Biomechanical Analysis of Unstable Osteochondral Fragment Fixation Using Three Different Techniques: Osteochondral Plug, Bioabsorbable Pin, and Suture Anchor with Tape

PURPOSE: To compare the initial fixation strength of osteochondral fragment fixations using osteochondral plugs, bioabsorbable pins, and knotless suture anchors. METHODS: Eighteen fresh-frozen immature (6 month old) porcine knees were used. An osteochondral fragment, cut from the articular surface of the medial femoral condyle to achieve a thickness of 5 mm, was used to mimic the unstable osteochondral fragment. It was fixed using three techniques, including two osteochondral plugs (osteochondral plug group), four full-threaded poly l-lactic acid pins (bioabsorbable pin group), and three suture anchors with a 2-0 tape (suture anchor group). Tensile loads at displacements of 1 and 2 mm and ultimate failure load were measured at a cross-head speed of 100 mm/min, and the variables of the three groups were compared statistically using a one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s honestly significant difference test. RESULTS: There was no significant difference in the tensile load to achieve 1-mm displacement. The load to achieve 2-mm displacement and the ultimate failure load were significantly greater in the suture anchor group than the osteochondral plug group and the bioabsorbable pin group. CONCLUSIONS: Single-pull destructive testing of a fixed articular osteochondral fragment with the force perpendicular to the articular surface, demonstrated no statistical difference in the tensile load to achieve 1-mm displacement, but the load to achieve 2-mm displacement was significantly greater for the three suture anchor-interlocking 2-0 tape constructs than the dual osteochondral plug fixation and the four bioabsorbable pin fixation constructs. Additionally, the three suture anchor-interlocking 2-0 tape construct’s mean single-pull failure load was greater than other two fixation procedures. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: To achieve osteochondral fragment union, sufficient fixation strength is critical. However, the initial fixation strength of osteochondral plugs, bioabsorbable pins, and knotless suture anchors for unstable osteochondral lesions remains unclear.