Cargando…

Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area

BACKGROUND: In North America, up to one billion birds are estimated to die annually due to collisions with glass. The transparent and reflective properties of glass present the illusion of a clear flight passage or continuous habitat. Approaches to reducing collision risk involve installing visual c...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: De Groot, Krista L., Wilson, Amy G., McKibbin, René, Hudson, Sarah A., Dohms, Kimberly M., Norris, Andrea R., Huang, Andrew C., Whitehorne, Ivy B. J., Fort, Kevin T., Roy, Christian, Bourque, Julie, Wilson, Scott
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: PeerJ Inc. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8953498/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35341053
http://dx.doi.org/10.7717/peerj.13142
_version_ 1784675865579225088
author De Groot, Krista L.
Wilson, Amy G.
McKibbin, René
Hudson, Sarah A.
Dohms, Kimberly M.
Norris, Andrea R.
Huang, Andrew C.
Whitehorne, Ivy B. J.
Fort, Kevin T.
Roy, Christian
Bourque, Julie
Wilson, Scott
author_facet De Groot, Krista L.
Wilson, Amy G.
McKibbin, René
Hudson, Sarah A.
Dohms, Kimberly M.
Norris, Andrea R.
Huang, Andrew C.
Whitehorne, Ivy B. J.
Fort, Kevin T.
Roy, Christian
Bourque, Julie
Wilson, Scott
author_sort De Groot, Krista L.
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: In North America, up to one billion birds are estimated to die annually due to collisions with glass. The transparent and reflective properties of glass present the illusion of a clear flight passage or continuous habitat. Approaches to reducing collision risk involve installing visual cues on glass that enable birds to perceive glass as a solid hazard at a sufficient distance to avoid it. METHODS: We monitored for bird-window collisions between 2013 and 2018 to measure response to bird protection window treatments at two low-rise buildings at the Alaksen National Wildlife Area in Delta, British Columbia, Canada. After 2 years of collision monitoring in an untreated state, we retrofitted one building with Feather Friendly(®) circular adhesive markers applied in a grid pattern across all windows, enabling a field-based assessment of the relative reduction in collisions in the 2 years of monitoring following treatment. An adjacent building that had been constructed with a bird protective UV-treated glass called ORNILUX(®) Mikado, was monitored throughout the two study periods. Carcass persistence trials were conducted to evaluate the likelihood that carcasses were missed due to carcass removal between scheduled searches. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: After accounting for differences in area of glass between the two buildings, year, and observer effects, our best-fit model for explaining collision risk included the building’s treatment group, when compared to models that included building and season only. We found that the Feather Friendly(®) markers reduced collision risk at the retrofitted building by 95%. Collision incidence was also lower at the two monitored façades of the building with ORNILUX(®) glass compared to the building with untreated glass. Although more research is needed on the effectiveness of bird-protection products across a range of conditions, our results highlight the benefit of these products for reducing avian mortality due to collisions with glass.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8953498
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher PeerJ Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-89534982022-03-26 Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area De Groot, Krista L. Wilson, Amy G. McKibbin, René Hudson, Sarah A. Dohms, Kimberly M. Norris, Andrea R. Huang, Andrew C. Whitehorne, Ivy B. J. Fort, Kevin T. Roy, Christian Bourque, Julie Wilson, Scott PeerJ Biodiversity BACKGROUND: In North America, up to one billion birds are estimated to die annually due to collisions with glass. The transparent and reflective properties of glass present the illusion of a clear flight passage or continuous habitat. Approaches to reducing collision risk involve installing visual cues on glass that enable birds to perceive glass as a solid hazard at a sufficient distance to avoid it. METHODS: We monitored for bird-window collisions between 2013 and 2018 to measure response to bird protection window treatments at two low-rise buildings at the Alaksen National Wildlife Area in Delta, British Columbia, Canada. After 2 years of collision monitoring in an untreated state, we retrofitted one building with Feather Friendly(®) circular adhesive markers applied in a grid pattern across all windows, enabling a field-based assessment of the relative reduction in collisions in the 2 years of monitoring following treatment. An adjacent building that had been constructed with a bird protective UV-treated glass called ORNILUX(®) Mikado, was monitored throughout the two study periods. Carcass persistence trials were conducted to evaluate the likelihood that carcasses were missed due to carcass removal between scheduled searches. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: After accounting for differences in area of glass between the two buildings, year, and observer effects, our best-fit model for explaining collision risk included the building’s treatment group, when compared to models that included building and season only. We found that the Feather Friendly(®) markers reduced collision risk at the retrofitted building by 95%. Collision incidence was also lower at the two monitored façades of the building with ORNILUX(®) glass compared to the building with untreated glass. Although more research is needed on the effectiveness of bird-protection products across a range of conditions, our results highlight the benefit of these products for reducing avian mortality due to collisions with glass. PeerJ Inc. 2022-03-22 /pmc/articles/PMC8953498/ /pubmed/35341053 http://dx.doi.org/10.7717/peerj.13142 Text en © 2022 De Groot et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, reproduction and adaptation in any medium and for any purpose provided that it is properly attributed. For attribution, the original author(s), title, publication source (PeerJ) and either DOI or URL of the article must be cited.
spellingShingle Biodiversity
De Groot, Krista L.
Wilson, Amy G.
McKibbin, René
Hudson, Sarah A.
Dohms, Kimberly M.
Norris, Andrea R.
Huang, Andrew C.
Whitehorne, Ivy B. J.
Fort, Kevin T.
Roy, Christian
Bourque, Julie
Wilson, Scott
Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area
title Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area
title_full Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area
title_fullStr Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area
title_full_unstemmed Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area
title_short Bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a Pacific coastal protected area
title_sort bird protection treatments reduce bird-window collision risk at low-rise buildings within a pacific coastal protected area
topic Biodiversity
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8953498/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35341053
http://dx.doi.org/10.7717/peerj.13142
work_keys_str_mv AT degrootkristal birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT wilsonamyg birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT mckibbinrene birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT hudsonsaraha birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT dohmskimberlym birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT norrisandrear birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT huangandrewc birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT whitehorneivybj birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT fortkevint birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT roychristian birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT bourquejulie birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea
AT wilsonscott birdprotectiontreatmentsreducebirdwindowcollisionriskatlowrisebuildingswithinapacificcoastalprotectedarea