Cargando…

A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis

Sepsis is a major reason for preventable hospital deaths. A cluster-randomized controlled trial on an educational intervention did not show improvements of sepsis management or outcome. We now aimed to test an improved implementation strategy in a second intervention phase in which new intervention...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Schwarzkopf, Daniel, Matthaeus-Kraemer, Claudia Tanja, Thomas-Rüddel, Daniel O., Rüddel, Hendrik, Poidinger, Bernhard, Bach, Friedhelm, Gerlach, Herwig, Gründling, Matthias, Lindner, Matthias, Scheer, Christian, Simon, Philipp, Weiss, Manfred, Reinhart, Konrad, Bloos, Frank
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nature Publishing Group UK 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8913650/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35273276
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-07915-9
_version_ 1784667491002220544
author Schwarzkopf, Daniel
Matthaeus-Kraemer, Claudia Tanja
Thomas-Rüddel, Daniel O.
Rüddel, Hendrik
Poidinger, Bernhard
Bach, Friedhelm
Gerlach, Herwig
Gründling, Matthias
Lindner, Matthias
Scheer, Christian
Simon, Philipp
Weiss, Manfred
Reinhart, Konrad
Bloos, Frank
author_facet Schwarzkopf, Daniel
Matthaeus-Kraemer, Claudia Tanja
Thomas-Rüddel, Daniel O.
Rüddel, Hendrik
Poidinger, Bernhard
Bach, Friedhelm
Gerlach, Herwig
Gründling, Matthias
Lindner, Matthias
Scheer, Christian
Simon, Philipp
Weiss, Manfred
Reinhart, Konrad
Bloos, Frank
author_sort Schwarzkopf, Daniel
collection PubMed
description Sepsis is a major reason for preventable hospital deaths. A cluster-randomized controlled trial on an educational intervention did not show improvements of sepsis management or outcome. We now aimed to test an improved implementation strategy in a second intervention phase in which new intervention hospitals (former controls) received a multifaceted educational intervention, while controls (former intervention hospitals) only received feedback of quality indicators. Changes in outcomes from the first to the second intervention phase were compared between groups using hierarchical generalized linear models controlling for possible confounders. During the two phases, 19 control hospitals included 4050 patients with sepsis and 21 intervention hospitals included 2526 patients. 28-day mortality did not show significant changes between study phases in both groups. The proportion of patients receiving antimicrobial therapy within one hour increased in intervention hospitals, but not in control hospitals. Taking at least two sets of blood cultures increased significantly in both groups. During phase 2, intervention hospitals showed higher proportion of adequate initial antimicrobial therapy and de-escalation within 5 days. A survey among involved clinicians indicated lacking resources for quality improvement. Therefore, quality improvement programs should include all elements of sepsis guidelines and provide hospitals with sufficient resources for quality improvement. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01187134. Registered 23 August 2010, https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/study/NCT01187134.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8913650
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Nature Publishing Group UK
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-89136502022-03-11 A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis Schwarzkopf, Daniel Matthaeus-Kraemer, Claudia Tanja Thomas-Rüddel, Daniel O. Rüddel, Hendrik Poidinger, Bernhard Bach, Friedhelm Gerlach, Herwig Gründling, Matthias Lindner, Matthias Scheer, Christian Simon, Philipp Weiss, Manfred Reinhart, Konrad Bloos, Frank Sci Rep Article Sepsis is a major reason for preventable hospital deaths. A cluster-randomized controlled trial on an educational intervention did not show improvements of sepsis management or outcome. We now aimed to test an improved implementation strategy in a second intervention phase in which new intervention hospitals (former controls) received a multifaceted educational intervention, while controls (former intervention hospitals) only received feedback of quality indicators. Changes in outcomes from the first to the second intervention phase were compared between groups using hierarchical generalized linear models controlling for possible confounders. During the two phases, 19 control hospitals included 4050 patients with sepsis and 21 intervention hospitals included 2526 patients. 28-day mortality did not show significant changes between study phases in both groups. The proportion of patients receiving antimicrobial therapy within one hour increased in intervention hospitals, but not in control hospitals. Taking at least two sets of blood cultures increased significantly in both groups. During phase 2, intervention hospitals showed higher proportion of adequate initial antimicrobial therapy and de-escalation within 5 days. A survey among involved clinicians indicated lacking resources for quality improvement. Therefore, quality improvement programs should include all elements of sepsis guidelines and provide hospitals with sufficient resources for quality improvement. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01187134. Registered 23 August 2010, https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/study/NCT01187134. Nature Publishing Group UK 2022-03-10 /pmc/articles/PMC8913650/ /pubmed/35273276 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-07915-9 Text en © The Author(s) 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) .
spellingShingle Article
Schwarzkopf, Daniel
Matthaeus-Kraemer, Claudia Tanja
Thomas-Rüddel, Daniel O.
Rüddel, Hendrik
Poidinger, Bernhard
Bach, Friedhelm
Gerlach, Herwig
Gründling, Matthias
Lindner, Matthias
Scheer, Christian
Simon, Philipp
Weiss, Manfred
Reinhart, Konrad
Bloos, Frank
A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
title A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
title_full A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
title_fullStr A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
title_full_unstemmed A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
title_short A multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
title_sort multifaceted educational intervention improved anti-infectious measures but had no effect on mortality in patients with severe sepsis
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8913650/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35273276
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-07915-9
work_keys_str_mv AT schwarzkopfdaniel amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT matthaeuskraemerclaudiatanja amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT thomasruddeldanielo amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT ruddelhendrik amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT poidingerbernhard amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT bachfriedhelm amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT gerlachherwig amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT grundlingmatthias amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT lindnermatthias amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT scheerchristian amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT simonphilipp amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT weissmanfred amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT reinhartkonrad amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT bloosfrank amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT amultifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT schwarzkopfdaniel multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT matthaeuskraemerclaudiatanja multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT thomasruddeldanielo multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT ruddelhendrik multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT poidingerbernhard multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT bachfriedhelm multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT gerlachherwig multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT grundlingmatthias multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT lindnermatthias multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT scheerchristian multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT simonphilipp multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT weissmanfred multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT reinhartkonrad multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT bloosfrank multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis
AT multifacetededucationalinterventionimprovedantiinfectiousmeasuresbuthadnoeffectonmortalityinpatientswithseveresepsis