Cargando…
Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study
Neuroanatomical abnormalities have been reported along a continuum from at-risk stages, including high schizotypy, to early and chronic psychosis. However, a comprehensive neuroanatomical mapping of schizotypy remains to be established. The authors conducted the first large-scale meta-analyses of co...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Nature Publishing Group UK
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9054674/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34707236 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41380-021-01359-9 |
_version_ | 1784697243162378240 |
---|---|
author | Kirschner, Matthias Hodzic-Santor, Benazir Antoniades, Mathilde Nenadic, Igor Kircher, Tilo Krug, Axel Meller, Tina Grotegerd, Dominik Fornito, Alex Arnatkeviciute, Aurina Bellgrove, Mark A. Tiego, Jeggan Dannlowski, Udo Koch, Katharina Hülsmann, Carina Kugel, Harald Enneking, Verena Klug, Melissa Leehr, Elisabeth J. Böhnlein, Joscha Gruber, Marius Mehler, David DeRosse, Pamela Moyett, Ashley Baune, Bernhard T. Green, Melissa Quidé, Yann Pantelis, Christos Chan, Raymond Wang, Yi Ettinger, Ulrich Debbané, Martin Derome, Melodie Gaser, Christian Besteher, Bianca Diederen, Kelly Spencer, Tom J. Fletcher, Paul Rössler, Wulf Smigielski, Lukasz Kumari, Veena Premkumar, Preethi Park, Haeme R. P. Wiebels, Kristina Lemmers-Jansen, Imke Gilleen, James Allen, Paul Kozhuharova, Petya Marsman, Jan-Bernard Lebedeva, Irina Tomyshev, Alexander Mukhorina, Anna Kaiser, Stefan Fett, Anne-Kathrin Sommer, Iris Schuite-Koops, Sanne Paquola, Casey Larivière, Sara Bernhardt, Boris Dagher, Alain Grant, Phillip van Erp, Theo G. M. Turner, Jessica A. Thompson, Paul M. Aleman, André Modinos, Gemma |
author_facet | Kirschner, Matthias Hodzic-Santor, Benazir Antoniades, Mathilde Nenadic, Igor Kircher, Tilo Krug, Axel Meller, Tina Grotegerd, Dominik Fornito, Alex Arnatkeviciute, Aurina Bellgrove, Mark A. Tiego, Jeggan Dannlowski, Udo Koch, Katharina Hülsmann, Carina Kugel, Harald Enneking, Verena Klug, Melissa Leehr, Elisabeth J. Böhnlein, Joscha Gruber, Marius Mehler, David DeRosse, Pamela Moyett, Ashley Baune, Bernhard T. Green, Melissa Quidé, Yann Pantelis, Christos Chan, Raymond Wang, Yi Ettinger, Ulrich Debbané, Martin Derome, Melodie Gaser, Christian Besteher, Bianca Diederen, Kelly Spencer, Tom J. Fletcher, Paul Rössler, Wulf Smigielski, Lukasz Kumari, Veena Premkumar, Preethi Park, Haeme R. P. Wiebels, Kristina Lemmers-Jansen, Imke Gilleen, James Allen, Paul Kozhuharova, Petya Marsman, Jan-Bernard Lebedeva, Irina Tomyshev, Alexander Mukhorina, Anna Kaiser, Stefan Fett, Anne-Kathrin Sommer, Iris Schuite-Koops, Sanne Paquola, Casey Larivière, Sara Bernhardt, Boris Dagher, Alain Grant, Phillip van Erp, Theo G. M. Turner, Jessica A. Thompson, Paul M. Aleman, André Modinos, Gemma |
author_sort | Kirschner, Matthias |
collection | PubMed |
description | Neuroanatomical abnormalities have been reported along a continuum from at-risk stages, including high schizotypy, to early and chronic psychosis. However, a comprehensive neuroanatomical mapping of schizotypy remains to be established. The authors conducted the first large-scale meta-analyses of cortical and subcortical morphometric patterns of schizotypy in healthy individuals, and compared these patterns with neuroanatomical abnormalities observed in major psychiatric disorders. The sample comprised 3004 unmedicated healthy individuals (12–68 years, 46.5% male) from 29 cohorts of the worldwide ENIGMA Schizotypy working group. Cortical and subcortical effect size maps with schizotypy scores were generated using standardized methods. Pattern similarities were assessed between the schizotypy-related cortical and subcortical maps and effect size maps from comparisons of schizophrenia (SZ), bipolar disorder (BD) and major depression (MDD) patients with controls. Thicker right medial orbitofrontal/ventromedial prefrontal cortex (mOFC/vmPFC) was associated with higher schizotypy scores (r = 0.067, p(FDR) = 0.02). The cortical thickness profile in schizotypy was positively correlated with cortical abnormalities in SZ (r = 0.285, p(spin) = 0.024), but not BD (r = 0.166, p(spin) = 0.205) or MDD (r = −0.274, p(spin) = 0.073). The schizotypy-related subcortical volume pattern was negatively correlated with subcortical abnormalities in SZ (rho = −0.690, p(spin) = 0.006), BD (rho = −0.672, p(spin) = 0.009), and MDD (rho = −0.692, p(spin) = 0.004). Comprehensive mapping of schizotypy-related brain morphometry in the general population revealed a significant relationship between higher schizotypy and thicker mOFC/vmPFC, in the absence of confounding effects due to antipsychotic medication or disease chronicity. The cortical pattern similarity between schizotypy and schizophrenia yields new insights into a dimensional neurobiological continuity across the extended psychosis phenotype. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9054674 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Nature Publishing Group UK |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-90546742022-05-01 Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study Kirschner, Matthias Hodzic-Santor, Benazir Antoniades, Mathilde Nenadic, Igor Kircher, Tilo Krug, Axel Meller, Tina Grotegerd, Dominik Fornito, Alex Arnatkeviciute, Aurina Bellgrove, Mark A. Tiego, Jeggan Dannlowski, Udo Koch, Katharina Hülsmann, Carina Kugel, Harald Enneking, Verena Klug, Melissa Leehr, Elisabeth J. Böhnlein, Joscha Gruber, Marius Mehler, David DeRosse, Pamela Moyett, Ashley Baune, Bernhard T. Green, Melissa Quidé, Yann Pantelis, Christos Chan, Raymond Wang, Yi Ettinger, Ulrich Debbané, Martin Derome, Melodie Gaser, Christian Besteher, Bianca Diederen, Kelly Spencer, Tom J. Fletcher, Paul Rössler, Wulf Smigielski, Lukasz Kumari, Veena Premkumar, Preethi Park, Haeme R. P. Wiebels, Kristina Lemmers-Jansen, Imke Gilleen, James Allen, Paul Kozhuharova, Petya Marsman, Jan-Bernard Lebedeva, Irina Tomyshev, Alexander Mukhorina, Anna Kaiser, Stefan Fett, Anne-Kathrin Sommer, Iris Schuite-Koops, Sanne Paquola, Casey Larivière, Sara Bernhardt, Boris Dagher, Alain Grant, Phillip van Erp, Theo G. M. Turner, Jessica A. Thompson, Paul M. Aleman, André Modinos, Gemma Mol Psychiatry Article Neuroanatomical abnormalities have been reported along a continuum from at-risk stages, including high schizotypy, to early and chronic psychosis. However, a comprehensive neuroanatomical mapping of schizotypy remains to be established. The authors conducted the first large-scale meta-analyses of cortical and subcortical morphometric patterns of schizotypy in healthy individuals, and compared these patterns with neuroanatomical abnormalities observed in major psychiatric disorders. The sample comprised 3004 unmedicated healthy individuals (12–68 years, 46.5% male) from 29 cohorts of the worldwide ENIGMA Schizotypy working group. Cortical and subcortical effect size maps with schizotypy scores were generated using standardized methods. Pattern similarities were assessed between the schizotypy-related cortical and subcortical maps and effect size maps from comparisons of schizophrenia (SZ), bipolar disorder (BD) and major depression (MDD) patients with controls. Thicker right medial orbitofrontal/ventromedial prefrontal cortex (mOFC/vmPFC) was associated with higher schizotypy scores (r = 0.067, p(FDR) = 0.02). The cortical thickness profile in schizotypy was positively correlated with cortical abnormalities in SZ (r = 0.285, p(spin) = 0.024), but not BD (r = 0.166, p(spin) = 0.205) or MDD (r = −0.274, p(spin) = 0.073). The schizotypy-related subcortical volume pattern was negatively correlated with subcortical abnormalities in SZ (rho = −0.690, p(spin) = 0.006), BD (rho = −0.672, p(spin) = 0.009), and MDD (rho = −0.692, p(spin) = 0.004). Comprehensive mapping of schizotypy-related brain morphometry in the general population revealed a significant relationship between higher schizotypy and thicker mOFC/vmPFC, in the absence of confounding effects due to antipsychotic medication or disease chronicity. The cortical pattern similarity between schizotypy and schizophrenia yields new insights into a dimensional neurobiological continuity across the extended psychosis phenotype. Nature Publishing Group UK 2021-10-27 2022 /pmc/articles/PMC9054674/ /pubmed/34707236 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41380-021-01359-9 Text en © The Author(s) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . |
spellingShingle | Article Kirschner, Matthias Hodzic-Santor, Benazir Antoniades, Mathilde Nenadic, Igor Kircher, Tilo Krug, Axel Meller, Tina Grotegerd, Dominik Fornito, Alex Arnatkeviciute, Aurina Bellgrove, Mark A. Tiego, Jeggan Dannlowski, Udo Koch, Katharina Hülsmann, Carina Kugel, Harald Enneking, Verena Klug, Melissa Leehr, Elisabeth J. Böhnlein, Joscha Gruber, Marius Mehler, David DeRosse, Pamela Moyett, Ashley Baune, Bernhard T. Green, Melissa Quidé, Yann Pantelis, Christos Chan, Raymond Wang, Yi Ettinger, Ulrich Debbané, Martin Derome, Melodie Gaser, Christian Besteher, Bianca Diederen, Kelly Spencer, Tom J. Fletcher, Paul Rössler, Wulf Smigielski, Lukasz Kumari, Veena Premkumar, Preethi Park, Haeme R. P. Wiebels, Kristina Lemmers-Jansen, Imke Gilleen, James Allen, Paul Kozhuharova, Petya Marsman, Jan-Bernard Lebedeva, Irina Tomyshev, Alexander Mukhorina, Anna Kaiser, Stefan Fett, Anne-Kathrin Sommer, Iris Schuite-Koops, Sanne Paquola, Casey Larivière, Sara Bernhardt, Boris Dagher, Alain Grant, Phillip van Erp, Theo G. M. Turner, Jessica A. Thompson, Paul M. Aleman, André Modinos, Gemma Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study |
title | Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study |
title_full | Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study |
title_fullStr | Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study |
title_full_unstemmed | Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study |
title_short | Cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide ENIGMA study |
title_sort | cortical and subcortical neuroanatomical signatures of schizotypy in 3004 individuals assessed in a worldwide enigma study |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9054674/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34707236 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41380-021-01359-9 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT kirschnermatthias corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT hodzicsantorbenazir corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT antoniadesmathilde corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT nenadicigor corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT kirchertilo corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT krugaxel corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT mellertina corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT grotegerddominik corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT fornitoalex corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT arnatkeviciuteaurina corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT bellgrovemarka corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT tiegojeggan corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT dannlowskiudo corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT kochkatharina corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT hulsmanncarina corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT kugelharald corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT ennekingverena corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT klugmelissa corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT leehrelisabethj corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT bohnleinjoscha corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT grubermarius corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT mehlerdavid corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT derossepamela corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT moyettashley corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT baunebernhardt corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT greenmelissa corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT quideyann corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT pantelischristos corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT chanraymond corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT wangyi corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT ettingerulrich corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT debbanemartin corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT deromemelodie corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT gaserchristian corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT besteherbianca corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT diederenkelly corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT spencertomj corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT fletcherpaul corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT rosslerwulf corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT smigielskilukasz corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT kumariveena corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT premkumarpreethi corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT parkhaemerp corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT wiebelskristina corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT lemmersjansenimke corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT gilleenjames corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT allenpaul corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT kozhuharovapetya corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT marsmanjanbernard corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT lebedevairina corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT tomyshevalexander corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT mukhorinaanna corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT kaiserstefan corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT fettannekathrin corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT sommeriris corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT schuitekoopssanne corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT paquolacasey corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT larivieresara corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT bernhardtboris corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT dagheralain corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT grantphillip corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT vanerptheogm corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT turnerjessicaa corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT thompsonpaulm corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT alemanandre corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy AT modinosgemma corticalandsubcorticalneuroanatomicalsignaturesofschizotypyin3004individualsassessedinaworldwideenigmastudy |