Cargando…
A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020)
Surveillance of Echinococcus multilocularis at the edge of its range is hindered by fragmented distributional patterns and low prevalence in definitive hosts. Thus, tests with adequate levels of sensitivity are especially important for discriminating between infected and non-infected areas. In this...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9070940/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35511816 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0268045 |
_version_ | 1784700741199331328 |
---|---|
author | Obber, Federica Celva, Roberto Da Rold, Graziana Trevisiol, Karin Ravagnan, Silvia Danesi, Patrizia Cenni, Lucia Rossi, Chiara Bonato, Paola Capello, Katia Hauffe, Heidi C. Massolo, Alessandro Cassini, Rudi Benvenuti, Valentina Agreiter, Andreas Righetti, Davide Ianniello, Marco Dellamaria, Debora Capelli, Gioia Citterio, Carlo V. |
author_facet | Obber, Federica Celva, Roberto Da Rold, Graziana Trevisiol, Karin Ravagnan, Silvia Danesi, Patrizia Cenni, Lucia Rossi, Chiara Bonato, Paola Capello, Katia Hauffe, Heidi C. Massolo, Alessandro Cassini, Rudi Benvenuti, Valentina Agreiter, Andreas Righetti, Davide Ianniello, Marco Dellamaria, Debora Capelli, Gioia Citterio, Carlo V. |
author_sort | Obber, Federica |
collection | PubMed |
description | Surveillance of Echinococcus multilocularis at the edge of its range is hindered by fragmented distributional patterns and low prevalence in definitive hosts. Thus, tests with adequate levels of sensitivity are especially important for discriminating between infected and non-infected areas. In this study we reassessed the prevalence of E. multilocularis at the southern border of its distribution in Province of Bolzano (Alto Adige, northeastern Alps, Italy), to improve surveillance in wildlife and provide more accurate estimates of exposure risk. We compared the diagnostic test currently implemented for surveillance based on coproscopy and multiplex PCR (CMPCR) to a real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) in 235 fox faeces collected in 2019 and 2020. The performances of the two tests were estimated using a scraping technique (SFCT) applied to the small intestines of a subsample (n = 123) of the same foxes as the reference standard. True prevalence was calculated and the sample size required by each faecal test for the detection of the parasite was then estimated. True prevalence of E. multilocularis in foxes (14.3%) was markedly higher than reported in the last decade, which was never more than 5% from 2012 to 2018 in the same area. In addition, qPCR showed a much higher sensitivity (83%) compared to CMPCR (21%) and agreement with the reference standard was far higher for qPCR (0.816) than CMPCR (0.298) meaning that for the latter protocol, a smaller sample size would be required to detect the disease. Alto Adige should be considered a highly endemic area. Routine surveillance on definitive hosts at the edges of the E. multilocularis distribution should be applied to smaller geographic areas, and rapid, sensitive diagnostic tools using directly host faeces, such as qPCR, should be adopted. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9070940 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-90709402022-05-06 A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) Obber, Federica Celva, Roberto Da Rold, Graziana Trevisiol, Karin Ravagnan, Silvia Danesi, Patrizia Cenni, Lucia Rossi, Chiara Bonato, Paola Capello, Katia Hauffe, Heidi C. Massolo, Alessandro Cassini, Rudi Benvenuti, Valentina Agreiter, Andreas Righetti, Davide Ianniello, Marco Dellamaria, Debora Capelli, Gioia Citterio, Carlo V. PLoS One Research Article Surveillance of Echinococcus multilocularis at the edge of its range is hindered by fragmented distributional patterns and low prevalence in definitive hosts. Thus, tests with adequate levels of sensitivity are especially important for discriminating between infected and non-infected areas. In this study we reassessed the prevalence of E. multilocularis at the southern border of its distribution in Province of Bolzano (Alto Adige, northeastern Alps, Italy), to improve surveillance in wildlife and provide more accurate estimates of exposure risk. We compared the diagnostic test currently implemented for surveillance based on coproscopy and multiplex PCR (CMPCR) to a real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) in 235 fox faeces collected in 2019 and 2020. The performances of the two tests were estimated using a scraping technique (SFCT) applied to the small intestines of a subsample (n = 123) of the same foxes as the reference standard. True prevalence was calculated and the sample size required by each faecal test for the detection of the parasite was then estimated. True prevalence of E. multilocularis in foxes (14.3%) was markedly higher than reported in the last decade, which was never more than 5% from 2012 to 2018 in the same area. In addition, qPCR showed a much higher sensitivity (83%) compared to CMPCR (21%) and agreement with the reference standard was far higher for qPCR (0.816) than CMPCR (0.298) meaning that for the latter protocol, a smaller sample size would be required to detect the disease. Alto Adige should be considered a highly endemic area. Routine surveillance on definitive hosts at the edges of the E. multilocularis distribution should be applied to smaller geographic areas, and rapid, sensitive diagnostic tools using directly host faeces, such as qPCR, should be adopted. Public Library of Science 2022-05-05 /pmc/articles/PMC9070940/ /pubmed/35511816 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0268045 Text en © 2022 Obber et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Obber, Federica Celva, Roberto Da Rold, Graziana Trevisiol, Karin Ravagnan, Silvia Danesi, Patrizia Cenni, Lucia Rossi, Chiara Bonato, Paola Capello, Katia Hauffe, Heidi C. Massolo, Alessandro Cassini, Rudi Benvenuti, Valentina Agreiter, Andreas Righetti, Davide Ianniello, Marco Dellamaria, Debora Capelli, Gioia Citterio, Carlo V. A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) |
title | A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) |
title_full | A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) |
title_fullStr | A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) |
title_full_unstemmed | A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) |
title_short | A highly endemic area of Echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), Alto Adige (Italy: 2019–2020) |
title_sort | highly endemic area of echinococcus multilocularis identified through a comparative re-assessment of prevalence in the red fox (vulpes vulpes), alto adige (italy: 2019–2020) |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9070940/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35511816 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0268045 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT obberfederica ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT celvaroberto ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT daroldgraziana ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT trevisiolkarin ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT ravagnansilvia ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT danesipatrizia ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT cennilucia ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT rossichiara ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT bonatopaola ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT capellokatia ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT hauffeheidic ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT massoloalessandro ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT cassinirudi ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT benvenutivalentina ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT agreiterandreas ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT righettidavide ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT ianniellomarco ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT dellamariadebora ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT capelligioia ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT citteriocarlov ahighlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT obberfederica highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT celvaroberto highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT daroldgraziana highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT trevisiolkarin highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT ravagnansilvia highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT danesipatrizia highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT cennilucia highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT rossichiara highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT bonatopaola highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT capellokatia highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT hauffeheidic highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT massoloalessandro highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT cassinirudi highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT benvenutivalentina highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT agreiterandreas highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT righettidavide highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT ianniellomarco highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT dellamariadebora highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT capelligioia highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 AT citteriocarlov highlyendemicareaofechinococcusmultilocularisidentifiedthroughacomparativereassessmentofprevalenceintheredfoxvulpesvulpesaltoadigeitaly20192020 |