Cargando…

The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality

BACKGROUND: Symptomatic dengue infection can result in a life-threatening shock syndrome and timely diagnosis is essential. Point-of-care tests for non-structural protein 1 and IgM are used widely but performance can be limited. We developed a supervised machine learning model to predict whether pat...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ming, Damien K., Tuan, Nguyen M., Hernandez, Bernard, Sangkaew, Sorawat, Vuong, Nguyen L., Chanh, Ho Q., Chau, Nguyen V. V., Simmons, Cameron P., Wills, Bridget, Georgiou, Pantelis, Holmes, Alison H., Yacoub, Sophie
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8963938/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35360365
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fdgth.2022.849641
_version_ 1784678098405425152
author Ming, Damien K.
Tuan, Nguyen M.
Hernandez, Bernard
Sangkaew, Sorawat
Vuong, Nguyen L.
Chanh, Ho Q.
Chau, Nguyen V. V.
Simmons, Cameron P.
Wills, Bridget
Georgiou, Pantelis
Holmes, Alison H.
Yacoub, Sophie
author_facet Ming, Damien K.
Tuan, Nguyen M.
Hernandez, Bernard
Sangkaew, Sorawat
Vuong, Nguyen L.
Chanh, Ho Q.
Chau, Nguyen V. V.
Simmons, Cameron P.
Wills, Bridget
Georgiou, Pantelis
Holmes, Alison H.
Yacoub, Sophie
author_sort Ming, Damien K.
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Symptomatic dengue infection can result in a life-threatening shock syndrome and timely diagnosis is essential. Point-of-care tests for non-structural protein 1 and IgM are used widely but performance can be limited. We developed a supervised machine learning model to predict whether patients with acute febrile illnesses had a diagnosis of dengue or other febrile illnesses (OFI). The impact of seasonality on model performance over time was examined. METHODS: We analysed data from a prospective observational clinical study in Vietnam. Enrolled patients presented with an acute febrile illness of <72 h duration. A gradient boosting model (XGBoost) was used to predict final diagnosis using age, sex, haematocrit, platelet, white cell, and lymphocyte count collected on enrolment. Data was randomly split 80/20% into a training and hold-out set, respectively, with the latter not used in model development. Cross-validation and hold out set testing was used, with performance over time evaluated through a rolling window approach. RESULTS: We included 8,100 patients recruited between 16th October 2010 and 10th December 2014. In total 2,240 (27.7%) patients were diagnosed with dengue infection. The optimised model from training data had an overall median area under the receiver operator curve (AUROC) of 0.86 (interquartile range 0.84–0.86), specificity of 0.92, sensitivity of 0.56, positive predictive value of 0.73, negative predictive value (NPV) of 0.84, and Brier score of 0.13 in predicting the final diagnosis, with similar performances in hold-out set testing (AUROC of 0.86). Model performances varied significantly over time as a function of seasonality and other factors. Incorporation of a dynamic threshold which continuously learns from recent cases resulted in a more consistent performance throughout the year (NPV >90%). CONCLUSION: Supervised machine learning models are able to discriminate between dengue and OFI diagnoses in patients presenting with an early undifferentiated febrile illness. These models could be of clinical utility in supporting healthcare decision-making and provide passive surveillance across dengue endemic regions. Effects of seasonality and changing disease prevalence must however be taken into account—this is of significant importance given unpredictable effects of human-induced climate change and the impact on health.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8963938
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-89639382022-03-30 The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality Ming, Damien K. Tuan, Nguyen M. Hernandez, Bernard Sangkaew, Sorawat Vuong, Nguyen L. Chanh, Ho Q. Chau, Nguyen V. V. Simmons, Cameron P. Wills, Bridget Georgiou, Pantelis Holmes, Alison H. Yacoub, Sophie Front Digit Health Digital Health BACKGROUND: Symptomatic dengue infection can result in a life-threatening shock syndrome and timely diagnosis is essential. Point-of-care tests for non-structural protein 1 and IgM are used widely but performance can be limited. We developed a supervised machine learning model to predict whether patients with acute febrile illnesses had a diagnosis of dengue or other febrile illnesses (OFI). The impact of seasonality on model performance over time was examined. METHODS: We analysed data from a prospective observational clinical study in Vietnam. Enrolled patients presented with an acute febrile illness of <72 h duration. A gradient boosting model (XGBoost) was used to predict final diagnosis using age, sex, haematocrit, platelet, white cell, and lymphocyte count collected on enrolment. Data was randomly split 80/20% into a training and hold-out set, respectively, with the latter not used in model development. Cross-validation and hold out set testing was used, with performance over time evaluated through a rolling window approach. RESULTS: We included 8,100 patients recruited between 16th October 2010 and 10th December 2014. In total 2,240 (27.7%) patients were diagnosed with dengue infection. The optimised model from training data had an overall median area under the receiver operator curve (AUROC) of 0.86 (interquartile range 0.84–0.86), specificity of 0.92, sensitivity of 0.56, positive predictive value of 0.73, negative predictive value (NPV) of 0.84, and Brier score of 0.13 in predicting the final diagnosis, with similar performances in hold-out set testing (AUROC of 0.86). Model performances varied significantly over time as a function of seasonality and other factors. Incorporation of a dynamic threshold which continuously learns from recent cases resulted in a more consistent performance throughout the year (NPV >90%). CONCLUSION: Supervised machine learning models are able to discriminate between dengue and OFI diagnoses in patients presenting with an early undifferentiated febrile illness. These models could be of clinical utility in supporting healthcare decision-making and provide passive surveillance across dengue endemic regions. Effects of seasonality and changing disease prevalence must however be taken into account—this is of significant importance given unpredictable effects of human-induced climate change and the impact on health. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-03-14 /pmc/articles/PMC8963938/ /pubmed/35360365 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fdgth.2022.849641 Text en Copyright © 2022 Ming, Tuan, Hernandez, Sangkaew, Vuong, Chanh, Chau, Simmons, Wills, Georgiou, Holmes and Yacoub. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Digital Health
Ming, Damien K.
Tuan, Nguyen M.
Hernandez, Bernard
Sangkaew, Sorawat
Vuong, Nguyen L.
Chanh, Ho Q.
Chau, Nguyen V. V.
Simmons, Cameron P.
Wills, Bridget
Georgiou, Pantelis
Holmes, Alison H.
Yacoub, Sophie
The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality
title The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality
title_full The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality
title_fullStr The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality
title_full_unstemmed The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality
title_short The Diagnosis of Dengue in Patients Presenting With Acute Febrile Illness Using Supervised Machine Learning and Impact of Seasonality
title_sort diagnosis of dengue in patients presenting with acute febrile illness using supervised machine learning and impact of seasonality
topic Digital Health
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8963938/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35360365
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fdgth.2022.849641
work_keys_str_mv AT mingdamienk thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT tuannguyenm thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT hernandezbernard thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT sangkaewsorawat thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT vuongnguyenl thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT chanhhoq thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT chaunguyenvv thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT simmonscameronp thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT willsbridget thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT georgioupantelis thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT holmesalisonh thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT yacoubsophie thediagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT mingdamienk diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT tuannguyenm diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT hernandezbernard diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT sangkaewsorawat diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT vuongnguyenl diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT chanhhoq diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT chaunguyenvv diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT simmonscameronp diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT willsbridget diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT georgioupantelis diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT holmesalisonh diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality
AT yacoubsophie diagnosisofdengueinpatientspresentingwithacutefebrileillnessusingsupervisedmachinelearningandimpactofseasonality