Hypofractionated Whole Breast Irradiation and Boost-IOERT in Early Stage Breast Cancer (HIOB): First Clinical Results of a Prospective Multicenter Trial (NCT01343459)

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Intraoperative electron radiation therapy (IOERT) has repeatedly demonstrated its power to yield high local control rates in all risk constellation of patients with invasive breast cancer when given as tumor bed boost prior to conventional whole breast irradiation (WBI) after breast conserving surgery (BCS). Since the standard for WBI continuously moved towards hypofractionation, we initiated a prospective trial in 2011 where we combined a high precision IOERT boost with a “moderate” hypofractionation schedule (15 × 2.7 Gy), the HIOB-trial [NCT01343459], as clinical evidence for this combination was scarce. Our results demonstrated a low five-year local recurrence rate (overall two events in a population of 1119 patients), which undershot such best evidences in two age groups (41–50 y and >50 y). As acute and late toxicity were mild with no impaired cosmetic outcome, the HIOB-concept seems to be a viable treatment option for patients who underwent BCS and intended WBI. ABSTRACT: Background and purpose: To investigate intraoperative electron radiation therapy (IOERT) as a tumor bed boost during breast conserving surgery (BCS) followed by hypofractionated whole breast irradiation (HWBI) on age-correlated in-breast recurrence (IBR) rates in patients with low- to high-risk invasive breast cancer. Material and methods: BCS and IOERT (11.1 Gy) preceded a HWBI (40.5 Gy) in 15 fractions. Five-year IBR-rates were compared by a sequential ratio test (SQRT) with best evidences in three age groups (35–40 y and 41–50 y: 3.6%, >50 y: 2%) in a prospective single arm design. Null hypothesis (H0) was defined to undershoot these benchmarks for proof of superiority. Results: Of 1445 enrolled patients, 326 met exclusion criteria, leaving 1119 as eligible for analysis. After a median follow-up of 50 months (range 0.7–104), we detected two local recurrences, both in the age group >50 y. With no observed IBR, superiority was demonstrated for the patient groups 41–50 and >50 y, respectively. For the youngest group (35–40 y), no appropriate statistical evaluation was yet possible due to insufficient recruitment. Conclusions: In terms of five-year IBR-rates, Boost-IOERT followed by HWBI has been demonstrated to be superior in patients older than 50 and in the age group 41–50 when compared to best published evidence until 2010.