional multi-center survey conducted from February 5 to April 29, 2021. The questionnaire consisted of 26 items in 6 subscales....
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Leibniz Research Centre for Working Environment and Human Factors
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8859647/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35221837 http://dx.doi.org/10.17179/excli2021-4439 |
_version_ | 1784654508391923712 |
---|---|
author | Askarian, Mehrdad Semenov, Aleksandr Llopis, Ferran Rubulotta, Francesca Dragovac, Gorana Pshenichnaya, Natalia Assadian, Ojan Ruch, Yvon Shayan, Zahra Padilla Fortunatti, Cristobal Lucey, Daniel Almohaizeie, Abdullah Kamal, Abu Hena Mostafa Ogunshe, Adenike Konkayev, Aidos Beg, Asim Primerano, Enzo Amer, Fatma Kumari Pilli, Hema Prakash Hung, Ivan Ayoade, Folusakin Lefrant, Jean Yves Zajkowska, Joanna Rello, Jordi Kazi, Momin Taghrir, Mohammad Hossein Blot, Stijn Leib, Stephen Hosseinpour, Parisa Hosseinpour, Hamidreza Erfani, Amirhossein Borazjani, Roham Akbarialiabad, Hossein Najafi, Masoud Askarian, Ardalan Erdem, Hakan |
author_facet | Askarian, Mehrdad Semenov, Aleksandr Llopis, Ferran Rubulotta, Francesca Dragovac, Gorana Pshenichnaya, Natalia Assadian, Ojan Ruch, Yvon Shayan, Zahra Padilla Fortunatti, Cristobal Lucey, Daniel Almohaizeie, Abdullah Kamal, Abu Hena Mostafa Ogunshe, Adenike Konkayev, Aidos Beg, Asim Primerano, Enzo Amer, Fatma Kumari Pilli, Hema Prakash Hung, Ivan Ayoade, Folusakin Lefrant, Jean Yves Zajkowska, Joanna Rello, Jordi Kazi, Momin Taghrir, Mohammad Hossein Blot, Stijn Leib, Stephen Hosseinpour, Parisa Hosseinpour, Hamidreza Erfani, Amirhossein Borazjani, Roham Akbarialiabad, Hossein Najafi, Masoud Askarian, Ardalan Erdem, Hakan |
author_sort | Askarian, Mehrdad |
collection | PubMed |
description | The aim of this study was to investigate the COVID-19 vaccination acceptance rate and its determinants among healthcare workers in a multicenter study. This was a cross-sectional multi-center survey conducted from February 5 to April 29, 2021. The questionnaire consisted of 26 items in 6 subscales. The English version of the questionnaire was translated into seven languages and distributed through Google Forms using snowball sampling; a colleague in each country was responsible for the forward and backward translation, and also the distribution of the questionnaire. A forward stepwise logistic regression was utilized to explore the variables and questionnaire factors tied to the intention to COVID-19 vaccination. 4630 participants from 91 countries completed the questionnaire. According to the United Nations Development Program 2020, 43.6 % of participants were from low Human Development Index (HDI) regions, 48.3 % high and very high, and 8.1 % from medium. The overall vaccination hesitancy rate was 37 %. Three out of six factors of the questionnaire were significantly related to intention to the vaccination. While 'Perceived benefits of the COVID-19 vaccination' (OR: 3.82, p-value<0.001) and 'Prosocial norms' (OR: 5.18, p-value<0.001) were associated with vaccination acceptance, 'The vaccine safety/cost concerns' with OR: 3.52, p-value<0.001 was tied to vaccination hesitancy. Medical doctors and pharmacists were more willing to take the vaccine in comparison to others. Importantly, HDI with OR: 12.28, 95 % CI: 6.10-24.72 was a strong positive determinant of COVID-19 vaccination acceptance. This study highlighted the vaccination hesitancy rate of 37 % in our sample among HCWs. Increasing awareness regarding vaccination benefits, confronting the misinformation, and strengthening the prosocial norms would be the primary domains for maximizing the vaccination coverage. The study also showed that the HDI is strongly associated with the vaccination acceptance/hesitancy, in a way that those living in low HDI contexts are more hesitant to receive the vaccine. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8859647 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Leibniz Research Centre for Working Environment and Human Factors |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-88596472022-02-25 The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study Askarian, Mehrdad Semenov, Aleksandr Llopis, Ferran Rubulotta, Francesca Dragovac, Gorana Pshenichnaya, Natalia Assadian, Ojan Ruch, Yvon Shayan, Zahra Padilla Fortunatti, Cristobal Lucey, Daniel Almohaizeie, Abdullah Kamal, Abu Hena Mostafa Ogunshe, Adenike Konkayev, Aidos Beg, Asim Primerano, Enzo Amer, Fatma Kumari Pilli, Hema Prakash Hung, Ivan Ayoade, Folusakin Lefrant, Jean Yves Zajkowska, Joanna Rello, Jordi Kazi, Momin Taghrir, Mohammad Hossein Blot, Stijn Leib, Stephen Hosseinpour, Parisa Hosseinpour, Hamidreza Erfani, Amirhossein Borazjani, Roham Akbarialiabad, Hossein Najafi, Masoud Askarian, Ardalan Erdem, Hakan EXCLI J Original Article The aim of this study was to investigate the COVID-19 vaccination acceptance rate and its determinants among healthcare workers in a multicenter study. This was a cross-sectional multi-center survey conducted from February 5 to April 29, 2021. The questionnaire consisted of 26 items in 6 subscales. The English version of the questionnaire was translated into seven languages and distributed through Google Forms using snowball sampling; a colleague in each country was responsible for the forward and backward translation, and also the distribution of the questionnaire. A forward stepwise logistic regression was utilized to explore the variables and questionnaire factors tied to the intention to COVID-19 vaccination. 4630 participants from 91 countries completed the questionnaire. According to the United Nations Development Program 2020, 43.6 % of participants were from low Human Development Index (HDI) regions, 48.3 % high and very high, and 8.1 % from medium. The overall vaccination hesitancy rate was 37 %. Three out of six factors of the questionnaire were significantly related to intention to the vaccination. While 'Perceived benefits of the COVID-19 vaccination' (OR: 3.82, p-value<0.001) and 'Prosocial norms' (OR: 5.18, p-value<0.001) were associated with vaccination acceptance, 'The vaccine safety/cost concerns' with OR: 3.52, p-value<0.001 was tied to vaccination hesitancy. Medical doctors and pharmacists were more willing to take the vaccine in comparison to others. Importantly, HDI with OR: 12.28, 95 % CI: 6.10-24.72 was a strong positive determinant of COVID-19 vaccination acceptance. This study highlighted the vaccination hesitancy rate of 37 % in our sample among HCWs. Increasing awareness regarding vaccination benefits, confronting the misinformation, and strengthening the prosocial norms would be the primary domains for maximizing the vaccination coverage. The study also showed that the HDI is strongly associated with the vaccination acceptance/hesitancy, in a way that those living in low HDI contexts are more hesitant to receive the vaccine. Leibniz Research Centre for Working Environment and Human Factors 2022-01-06 /pmc/articles/PMC8859647/ /pubmed/35221837 http://dx.doi.org/10.17179/excli2021-4439 Text en Copyright © 2022 Askarian et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) ) You are free to copy, distribute and transmit the work, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Original Article Askarian, Mehrdad Semenov, Aleksandr Llopis, Ferran Rubulotta, Francesca Dragovac, Gorana Pshenichnaya, Natalia Assadian, Ojan Ruch, Yvon Shayan, Zahra Padilla Fortunatti, Cristobal Lucey, Daniel Almohaizeie, Abdullah Kamal, Abu Hena Mostafa Ogunshe, Adenike Konkayev, Aidos Beg, Asim Primerano, Enzo Amer, Fatma Kumari Pilli, Hema Prakash Hung, Ivan Ayoade, Folusakin Lefrant, Jean Yves Zajkowska, Joanna Rello, Jordi Kazi, Momin Taghrir, Mohammad Hossein Blot, Stijn Leib, Stephen Hosseinpour, Parisa Hosseinpour, Hamidreza Erfani, Amirhossein Borazjani, Roham Akbarialiabad, Hossein Najafi, Masoud Askarian, Ardalan Erdem, Hakan The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study |
title | The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study |
title_full | The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study |
title_fullStr | The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study |
title_full_unstemmed | The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study |
title_short | The COVID-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 Countries: A multicenter cross-sectional study |
title_sort | covid-19 vaccination acceptance/hesitancy rate and its determinants among healthcare workers of 91 countries: a multicenter cross-sectional study |
topic | Original Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8859647/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35221837 http://dx.doi.org/10.17179/excli2021-4439 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT askarianmehrdad thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT semenovaleksandr thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT llopisferran thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT rubulottafrancesca thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT dragovacgorana thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT pshenichnayanatalia thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT assadianojan thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT ruchyvon thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT shayanzahra thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT padillafortunatticristobal thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT luceydaniel thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT almohaizeieabdullah thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT kamalabuhenamostafa thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT ogunsheadenike thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT konkayevaidos thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT begasim thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT primeranoenzo thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT amerfatma thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT kumaripillihemaprakash thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT hungivan thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT ayoadefolusakin thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT lefrantjeanyves thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT zajkowskajoanna thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT rellojordi thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT kazimomin thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT taghrirmohammadhossein thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT blotstijn thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT leibstephen thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT hosseinpourparisa thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT hosseinpourhamidreza thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT erfaniamirhossein thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT borazjaniroham thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT akbarialiabadhossein thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT najafimasoud thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT askarianardalan thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT erdemhakan thecovid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT askarianmehrdad covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT semenovaleksandr covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT llopisferran covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT rubulottafrancesca covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT dragovacgorana covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT pshenichnayanatalia covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT assadianojan covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT ruchyvon covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT shayanzahra covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT padillafortunatticristobal covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT luceydaniel covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT almohaizeieabdullah covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT kamalabuhenamostafa covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT ogunsheadenike covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT konkayevaidos covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT begasim covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT primeranoenzo covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT amerfatma covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT kumaripillihemaprakash covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT hungivan covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT ayoadefolusakin covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT lefrantjeanyves covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT zajkowskajoanna covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT rellojordi covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT kazimomin covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT taghrirmohammadhossein covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT blotstijn covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT leibstephen covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT hosseinpourparisa covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT hosseinpourhamidreza covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT erfaniamirhossein covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT borazjaniroham covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT akbarialiabadhossein covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT najafimasoud covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT askarianardalan covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy AT erdemhakan covid19vaccinationacceptancehesitancyrateanditsdeterminantsamonghealthcareworkersof91countriesamulticentercrosssectionalstudy |