Cargando…
Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Documentation is important for quality improvement, education, and research. There is currently a lack of recommendations regarding key aspects of documentation in regional anesthesia. The aim of this study was to establish recommendations for documentation in regional ane...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
BMJ Publishing Group
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8961753/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35193970 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/rapm-2021-103136 |
_version_ | 1784677664288669696 |
---|---|
author | Ahmed, Hassan M Atterton, Benjamin P Crowe, Gillian G Barratta, Jaime L Johnson, Mark Viscusi, Eugene Adhikary, Sanjib Albrecht, Eric Boretsky, Karen Boublik, Jan Breslin, Dara S Byrne, Kelly Ch'ng, Alan Chuan, Alwin Conroy, Patrick Daniel, Craig Daszkiewicz, Andrzej Delbos, Alain Dirzu, Dan Sebastian Dmytriiev, Dmytro Fennessy, Paul Fischer, H Barrie J Frizelle, Henry Gadsden, Jeff Gautier, Philippe Gupta, Rajnish K Gürkan, Yavuz Hardman, Harold David Harrop-Griffiths, William Hebbard, Peter Hernandez, Nadia Hlasny, Jakub Iohom, Gabriella Ip, Vivian H Y Jeng, Christina L Johnson, Rebecca L Kalagara, Hari Kinirons, Brian Lansdown, Andrew Kenneth Leng, Jody C Lim, Yean Chin Lobo, Clara Ludwin, Danielle B Macfarlane, Alan James Robert Machi, Anthony T Mahon, Padraig Mannion, Stephen McLeod, David H Merjavy, Peter Miscuks, Aleksejs Mitchell, Christopher H Moka, Eleni Moran, Peter Ngui, Ann Nin, Olga C O'Donnell, Brian D Pawa, Amit Perlas, Anahi Porter, Steven Pozek, John-Paul Rebelo, Humberto C Roqués, Vicente Schroeder, Kristopher M Schwartz, Gary Schwenk, Eric S Sermeus, Luc Shorten, George Srinivasan, Karthikeyan Stevens, Markus F Theodoraki, Kassiani Turbitt, Lloyd R Valdés-Vilches, Luis Fernando Volk, Thomas Webster, Katrina Wiesmann, T Wilson, Sylvia H Wolmarans, Morné Woodworth, Glenn Worek, Andrew K Moran, E M Louise |
author_facet | Ahmed, Hassan M Atterton, Benjamin P Crowe, Gillian G Barratta, Jaime L Johnson, Mark Viscusi, Eugene Adhikary, Sanjib Albrecht, Eric Boretsky, Karen Boublik, Jan Breslin, Dara S Byrne, Kelly Ch'ng, Alan Chuan, Alwin Conroy, Patrick Daniel, Craig Daszkiewicz, Andrzej Delbos, Alain Dirzu, Dan Sebastian Dmytriiev, Dmytro Fennessy, Paul Fischer, H Barrie J Frizelle, Henry Gadsden, Jeff Gautier, Philippe Gupta, Rajnish K Gürkan, Yavuz Hardman, Harold David Harrop-Griffiths, William Hebbard, Peter Hernandez, Nadia Hlasny, Jakub Iohom, Gabriella Ip, Vivian H Y Jeng, Christina L Johnson, Rebecca L Kalagara, Hari Kinirons, Brian Lansdown, Andrew Kenneth Leng, Jody C Lim, Yean Chin Lobo, Clara Ludwin, Danielle B Macfarlane, Alan James Robert Machi, Anthony T Mahon, Padraig Mannion, Stephen McLeod, David H Merjavy, Peter Miscuks, Aleksejs Mitchell, Christopher H Moka, Eleni Moran, Peter Ngui, Ann Nin, Olga C O'Donnell, Brian D Pawa, Amit Perlas, Anahi Porter, Steven Pozek, John-Paul Rebelo, Humberto C Roqués, Vicente Schroeder, Kristopher M Schwartz, Gary Schwenk, Eric S Sermeus, Luc Shorten, George Srinivasan, Karthikeyan Stevens, Markus F Theodoraki, Kassiani Turbitt, Lloyd R Valdés-Vilches, Luis Fernando Volk, Thomas Webster, Katrina Wiesmann, T Wilson, Sylvia H Wolmarans, Morné Woodworth, Glenn Worek, Andrew K Moran, E M Louise |
author_sort | Ahmed, Hassan M |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Documentation is important for quality improvement, education, and research. There is currently a lack of recommendations regarding key aspects of documentation in regional anesthesia. The aim of this study was to establish recommendations for documentation in regional anesthesia. METHODS: Following the formation of the executive committee and a directed literature review, a long list of potential documentation components was created. A modified Delphi process was then employed to achieve consensus amongst a group of international experts in regional anesthesia. This consisted of 2 rounds of anonymous electronic voting and a final virtual round table discussion with live polling on items not yet excluded or accepted from previous rounds. Progression or exclusion of potential components through the rounds was based on the achievement of strong consensus. Strong consensus was defined as ≥75% agreement and weak consensus as 50%–74% agreement. RESULTS: Seventy-seven collaborators participated in both rounds 1 and 2, while 50 collaborators took part in round 3. In total, experts voted on 83 items and achieved a strong consensus on 51 items, weak consensus on 3 and rejected 29. CONCLUSION: By means of a modified Delphi process, we have established expert consensus on documentation in regional anesthesia. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8961753 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | BMJ Publishing Group |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-89617532022-04-11 Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project Ahmed, Hassan M Atterton, Benjamin P Crowe, Gillian G Barratta, Jaime L Johnson, Mark Viscusi, Eugene Adhikary, Sanjib Albrecht, Eric Boretsky, Karen Boublik, Jan Breslin, Dara S Byrne, Kelly Ch'ng, Alan Chuan, Alwin Conroy, Patrick Daniel, Craig Daszkiewicz, Andrzej Delbos, Alain Dirzu, Dan Sebastian Dmytriiev, Dmytro Fennessy, Paul Fischer, H Barrie J Frizelle, Henry Gadsden, Jeff Gautier, Philippe Gupta, Rajnish K Gürkan, Yavuz Hardman, Harold David Harrop-Griffiths, William Hebbard, Peter Hernandez, Nadia Hlasny, Jakub Iohom, Gabriella Ip, Vivian H Y Jeng, Christina L Johnson, Rebecca L Kalagara, Hari Kinirons, Brian Lansdown, Andrew Kenneth Leng, Jody C Lim, Yean Chin Lobo, Clara Ludwin, Danielle B Macfarlane, Alan James Robert Machi, Anthony T Mahon, Padraig Mannion, Stephen McLeod, David H Merjavy, Peter Miscuks, Aleksejs Mitchell, Christopher H Moka, Eleni Moran, Peter Ngui, Ann Nin, Olga C O'Donnell, Brian D Pawa, Amit Perlas, Anahi Porter, Steven Pozek, John-Paul Rebelo, Humberto C Roqués, Vicente Schroeder, Kristopher M Schwartz, Gary Schwenk, Eric S Sermeus, Luc Shorten, George Srinivasan, Karthikeyan Stevens, Markus F Theodoraki, Kassiani Turbitt, Lloyd R Valdés-Vilches, Luis Fernando Volk, Thomas Webster, Katrina Wiesmann, T Wilson, Sylvia H Wolmarans, Morné Woodworth, Glenn Worek, Andrew K Moran, E M Louise Reg Anesth Pain Med Original Research BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Documentation is important for quality improvement, education, and research. There is currently a lack of recommendations regarding key aspects of documentation in regional anesthesia. The aim of this study was to establish recommendations for documentation in regional anesthesia. METHODS: Following the formation of the executive committee and a directed literature review, a long list of potential documentation components was created. A modified Delphi process was then employed to achieve consensus amongst a group of international experts in regional anesthesia. This consisted of 2 rounds of anonymous electronic voting and a final virtual round table discussion with live polling on items not yet excluded or accepted from previous rounds. Progression or exclusion of potential components through the rounds was based on the achievement of strong consensus. Strong consensus was defined as ≥75% agreement and weak consensus as 50%–74% agreement. RESULTS: Seventy-seven collaborators participated in both rounds 1 and 2, while 50 collaborators took part in round 3. In total, experts voted on 83 items and achieved a strong consensus on 51 items, weak consensus on 3 and rejected 29. CONCLUSION: By means of a modified Delphi process, we have established expert consensus on documentation in regional anesthesia. BMJ Publishing Group 2022-05 2022-02-22 /pmc/articles/PMC8961753/ /pubmed/35193970 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/rapm-2021-103136 Text en © American Society of Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine 2022. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. Published by BMJ. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, an indication of whether changes were made, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) . |
spellingShingle | Original Research Ahmed, Hassan M Atterton, Benjamin P Crowe, Gillian G Barratta, Jaime L Johnson, Mark Viscusi, Eugene Adhikary, Sanjib Albrecht, Eric Boretsky, Karen Boublik, Jan Breslin, Dara S Byrne, Kelly Ch'ng, Alan Chuan, Alwin Conroy, Patrick Daniel, Craig Daszkiewicz, Andrzej Delbos, Alain Dirzu, Dan Sebastian Dmytriiev, Dmytro Fennessy, Paul Fischer, H Barrie J Frizelle, Henry Gadsden, Jeff Gautier, Philippe Gupta, Rajnish K Gürkan, Yavuz Hardman, Harold David Harrop-Griffiths, William Hebbard, Peter Hernandez, Nadia Hlasny, Jakub Iohom, Gabriella Ip, Vivian H Y Jeng, Christina L Johnson, Rebecca L Kalagara, Hari Kinirons, Brian Lansdown, Andrew Kenneth Leng, Jody C Lim, Yean Chin Lobo, Clara Ludwin, Danielle B Macfarlane, Alan James Robert Machi, Anthony T Mahon, Padraig Mannion, Stephen McLeod, David H Merjavy, Peter Miscuks, Aleksejs Mitchell, Christopher H Moka, Eleni Moran, Peter Ngui, Ann Nin, Olga C O'Donnell, Brian D Pawa, Amit Perlas, Anahi Porter, Steven Pozek, John-Paul Rebelo, Humberto C Roqués, Vicente Schroeder, Kristopher M Schwartz, Gary Schwenk, Eric S Sermeus, Luc Shorten, George Srinivasan, Karthikeyan Stevens, Markus F Theodoraki, Kassiani Turbitt, Lloyd R Valdés-Vilches, Luis Fernando Volk, Thomas Webster, Katrina Wiesmann, T Wilson, Sylvia H Wolmarans, Morné Woodworth, Glenn Worek, Andrew K Moran, E M Louise Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project |
title | Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project |
title_full | Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project |
title_fullStr | Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project |
title_full_unstemmed | Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project |
title_short | Recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel Delphi consensus project |
title_sort | recommendations for effective documentation in regional anesthesia: an expert panel delphi consensus project |
topic | Original Research |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8961753/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35193970 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/rapm-2021-103136 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT ahmedhassanm recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT attertonbenjaminp recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT crowegilliang recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT barrattajaimel recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT johnsonmark recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT viscusieugene recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT adhikarysanjib recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT albrechteric recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT boretskykaren recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT boublikjan recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT breslindaras recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT byrnekelly recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT chngalan recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT chuanalwin recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT conroypatrick recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT danielcraig recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT daszkiewiczandrzej recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT delbosalain recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT dirzudansebastian recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT dmytriievdmytro recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT fennessypaul recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT fischerhbarriej recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT frizellehenry recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT gadsdenjeff recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT gautierphilippe recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT guptarajnishk recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT gurkanyavuz recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT hardmanharolddavid recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT harropgriffithswilliam recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT hebbardpeter recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT hernandeznadia recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT hlasnyjakub recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT iohomgabriella recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT ipvivianhy recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT jengchristinal recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT johnsonrebeccal recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT kalagarahari recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT kinironsbrian recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT lansdownandrewkenneth recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT lengjodyc recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT limyeanchin recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT loboclara recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT ludwindanielleb recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT macfarlanealanjamesrobert recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT machianthonyt recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT mahonpadraig recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT mannionstephen recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT mcleoddavidh recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT merjavypeter recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT miscuksaleksejs recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT mitchellchristopherh recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT mokaeleni recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT moranpeter recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT nguiann recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT ninolgac recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT odonnellbriand recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT pawaamit recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT perlasanahi recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT portersteven recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT pozekjohnpaul recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT rebelohumbertoc recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT roquesvicente recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT schroederkristopherm recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT schwartzgary recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT schwenkerics recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT sermeusluc recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT shortengeorge recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT srinivasankarthikeyan recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT stevensmarkusf recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT theodorakikassiani recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT turbittlloydr recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT valdesvilchesluisfernando recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT volkthomas recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT websterkatrina recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT wiesmannt recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT wilsonsylviah recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT wolmaransmorne recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT woodworthglenn recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT worekandrewk recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject AT moranemlouise recommendationsforeffectivedocumentationinregionalanesthesiaanexpertpaneldelphiconsensusproject |