Ophthalmic Telesurgery with a Low-Cost Smartphone Video System for Surgeon Self-Reflection and Remote Synchronous Consultation: A Qualitative and Quantitative Study

SUMMARY: More than a third of the global burden of blindness is due to cataracts, yet cataract surgery is one of the most cost-effective surgical treatments in medicine. Poor surgical outcomes in many settings remain a major challenge, raising concerns about the quality and efficacy of surgical training. Reflective learning from video recordings of a trainees' surgical performance has a high educational impact and is available routinely for surgical training within high-resource institutions. However, the prohibitive cost and limited portability of current surgical video recording systems make its use problematic in low-resource settings and outreach environments. OBJECTIVE: The study's aim was to evaluate the potential of smartphone-captured surgical videos for surgeon learning via self-recording and self-review as well as the potential to support live telesurgical consultation. METHODOLOGY: A quantitative and qualitative methodology was used to explore and describe the utility and acceptance of smartphone videos in two training facilities in Nepal. Twenty surgeries were recorded on the smartphone for surgeon self-review, to assess image quality, and its application to measure performance against the International Council of Ophthalmology (ICO) Ophthalmology Surgical Competency Assessment Rubrics (OSCAR) SICS Rubric. The same system was used to transmit 15 different surgeries live via Skype from Nepal to an ophthalmologist surgical trainer in South Africa to evaluate the feasibility of live consultation. FINDINGS: Overall video quality was described as high in 65% and moderate in 35% for the videos recorded for self-review. In the surgeries streamed via Skype, quality was described as high in 92.9% and moderate in 7.1%. There were no instances where the video quality was described as poor. The video quality was good enough that the surgeons could measure against ICO-OSCAR rubric in all cases. DISCUSSION: The video quality of smartphone-captured surgical videos was found to be high and gained acceptance for reflective teaching and learning purposes. The extended telesurgical potential and portability of the smartphone enables use across many settings. More studies over a longer period are needed to determine how they can support training and learning in cataract surgery.