Cargando…

Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil

INTRODUCTION: Acute stroke interventions, such as stroke units and reperfusion therapy, have the potential to improve outcomes. However, there are many disparities in patient characteristics and access to the best stroke care. Thus, we aim to compare patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) after s...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques, Borelli, Wyllians Vendramini, Secchi, Thais Leite, Mantovani, Gabriel Paulo, Pille, Arthur, Mora Cuervo, Daissy Liliana, Carbonera, Leonardo Augusto, de Souza, Ana Claudia, Martins, Magda Carla Ouriques, Brondani, Rosane, de Almeida, Andrea Garcia, Dal Pizzol, Angélica, dos Santos, Franciele Pereira, Alves, Ana Claudia, Meier, Nathalia Soares, Andrade, Guilherme Pamplona Bueno, Maciel, Pedro Angst, Weber, Alexandre, Machado, Gustavo Dariva, Parrini, Mohamed, Nasi, Luiz Antonio
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9120355/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35599734
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2022.857094
_version_ 1784710905767919616
author Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques
Borelli, Wyllians Vendramini
Secchi, Thais Leite
Mantovani, Gabriel Paulo
Pille, Arthur
Mora Cuervo, Daissy Liliana
Carbonera, Leonardo Augusto
de Souza, Ana Claudia
Martins, Magda Carla Ouriques
Brondani, Rosane
de Almeida, Andrea Garcia
Dal Pizzol, Angélica
dos Santos, Franciele Pereira
Alves, Ana Claudia
Meier, Nathalia Soares
Andrade, Guilherme Pamplona Bueno
Maciel, Pedro Angst
Weber, Alexandre
Machado, Gustavo Dariva
Parrini, Mohamed
Nasi, Luiz Antonio
author_facet Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques
Borelli, Wyllians Vendramini
Secchi, Thais Leite
Mantovani, Gabriel Paulo
Pille, Arthur
Mora Cuervo, Daissy Liliana
Carbonera, Leonardo Augusto
de Souza, Ana Claudia
Martins, Magda Carla Ouriques
Brondani, Rosane
de Almeida, Andrea Garcia
Dal Pizzol, Angélica
dos Santos, Franciele Pereira
Alves, Ana Claudia
Meier, Nathalia Soares
Andrade, Guilherme Pamplona Bueno
Maciel, Pedro Angst
Weber, Alexandre
Machado, Gustavo Dariva
Parrini, Mohamed
Nasi, Luiz Antonio
author_sort Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Acute stroke interventions, such as stroke units and reperfusion therapy, have the potential to improve outcomes. However, there are many disparities in patient characteristics and access to the best stroke care. Thus, we aim to compare patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) after stroke in two stroke centers representing the public and private healthcare systems in Brazil. METHODS: PROMs through the International Consortium for Health Outcomes Measures (ICHOM) were assessed at 90 days after the stroke to compare two Brazilian hospitals in southern Brazil: a public university and a private stroke center, both with stroke protocols and stroke units. RESULTS: When compared with the private setting (n = 165), patients from the public hospital (n = 175) were younger, had poorer control of risk factors, had more frequent previous strokes, and arrived with more severe strokes. Both hospitals had a similar percentage of IV thrombolysis treatment. Only 5 patients received mechanical thrombectomy (MT), all in the private hospital. Public hospital patients presented significantly worse outcomes at 3 months, including worse quality of life and functional dependence (60 vs. 48%, p = 0.03). Poor outcome, as measured by the mRS score, was significantly associated with older age, higher NIHSS score, and the presence of heart failure. However, the public practice was a strong predictor of any self-reported disability. CONCLUSION: Patients assisted at a good quality public stroke center with the same protocol used in the private hospital presented worse disability as measured by mRS and patient-reported outcome measures, with greater inability to communicate, dress, toilet, feed, and walk.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9120355
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-91203552022-05-21 Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques Borelli, Wyllians Vendramini Secchi, Thais Leite Mantovani, Gabriel Paulo Pille, Arthur Mora Cuervo, Daissy Liliana Carbonera, Leonardo Augusto de Souza, Ana Claudia Martins, Magda Carla Ouriques Brondani, Rosane de Almeida, Andrea Garcia Dal Pizzol, Angélica dos Santos, Franciele Pereira Alves, Ana Claudia Meier, Nathalia Soares Andrade, Guilherme Pamplona Bueno Maciel, Pedro Angst Weber, Alexandre Machado, Gustavo Dariva Parrini, Mohamed Nasi, Luiz Antonio Front Neurol Neurology INTRODUCTION: Acute stroke interventions, such as stroke units and reperfusion therapy, have the potential to improve outcomes. However, there are many disparities in patient characteristics and access to the best stroke care. Thus, we aim to compare patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) after stroke in two stroke centers representing the public and private healthcare systems in Brazil. METHODS: PROMs through the International Consortium for Health Outcomes Measures (ICHOM) were assessed at 90 days after the stroke to compare two Brazilian hospitals in southern Brazil: a public university and a private stroke center, both with stroke protocols and stroke units. RESULTS: When compared with the private setting (n = 165), patients from the public hospital (n = 175) were younger, had poorer control of risk factors, had more frequent previous strokes, and arrived with more severe strokes. Both hospitals had a similar percentage of IV thrombolysis treatment. Only 5 patients received mechanical thrombectomy (MT), all in the private hospital. Public hospital patients presented significantly worse outcomes at 3 months, including worse quality of life and functional dependence (60 vs. 48%, p = 0.03). Poor outcome, as measured by the mRS score, was significantly associated with older age, higher NIHSS score, and the presence of heart failure. However, the public practice was a strong predictor of any self-reported disability. CONCLUSION: Patients assisted at a good quality public stroke center with the same protocol used in the private hospital presented worse disability as measured by mRS and patient-reported outcome measures, with greater inability to communicate, dress, toilet, feed, and walk. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-05-06 /pmc/articles/PMC9120355/ /pubmed/35599734 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2022.857094 Text en Copyright © 2022 Martins, Borelli, Secchi, Mantovani, Pille, Mora Cuervo, Carbonera, Souza, Martins, Brondani, Almeida, Dal Pizzol, Santos, Alves, Meier, Andrade, Maciel, Weber, Machado, Parrini and Nasi. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Neurology
Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques
Borelli, Wyllians Vendramini
Secchi, Thais Leite
Mantovani, Gabriel Paulo
Pille, Arthur
Mora Cuervo, Daissy Liliana
Carbonera, Leonardo Augusto
de Souza, Ana Claudia
Martins, Magda Carla Ouriques
Brondani, Rosane
de Almeida, Andrea Garcia
Dal Pizzol, Angélica
dos Santos, Franciele Pereira
Alves, Ana Claudia
Meier, Nathalia Soares
Andrade, Guilherme Pamplona Bueno
Maciel, Pedro Angst
Weber, Alexandre
Machado, Gustavo Dariva
Parrini, Mohamed
Nasi, Luiz Antonio
Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil
title Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil
title_full Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil
title_fullStr Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil
title_full_unstemmed Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil
title_short Disparities in Stroke Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Between Healthcare Systems in Brazil
title_sort disparities in stroke patient-reported outcomes measurement between healthcare systems in brazil
topic Neurology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9120355/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35599734
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2022.857094
work_keys_str_mv AT martinssheilacristinaouriques disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT borelliwylliansvendramini disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT secchithaisleite disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT mantovanigabrielpaulo disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT pillearthur disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT moracuervodaissyliliana disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT carboneraleonardoaugusto disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT desouzaanaclaudia disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT martinsmagdacarlaouriques disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT brondanirosane disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT dealmeidaandreagarcia disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT dalpizzolangelica disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT dossantosfrancielepereira disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT alvesanaclaudia disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT meiernathaliasoares disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT andradeguilhermepamplonabueno disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT macielpedroangst disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT weberalexandre disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT machadogustavodariva disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT parrinimohamed disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil
AT nasiluizantonio disparitiesinstrokepatientreportedoutcomesmeasurementbetweenhealthcaresystemsinbrazil