Cargando…

Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Determination of species in the ant genus Odontomachus, which is a venomous group of ants, may require the use of highly trained entomologists. In Thailand, three species are very similar and difficult to distinguish: O. monticola, O. rixosus, and O. simillimus. In such a situation,...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Samung, Yudthana, Chaiphongpachara, Tanawat, Ruangsittichai, Jiraporn, Sriwichai, Patchara, Phayakkaphon, Anon, Jaitrong, Weeyawat, Dujardin, Jean-Pierre, Sumruayphol, Suchada
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8955869/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35323585
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/insects13030287
_version_ 1784676442255130624
author Samung, Yudthana
Chaiphongpachara, Tanawat
Ruangsittichai, Jiraporn
Sriwichai, Patchara
Phayakkaphon, Anon
Jaitrong, Weeyawat
Dujardin, Jean-Pierre
Sumruayphol, Suchada
author_facet Samung, Yudthana
Chaiphongpachara, Tanawat
Ruangsittichai, Jiraporn
Sriwichai, Patchara
Phayakkaphon, Anon
Jaitrong, Weeyawat
Dujardin, Jean-Pierre
Sumruayphol, Suchada
author_sort Samung, Yudthana
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Determination of species in the ant genus Odontomachus, which is a venomous group of ants, may require the use of highly trained entomologists. In Thailand, three species are very similar and difficult to distinguish: O. monticola, O. rixosus, and O. simillimus. In such a situation, a complementary technique not requiring highly specialized entomological knowledge is welcome. The geometric morphometric approach has proven to be this sort of tool, especially powerful for morphologically close or even cryptic species. In its most recent development, the geometric method uses the relative position of some anatomical landmarks. However, in worker ants these landmarks are few in number and can be difficult to assess without dissection. Here, therefore, we use the outline-based approach, an alternative geometric technique that has not yet been tested in ants. We show that the simple outline of the head contains a strong taxonomic signal, much stronger than the one obtained from the pronotum shape. The outline technique therefore represents a promising approach to aid in the determination of ant species. ABSTRACT: All members of the ant genus Odontomachus Latreille, 1804 are venomous ants. Four species in this genus have been identified from Thailand: Odontomachus latidens Mayr, 1867; O. monticola Emery, 1892; O. rixosus Smith, 1757; and O. simillimus Smith, 1758. The three latter species are available and have been used for an outline morphometric study. They display similar morphology, which makes their distinction very difficult except for highly qualified individuals. A total of 80 worker specimens were studied, exploring the contour shapes of their head and pronotum as possible taxonomic characters. The size of each body part was estimated determining the contour perimeter, the values for which were largely overlapping between O. rixosus and O. simillimus; most O. monticola specimens exhibited a significantly larger size. In contrast to the size, each contour shape of the head or pronotum established O. rixosus as the most distinct species. An exploratory data analysis disclosed the higher taxonomic signal of the head contour relative to the pronotum one. The scores obtained for validated reclassification were much better for the head (99%) than for the pronotum (82%). This study supports outline morphometrics of the head as a promising approach to contribute to the morphological identification of ant species, at least for monomorphic workers.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8955869
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-89558692022-03-26 Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics Samung, Yudthana Chaiphongpachara, Tanawat Ruangsittichai, Jiraporn Sriwichai, Patchara Phayakkaphon, Anon Jaitrong, Weeyawat Dujardin, Jean-Pierre Sumruayphol, Suchada Insects Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Determination of species in the ant genus Odontomachus, which is a venomous group of ants, may require the use of highly trained entomologists. In Thailand, three species are very similar and difficult to distinguish: O. monticola, O. rixosus, and O. simillimus. In such a situation, a complementary technique not requiring highly specialized entomological knowledge is welcome. The geometric morphometric approach has proven to be this sort of tool, especially powerful for morphologically close or even cryptic species. In its most recent development, the geometric method uses the relative position of some anatomical landmarks. However, in worker ants these landmarks are few in number and can be difficult to assess without dissection. Here, therefore, we use the outline-based approach, an alternative geometric technique that has not yet been tested in ants. We show that the simple outline of the head contains a strong taxonomic signal, much stronger than the one obtained from the pronotum shape. The outline technique therefore represents a promising approach to aid in the determination of ant species. ABSTRACT: All members of the ant genus Odontomachus Latreille, 1804 are venomous ants. Four species in this genus have been identified from Thailand: Odontomachus latidens Mayr, 1867; O. monticola Emery, 1892; O. rixosus Smith, 1757; and O. simillimus Smith, 1758. The three latter species are available and have been used for an outline morphometric study. They display similar morphology, which makes their distinction very difficult except for highly qualified individuals. A total of 80 worker specimens were studied, exploring the contour shapes of their head and pronotum as possible taxonomic characters. The size of each body part was estimated determining the contour perimeter, the values for which were largely overlapping between O. rixosus and O. simillimus; most O. monticola specimens exhibited a significantly larger size. In contrast to the size, each contour shape of the head or pronotum established O. rixosus as the most distinct species. An exploratory data analysis disclosed the higher taxonomic signal of the head contour relative to the pronotum one. The scores obtained for validated reclassification were much better for the head (99%) than for the pronotum (82%). This study supports outline morphometrics of the head as a promising approach to contribute to the morphological identification of ant species, at least for monomorphic workers. MDPI 2022-03-14 /pmc/articles/PMC8955869/ /pubmed/35323585 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/insects13030287 Text en © 2022 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Samung, Yudthana
Chaiphongpachara, Tanawat
Ruangsittichai, Jiraporn
Sriwichai, Patchara
Phayakkaphon, Anon
Jaitrong, Weeyawat
Dujardin, Jean-Pierre
Sumruayphol, Suchada
Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics
title Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics
title_full Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics
title_fullStr Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics
title_full_unstemmed Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics
title_short Species Discrimination of Three Odontomachus (Formicidae: Ponerinae) Species in Thailand Using Outline Morphometrics
title_sort species discrimination of three odontomachus (formicidae: ponerinae) species in thailand using outline morphometrics
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8955869/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35323585
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/insects13030287
work_keys_str_mv AT samungyudthana speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT chaiphongpacharatanawat speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT ruangsittichaijiraporn speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT sriwichaipatchara speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT phayakkaphonanon speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT jaitrongweeyawat speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT dujardinjeanpierre speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics
AT sumruaypholsuchada speciesdiscriminationofthreeodontomachusformicidaeponerinaespeciesinthailandusingoutlinemorphometrics