Cargando…

Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children

IMPORTANCE: The wide variation in the accuracy and reliability of the Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma (FAST) and the extended FAST (E-FAST) for children after blunt abdominal trauma reflects user expertise. FAST and E-FAST that are performed by experts tend to be more complete, better...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Kornblith, Aaron E., Addo, Newton, Plasencia, Monica, Shaahinfar, Ashkon, Lin-Martore, Margaret, Sabbineni, Naina, Gold, Delia, Bellman, Lily, Berant, Ron, Bergmann, Kelly R., Brenkert, Timothy E., Chen, Aaron, Constantine, Erika, Deanehan, J. Kate, Dessie, Almaz, Elkhunovich, Marsha, Fischer, Jason, Gravel, Cynthia A., Kharasch, Sig, Kwan, Charisse W., Lam, Samuel H. F., Neal, Jeffrey T., Pade, Kathyrn H., Rempell, Rachel, Shefrin, Allan E., Sivitz, Adam, Snelling, Peter J., Tessaro, Mark O., White, William
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: American Medical Association 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8933745/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35302632
http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.2922
_version_ 1784671723109482496
author Kornblith, Aaron E.
Addo, Newton
Plasencia, Monica
Shaahinfar, Ashkon
Lin-Martore, Margaret
Sabbineni, Naina
Gold, Delia
Bellman, Lily
Berant, Ron
Bergmann, Kelly R.
Brenkert, Timothy E.
Chen, Aaron
Constantine, Erika
Deanehan, J. Kate
Dessie, Almaz
Elkhunovich, Marsha
Fischer, Jason
Gravel, Cynthia A.
Kharasch, Sig
Kwan, Charisse W.
Lam, Samuel H. F.
Neal, Jeffrey T.
Pade, Kathyrn H.
Rempell, Rachel
Shefrin, Allan E.
Sivitz, Adam
Snelling, Peter J.
Tessaro, Mark O.
White, William
author_facet Kornblith, Aaron E.
Addo, Newton
Plasencia, Monica
Shaahinfar, Ashkon
Lin-Martore, Margaret
Sabbineni, Naina
Gold, Delia
Bellman, Lily
Berant, Ron
Bergmann, Kelly R.
Brenkert, Timothy E.
Chen, Aaron
Constantine, Erika
Deanehan, J. Kate
Dessie, Almaz
Elkhunovich, Marsha
Fischer, Jason
Gravel, Cynthia A.
Kharasch, Sig
Kwan, Charisse W.
Lam, Samuel H. F.
Neal, Jeffrey T.
Pade, Kathyrn H.
Rempell, Rachel
Shefrin, Allan E.
Sivitz, Adam
Snelling, Peter J.
Tessaro, Mark O.
White, William
author_sort Kornblith, Aaron E.
collection PubMed
description IMPORTANCE: The wide variation in the accuracy and reliability of the Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma (FAST) and the extended FAST (E-FAST) for children after blunt abdominal trauma reflects user expertise. FAST and E-FAST that are performed by experts tend to be more complete, better quality, and more often clinically valuable. OBJECTIVE: To develop definitions of a complete, high-quality, and accurate interpretation for the FAST and E-FAST in children with injury using an expert, consensus–based modified Delphi technique. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This consensus-based qualitative study was conducted between May 1 to June 30, 2021. It used a scoping review and iterative Delphi technique and involved 2 rounds of online surveys and a live webinar to achieve consensus among a 26-member panel. This panel consisted of international experts in pediatric emergency point-of-care ultrasonography. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Definitions of complete, high-quality, and accurate FAST and E-FAST studies for children after injury. RESULTS: Of the 29 invited pediatric FAST experts, 26 (15 men [58%]) agreed to participate in the panel. All 26 panelists completed the 2 rounds of surveys, and 24 (92%) participated in the live and asynchronous online discussions. Consensus was reached on FAST and E-FAST study definitions, and the panelists rated these 5 anatomic views as important and appropriate for a complete FAST: right upper-quadrant abdominal view, left upper-quadrant abdominal view, suprapubic views (transverse and sagittal), and subxiphoid cardiac view. For E-FAST, the same FAST anatomic views with the addition of the lung or pneumothorax view were deemed appropriate and important. In addition, the panelists rated a total of 32 landmarks as important for assessing completeness. Similarly, the panelists rated 14 statements on quality and 20 statements on accurate interpretation as appropriate. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This qualitative study generated definitions for complete FAST and E-FAST studies with high image quality and accurate interpretation in children with injury. These definitions are similar to those in adults with injury and may be used for future education, quality assurance, and research. Future research may focus on interpretation of trace volumes of abdominal free fluid and the use of serial FAST.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8933745
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher American Medical Association
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-89337452022-04-01 Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children Kornblith, Aaron E. Addo, Newton Plasencia, Monica Shaahinfar, Ashkon Lin-Martore, Margaret Sabbineni, Naina Gold, Delia Bellman, Lily Berant, Ron Bergmann, Kelly R. Brenkert, Timothy E. Chen, Aaron Constantine, Erika Deanehan, J. Kate Dessie, Almaz Elkhunovich, Marsha Fischer, Jason Gravel, Cynthia A. Kharasch, Sig Kwan, Charisse W. Lam, Samuel H. F. Neal, Jeffrey T. Pade, Kathyrn H. Rempell, Rachel Shefrin, Allan E. Sivitz, Adam Snelling, Peter J. Tessaro, Mark O. White, William JAMA Netw Open Original Investigation IMPORTANCE: The wide variation in the accuracy and reliability of the Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma (FAST) and the extended FAST (E-FAST) for children after blunt abdominal trauma reflects user expertise. FAST and E-FAST that are performed by experts tend to be more complete, better quality, and more often clinically valuable. OBJECTIVE: To develop definitions of a complete, high-quality, and accurate interpretation for the FAST and E-FAST in children with injury using an expert, consensus–based modified Delphi technique. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This consensus-based qualitative study was conducted between May 1 to June 30, 2021. It used a scoping review and iterative Delphi technique and involved 2 rounds of online surveys and a live webinar to achieve consensus among a 26-member panel. This panel consisted of international experts in pediatric emergency point-of-care ultrasonography. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Definitions of complete, high-quality, and accurate FAST and E-FAST studies for children after injury. RESULTS: Of the 29 invited pediatric FAST experts, 26 (15 men [58%]) agreed to participate in the panel. All 26 panelists completed the 2 rounds of surveys, and 24 (92%) participated in the live and asynchronous online discussions. Consensus was reached on FAST and E-FAST study definitions, and the panelists rated these 5 anatomic views as important and appropriate for a complete FAST: right upper-quadrant abdominal view, left upper-quadrant abdominal view, suprapubic views (transverse and sagittal), and subxiphoid cardiac view. For E-FAST, the same FAST anatomic views with the addition of the lung or pneumothorax view were deemed appropriate and important. In addition, the panelists rated a total of 32 landmarks as important for assessing completeness. Similarly, the panelists rated 14 statements on quality and 20 statements on accurate interpretation as appropriate. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This qualitative study generated definitions for complete FAST and E-FAST studies with high image quality and accurate interpretation in children with injury. These definitions are similar to those in adults with injury and may be used for future education, quality assurance, and research. Future research may focus on interpretation of trace volumes of abdominal free fluid and the use of serial FAST. American Medical Association 2022-03-18 /pmc/articles/PMC8933745/ /pubmed/35302632 http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.2922 Text en Copyright 2022 Kornblith AE et al. JAMA Network Open. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC-BY License.
spellingShingle Original Investigation
Kornblith, Aaron E.
Addo, Newton
Plasencia, Monica
Shaahinfar, Ashkon
Lin-Martore, Margaret
Sabbineni, Naina
Gold, Delia
Bellman, Lily
Berant, Ron
Bergmann, Kelly R.
Brenkert, Timothy E.
Chen, Aaron
Constantine, Erika
Deanehan, J. Kate
Dessie, Almaz
Elkhunovich, Marsha
Fischer, Jason
Gravel, Cynthia A.
Kharasch, Sig
Kwan, Charisse W.
Lam, Samuel H. F.
Neal, Jeffrey T.
Pade, Kathyrn H.
Rempell, Rachel
Shefrin, Allan E.
Sivitz, Adam
Snelling, Peter J.
Tessaro, Mark O.
White, William
Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children
title Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children
title_full Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children
title_fullStr Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children
title_full_unstemmed Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children
title_short Development of a Consensus-Based Definition of Focused Assessment With Sonography for Trauma in Children
title_sort development of a consensus-based definition of focused assessment with sonography for trauma in children
topic Original Investigation
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8933745/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35302632
http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.2922
work_keys_str_mv AT kornblithaarone developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT addonewton developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT plasenciamonica developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT shaahinfarashkon developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT linmartoremargaret developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT sabbineninaina developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT golddelia developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT bellmanlily developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT berantron developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT bergmannkellyr developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT brenkerttimothye developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT chenaaron developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT constantineerika developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT deanehanjkate developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT dessiealmaz developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT elkhunovichmarsha developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT fischerjason developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT gravelcynthiaa developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT kharaschsig developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT kwancharissew developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT lamsamuelhf developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT nealjeffreyt developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT padekathyrnh developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT rempellrachel developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT shefrinallane developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT sivitzadam developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT snellingpeterj developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT tessaromarko developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren
AT whitewilliam developmentofaconsensusbaseddefinitionoffocusedassessmentwithsonographyfortraumainchildren