Cargando…

The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis

The trend of the number of publications on a research field is often used to quantify research interest and effort, but this measure is biased by general publication record inflation. This study introduces a novel metric as an unbiased and quantitative tool for trend analysis and bibliometrics. The...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Nelis, Joost L. D., Rosas da Silva, Gonçalo, Ortuño, Jordi, Tsagkaris, Aristeidis S., Borremans, Benny, Haslova, Jana, Colgrave, Michelle L., Elliott, Christopher T.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9122180/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35594252
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0268433
_version_ 1784711291033616384
author Nelis, Joost L. D.
Rosas da Silva, Gonçalo
Ortuño, Jordi
Tsagkaris, Aristeidis S.
Borremans, Benny
Haslova, Jana
Colgrave, Michelle L.
Elliott, Christopher T.
author_facet Nelis, Joost L. D.
Rosas da Silva, Gonçalo
Ortuño, Jordi
Tsagkaris, Aristeidis S.
Borremans, Benny
Haslova, Jana
Colgrave, Michelle L.
Elliott, Christopher T.
author_sort Nelis, Joost L. D.
collection PubMed
description The trend of the number of publications on a research field is often used to quantify research interest and effort, but this measure is biased by general publication record inflation. This study introduces a novel metric as an unbiased and quantitative tool for trend analysis and bibliometrics. The metric was used to reanalyze reported publication trends and perform in-depth trend analyses on patent groups and a broad range of field in the life-sciences. The analyses confirmed that inflation bias frequently results in the incorrect identification of field-specific increased growth. It was shown that the metric enables a more detailed, quantitative and robust trend analysis of peer reviewed publications and patents. Some examples of the metric’s uses are quantifying inflation-corrected growth in research regarding microplastics (51% ± 10%) between 2012 and 2018 and detecting inflation-corrected growth increase for transcriptomics and metabolomics compared to genomics and proteomics (Tukey post hoc p<0.0001). The developed trend-analysis tool removes inflation bias from bibliometric trend analyses. The metric improves evidence-driven decision-making regarding research effort investment and funding allocation.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9122180
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-91221802022-05-21 The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis Nelis, Joost L. D. Rosas da Silva, Gonçalo Ortuño, Jordi Tsagkaris, Aristeidis S. Borremans, Benny Haslova, Jana Colgrave, Michelle L. Elliott, Christopher T. PLoS One Research Article The trend of the number of publications on a research field is often used to quantify research interest and effort, but this measure is biased by general publication record inflation. This study introduces a novel metric as an unbiased and quantitative tool for trend analysis and bibliometrics. The metric was used to reanalyze reported publication trends and perform in-depth trend analyses on patent groups and a broad range of field in the life-sciences. The analyses confirmed that inflation bias frequently results in the incorrect identification of field-specific increased growth. It was shown that the metric enables a more detailed, quantitative and robust trend analysis of peer reviewed publications and patents. Some examples of the metric’s uses are quantifying inflation-corrected growth in research regarding microplastics (51% ± 10%) between 2012 and 2018 and detecting inflation-corrected growth increase for transcriptomics and metabolomics compared to genomics and proteomics (Tukey post hoc p<0.0001). The developed trend-analysis tool removes inflation bias from bibliometric trend analyses. The metric improves evidence-driven decision-making regarding research effort investment and funding allocation. Public Library of Science 2022-05-20 /pmc/articles/PMC9122180/ /pubmed/35594252 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0268433 Text en © 2022 Nelis et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Nelis, Joost L. D.
Rosas da Silva, Gonçalo
Ortuño, Jordi
Tsagkaris, Aristeidis S.
Borremans, Benny
Haslova, Jana
Colgrave, Michelle L.
Elliott, Christopher T.
The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
title The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
title_full The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
title_fullStr The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
title_full_unstemmed The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
title_short The General Growth Tendency: A tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
title_sort general growth tendency: a tool to improve publication trend reporting by removing record inflation bias and enabling quantitative trend analysis
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9122180/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35594252
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0268433
work_keys_str_mv AT nelisjoostld thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT rosasdasilvagoncalo thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT ortunojordi thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT tsagkarisaristeidiss thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT borremansbenny thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT haslovajana thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT colgravemichellel thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT elliottchristophert thegeneralgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT nelisjoostld generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT rosasdasilvagoncalo generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT ortunojordi generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT tsagkarisaristeidiss generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT borremansbenny generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT haslovajana generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT colgravemichellel generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis
AT elliottchristophert generalgrowthtendencyatooltoimprovepublicationtrendreportingbyremovingrecordinflationbiasandenablingquantitativetrendanalysis