Cargando…
Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study
OBJECTIVE: Drug‐resistant focal epilepsy is often caused by focal cortical dysplasias (FCDs). The distribution of these lesions across the cerebral cortex and the impact of lesion location on clinical presentation and surgical outcome are largely unknown. We created a neuroimaging cohort of patients...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8916105/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34845719 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/epi.17130 |
_version_ | 1784668213254029312 |
---|---|
author | Wagstyl, Konrad Whitaker, Kirstie Raznahan, Armin Seidlitz, Jakob Vértes, Petra E. Foldes, Stephen Humphreys, Zachary Hu, Wenhan Mo, Jiajie Likeman, Marcus Davies, Shirin Lenge, Matteo Cohen, Nathan T. Tang, Yingying Wang, Shan Ripart, Mathilde Chari, Aswin Tisdall, Martin Bargallo, Nuria Conde‐Blanco, Estefanía Pariente, Jose Carlos Pascual‐Diaz, Saül Delgado‐Martínez, Ignacio Pérez‐Enríquez, Carmen Lagorio, Ilaria Abela, Eugenio Mullatti, Nandini O'Muircheartaigh, Jonathan Vecchiato, Katy Liu, Yawu Caligiuri, Maria Sinclair, Ben Vivash, Lucy Willard, Anna Kandasamy, Jothy McLellan, Ailsa Sokol, Drahoslav Semmelroch, Mira Kloster, Ane Opheim, Giske Yasuda, Clarissa Zhang, Kai Hamandi, Khalid Barba, Carmen Guerrini, Renzo Gaillard, William Davis You, Xiaozhen Wang, Irene González‐Ortiz, Sofía Severino, Mariasavina Striano, Pasquale Tortora, Domenico Kalviainen, Reetta Gambardella, Antonio Labate, Angelo Desmond, Patricia Lui, Elaine O'Brien, Terry Shetty, Jay Jackson, Graeme Duncan, John S. Winston, Gavin P. Pinborg, Lars Cendes, Fernando Cross, Judith Helen Baldeweg, Torsten Adler, Sophie |
author_facet | Wagstyl, Konrad Whitaker, Kirstie Raznahan, Armin Seidlitz, Jakob Vértes, Petra E. Foldes, Stephen Humphreys, Zachary Hu, Wenhan Mo, Jiajie Likeman, Marcus Davies, Shirin Lenge, Matteo Cohen, Nathan T. Tang, Yingying Wang, Shan Ripart, Mathilde Chari, Aswin Tisdall, Martin Bargallo, Nuria Conde‐Blanco, Estefanía Pariente, Jose Carlos Pascual‐Diaz, Saül Delgado‐Martínez, Ignacio Pérez‐Enríquez, Carmen Lagorio, Ilaria Abela, Eugenio Mullatti, Nandini O'Muircheartaigh, Jonathan Vecchiato, Katy Liu, Yawu Caligiuri, Maria Sinclair, Ben Vivash, Lucy Willard, Anna Kandasamy, Jothy McLellan, Ailsa Sokol, Drahoslav Semmelroch, Mira Kloster, Ane Opheim, Giske Yasuda, Clarissa Zhang, Kai Hamandi, Khalid Barba, Carmen Guerrini, Renzo Gaillard, William Davis You, Xiaozhen Wang, Irene González‐Ortiz, Sofía Severino, Mariasavina Striano, Pasquale Tortora, Domenico Kalviainen, Reetta Gambardella, Antonio Labate, Angelo Desmond, Patricia Lui, Elaine O'Brien, Terry Shetty, Jay Jackson, Graeme Duncan, John S. Winston, Gavin P. Pinborg, Lars Cendes, Fernando Cross, Judith Helen Baldeweg, Torsten Adler, Sophie |
author_sort | Wagstyl, Konrad |
collection | PubMed |
description | OBJECTIVE: Drug‐resistant focal epilepsy is often caused by focal cortical dysplasias (FCDs). The distribution of these lesions across the cerebral cortex and the impact of lesion location on clinical presentation and surgical outcome are largely unknown. We created a neuroimaging cohort of patients with individually mapped FCDs to determine factors associated with lesion location and predictors of postsurgical outcome. METHODS: The MELD (Multi‐centre Epilepsy Lesion Detection) project collated a retrospective cohort of 580 patients with epilepsy attributed to FCD from 20 epilepsy centers worldwide. Magnetic resonance imaging‐based maps of individual FCDs with accompanying demographic, clinical, and surgical information were collected. We mapped the distribution of FCDs, examined for associations between clinical factors and lesion location, and developed a predictive model of postsurgical seizure freedom. RESULTS: FCDs were nonuniformly distributed, concentrating in the superior frontal sulcus, frontal pole, and temporal pole. Epilepsy onset was typically before the age of 10 years. Earlier epilepsy onset was associated with lesions in primary sensory areas, whereas later epilepsy onset was associated with lesions in association cortices. Lesions in temporal and occipital lobes tended to be larger than frontal lobe lesions. Seizure freedom rates varied with FCD location, from around 30% in visual, motor, and premotor areas to 75% in superior temporal and frontal gyri. The predictive model of postsurgical seizure freedom had a positive predictive value of 70% and negative predictive value of 61%. SIGNIFICANCE: FCD location is an important determinant of its size, the age at epilepsy onset, and the likelihood of seizure freedom postsurgery. Our atlas of lesion locations can be used to guide the radiological search for subtle lesions in individual patients. Our atlas of regional seizure freedom rates and associated predictive model can be used to estimate individual likelihoods of postsurgical seizure freedom. Data‐driven atlases and predictive models are essential for evidence‐based, precision medicine and risk counseling in epilepsy. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8916105 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-89161052022-03-18 Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study Wagstyl, Konrad Whitaker, Kirstie Raznahan, Armin Seidlitz, Jakob Vértes, Petra E. Foldes, Stephen Humphreys, Zachary Hu, Wenhan Mo, Jiajie Likeman, Marcus Davies, Shirin Lenge, Matteo Cohen, Nathan T. Tang, Yingying Wang, Shan Ripart, Mathilde Chari, Aswin Tisdall, Martin Bargallo, Nuria Conde‐Blanco, Estefanía Pariente, Jose Carlos Pascual‐Diaz, Saül Delgado‐Martínez, Ignacio Pérez‐Enríquez, Carmen Lagorio, Ilaria Abela, Eugenio Mullatti, Nandini O'Muircheartaigh, Jonathan Vecchiato, Katy Liu, Yawu Caligiuri, Maria Sinclair, Ben Vivash, Lucy Willard, Anna Kandasamy, Jothy McLellan, Ailsa Sokol, Drahoslav Semmelroch, Mira Kloster, Ane Opheim, Giske Yasuda, Clarissa Zhang, Kai Hamandi, Khalid Barba, Carmen Guerrini, Renzo Gaillard, William Davis You, Xiaozhen Wang, Irene González‐Ortiz, Sofía Severino, Mariasavina Striano, Pasquale Tortora, Domenico Kalviainen, Reetta Gambardella, Antonio Labate, Angelo Desmond, Patricia Lui, Elaine O'Brien, Terry Shetty, Jay Jackson, Graeme Duncan, John S. Winston, Gavin P. Pinborg, Lars Cendes, Fernando Cross, Judith Helen Baldeweg, Torsten Adler, Sophie Epilepsia Research Article OBJECTIVE: Drug‐resistant focal epilepsy is often caused by focal cortical dysplasias (FCDs). The distribution of these lesions across the cerebral cortex and the impact of lesion location on clinical presentation and surgical outcome are largely unknown. We created a neuroimaging cohort of patients with individually mapped FCDs to determine factors associated with lesion location and predictors of postsurgical outcome. METHODS: The MELD (Multi‐centre Epilepsy Lesion Detection) project collated a retrospective cohort of 580 patients with epilepsy attributed to FCD from 20 epilepsy centers worldwide. Magnetic resonance imaging‐based maps of individual FCDs with accompanying demographic, clinical, and surgical information were collected. We mapped the distribution of FCDs, examined for associations between clinical factors and lesion location, and developed a predictive model of postsurgical seizure freedom. RESULTS: FCDs were nonuniformly distributed, concentrating in the superior frontal sulcus, frontal pole, and temporal pole. Epilepsy onset was typically before the age of 10 years. Earlier epilepsy onset was associated with lesions in primary sensory areas, whereas later epilepsy onset was associated with lesions in association cortices. Lesions in temporal and occipital lobes tended to be larger than frontal lobe lesions. Seizure freedom rates varied with FCD location, from around 30% in visual, motor, and premotor areas to 75% in superior temporal and frontal gyri. The predictive model of postsurgical seizure freedom had a positive predictive value of 70% and negative predictive value of 61%. SIGNIFICANCE: FCD location is an important determinant of its size, the age at epilepsy onset, and the likelihood of seizure freedom postsurgery. Our atlas of lesion locations can be used to guide the radiological search for subtle lesions in individual patients. Our atlas of regional seizure freedom rates and associated predictive model can be used to estimate individual likelihoods of postsurgical seizure freedom. Data‐driven atlases and predictive models are essential for evidence‐based, precision medicine and risk counseling in epilepsy. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021-11-29 2022-01 /pmc/articles/PMC8916105/ /pubmed/34845719 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/epi.17130 Text en © 2021 The Authors. Epilepsia published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of International League Against Epilepsy https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Wagstyl, Konrad Whitaker, Kirstie Raznahan, Armin Seidlitz, Jakob Vértes, Petra E. Foldes, Stephen Humphreys, Zachary Hu, Wenhan Mo, Jiajie Likeman, Marcus Davies, Shirin Lenge, Matteo Cohen, Nathan T. Tang, Yingying Wang, Shan Ripart, Mathilde Chari, Aswin Tisdall, Martin Bargallo, Nuria Conde‐Blanco, Estefanía Pariente, Jose Carlos Pascual‐Diaz, Saül Delgado‐Martínez, Ignacio Pérez‐Enríquez, Carmen Lagorio, Ilaria Abela, Eugenio Mullatti, Nandini O'Muircheartaigh, Jonathan Vecchiato, Katy Liu, Yawu Caligiuri, Maria Sinclair, Ben Vivash, Lucy Willard, Anna Kandasamy, Jothy McLellan, Ailsa Sokol, Drahoslav Semmelroch, Mira Kloster, Ane Opheim, Giske Yasuda, Clarissa Zhang, Kai Hamandi, Khalid Barba, Carmen Guerrini, Renzo Gaillard, William Davis You, Xiaozhen Wang, Irene González‐Ortiz, Sofía Severino, Mariasavina Striano, Pasquale Tortora, Domenico Kalviainen, Reetta Gambardella, Antonio Labate, Angelo Desmond, Patricia Lui, Elaine O'Brien, Terry Shetty, Jay Jackson, Graeme Duncan, John S. Winston, Gavin P. Pinborg, Lars Cendes, Fernando Cross, Judith Helen Baldeweg, Torsten Adler, Sophie Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study |
title | Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study |
title_full | Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study |
title_fullStr | Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study |
title_full_unstemmed | Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study |
title_short | Atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: A MELD study |
title_sort | atlas of lesion locations and postsurgical seizure freedom in focal cortical dysplasia: a meld study |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8916105/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34845719 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/epi.17130 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT wagstylkonrad atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT whitakerkirstie atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT raznahanarmin atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT seidlitzjakob atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT vertespetrae atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT foldesstephen atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT humphreyszachary atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT huwenhan atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT mojiajie atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT likemanmarcus atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT daviesshirin atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT lengematteo atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT cohennathant atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT tangyingying atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT wangshan atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT ripartmathilde atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT chariaswin atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT tisdallmartin atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT bargallonuria atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT condeblancoestefania atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT parientejosecarlos atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT pascualdiazsaul atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT delgadomartinezignacio atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT perezenriquezcarmen atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT lagorioilaria atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT abelaeugenio atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT mullattinandini atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT omuircheartaighjonathan atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT vecchiatokaty atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT liuyawu atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT caligiurimaria atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT sinclairben atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT vivashlucy atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT willardanna atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT kandasamyjothy atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT mclellanailsa atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT sokoldrahoslav atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT semmelrochmira atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT klosterane atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT opheimgiske atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT yasudaclarissa atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT zhangkai atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT hamandikhalid atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT barbacarmen atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT guerrinirenzo atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT gaillardwilliamdavis atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT youxiaozhen atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT wangirene atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT gonzalezortizsofia atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT severinomariasavina atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT strianopasquale atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT tortoradomenico atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT kalviainenreetta atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT gambardellaantonio atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT labateangelo atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT desmondpatricia atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT luielaine atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT obrienterry atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT shettyjay atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT jacksongraeme atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT duncanjohns atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT winstongavinp atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT pinborglars atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT cendesfernando atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT crossjudithhelen atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT baldewegtorsten atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy AT adlersophie atlasoflesionlocationsandpostsurgicalseizurefreedominfocalcorticaldysplasiaameldstudy |