Cargando…
International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions
BACKGROUND: Obstetric infections are the third most common cause of maternal mortality, with the largest burden in low and middle-income countries (LMICs). We analyzed causes of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss identified contributing factors and generated suggested actions for qualit...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
BioMed Central
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9128080/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35606709 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12884-022-04731-x |
_version_ | 1784712487061422080 |
---|---|
author | Okafor, Obiageli Roos, Nathalie Abdosh, Abdulfetah Abdulkadir Adesina, Olubukola Alaoui, Zaynab Romero, William Arriaga Assarag, Bouchra Aworinde, Olufemi de Bernis, Luc Castro, Rigoberto Chrifi, Hassan Day, Louise Tina Demissew, Rahel Aceituno, María Guadalupe Flores Gadama, Luis Gashawbeza, Biruck Keke, Sourou Goufodji Govule, Philip Gwako, George Jayaratne, Kapila Komboigo, Evelyne Béwendin Lara, Bredy Madziyire, Mugove Gerald Mathai, Matthews Moulki, Rachid Moutaouadia, Iatimad Munjanja, Stephen Fletes, Carlos Alberto Ochoa Ortiz, Edgar Ivan Ouedraogo, Henri Gautier Qureshi, Zahida Recidoro, Zenaida Dy Senanayake, Hemantha Soma-Pillay, Priya Tin, Khaing Nwe Sedami, Pascal Worku, Dawit Bonet, Mercedes |
author_facet | Okafor, Obiageli Roos, Nathalie Abdosh, Abdulfetah Abdulkadir Adesina, Olubukola Alaoui, Zaynab Romero, William Arriaga Assarag, Bouchra Aworinde, Olufemi de Bernis, Luc Castro, Rigoberto Chrifi, Hassan Day, Louise Tina Demissew, Rahel Aceituno, María Guadalupe Flores Gadama, Luis Gashawbeza, Biruck Keke, Sourou Goufodji Govule, Philip Gwako, George Jayaratne, Kapila Komboigo, Evelyne Béwendin Lara, Bredy Madziyire, Mugove Gerald Mathai, Matthews Moulki, Rachid Moutaouadia, Iatimad Munjanja, Stephen Fletes, Carlos Alberto Ochoa Ortiz, Edgar Ivan Ouedraogo, Henri Gautier Qureshi, Zahida Recidoro, Zenaida Dy Senanayake, Hemantha Soma-Pillay, Priya Tin, Khaing Nwe Sedami, Pascal Worku, Dawit Bonet, Mercedes |
author_sort | Okafor, Obiageli |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Obstetric infections are the third most common cause of maternal mortality, with the largest burden in low and middle-income countries (LMICs). We analyzed causes of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss identified contributing factors and generated suggested actions for quality of care improvement. METHOD: An international, virtual confidential enquiry was conducted for maternal deaths and near-miss cases that occurred in 15 health facilities in 11 LMICs reporting at least one death within the GLOSS study. Facility medical records and local review committee documents containing information on maternal characteristics, timing and chain of events, case management, outcomes, and facility characteristics were summarized into a case report for each woman and reviewed by an international external review committee. Modifiable factors were identified and suggested actions were organized using the three delays framework. RESULTS: Thirteen infection-related maternal deaths and 19 near-miss cases were reviewed in 20 virtual meetings by an international external review committee. Of 151 modifiable factors identified during the review, delays in receiving care contributed to 71/85 modifiable factors in maternal deaths and 55/66 modifiable factors in near-miss cases. Delays in reaching a GLOSS facility contributed to 5/85 and 1/66 modifiable factors for maternal deaths and near-miss cases, respectively. Two modifiable factors in maternal deaths were related to delays in the decision to seek care compared to three modifiable factors in near-miss cases. Suboptimal use of antibiotics, missing microbiological culture and other laboratory results, incorrect working diagnosis, and infrequent monitoring during admission were the main contributors to care delays among both maternal deaths and near-miss cases. Local facility audits were conducted for 2/13 maternal deaths and 0/19 near-miss cases. Based on the review findings, the external review committee recommended actions to improve the prevention and management of maternal infections. CONCLUSION: Prompt recognition and treatment of the infection remain critical addressable gaps in the provision of high-quality care to prevent and manage infection-related severe maternal outcomes in LMICs. Poor uptake of maternal death and near-miss reviews suggests missed learning opportunities by facility teams. Virtual platforms offer a feasible solution to improve routine adoption of confidential maternal death and near-miss reviews locally. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12884-022-04731-x. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9128080 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | BioMed Central |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-91280802022-05-25 International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions Okafor, Obiageli Roos, Nathalie Abdosh, Abdulfetah Abdulkadir Adesina, Olubukola Alaoui, Zaynab Romero, William Arriaga Assarag, Bouchra Aworinde, Olufemi de Bernis, Luc Castro, Rigoberto Chrifi, Hassan Day, Louise Tina Demissew, Rahel Aceituno, María Guadalupe Flores Gadama, Luis Gashawbeza, Biruck Keke, Sourou Goufodji Govule, Philip Gwako, George Jayaratne, Kapila Komboigo, Evelyne Béwendin Lara, Bredy Madziyire, Mugove Gerald Mathai, Matthews Moulki, Rachid Moutaouadia, Iatimad Munjanja, Stephen Fletes, Carlos Alberto Ochoa Ortiz, Edgar Ivan Ouedraogo, Henri Gautier Qureshi, Zahida Recidoro, Zenaida Dy Senanayake, Hemantha Soma-Pillay, Priya Tin, Khaing Nwe Sedami, Pascal Worku, Dawit Bonet, Mercedes BMC Pregnancy Childbirth Research BACKGROUND: Obstetric infections are the third most common cause of maternal mortality, with the largest burden in low and middle-income countries (LMICs). We analyzed causes of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss identified contributing factors and generated suggested actions for quality of care improvement. METHOD: An international, virtual confidential enquiry was conducted for maternal deaths and near-miss cases that occurred in 15 health facilities in 11 LMICs reporting at least one death within the GLOSS study. Facility medical records and local review committee documents containing information on maternal characteristics, timing and chain of events, case management, outcomes, and facility characteristics were summarized into a case report for each woman and reviewed by an international external review committee. Modifiable factors were identified and suggested actions were organized using the three delays framework. RESULTS: Thirteen infection-related maternal deaths and 19 near-miss cases were reviewed in 20 virtual meetings by an international external review committee. Of 151 modifiable factors identified during the review, delays in receiving care contributed to 71/85 modifiable factors in maternal deaths and 55/66 modifiable factors in near-miss cases. Delays in reaching a GLOSS facility contributed to 5/85 and 1/66 modifiable factors for maternal deaths and near-miss cases, respectively. Two modifiable factors in maternal deaths were related to delays in the decision to seek care compared to three modifiable factors in near-miss cases. Suboptimal use of antibiotics, missing microbiological culture and other laboratory results, incorrect working diagnosis, and infrequent monitoring during admission were the main contributors to care delays among both maternal deaths and near-miss cases. Local facility audits were conducted for 2/13 maternal deaths and 0/19 near-miss cases. Based on the review findings, the external review committee recommended actions to improve the prevention and management of maternal infections. CONCLUSION: Prompt recognition and treatment of the infection remain critical addressable gaps in the provision of high-quality care to prevent and manage infection-related severe maternal outcomes in LMICs. Poor uptake of maternal death and near-miss reviews suggests missed learning opportunities by facility teams. Virtual platforms offer a feasible solution to improve routine adoption of confidential maternal death and near-miss reviews locally. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12884-022-04731-x. BioMed Central 2022-05-23 /pmc/articles/PMC9128080/ /pubmed/35606709 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12884-022-04731-x Text en © The Author(s) 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) ) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. |
spellingShingle | Research Okafor, Obiageli Roos, Nathalie Abdosh, Abdulfetah Abdulkadir Adesina, Olubukola Alaoui, Zaynab Romero, William Arriaga Assarag, Bouchra Aworinde, Olufemi de Bernis, Luc Castro, Rigoberto Chrifi, Hassan Day, Louise Tina Demissew, Rahel Aceituno, María Guadalupe Flores Gadama, Luis Gashawbeza, Biruck Keke, Sourou Goufodji Govule, Philip Gwako, George Jayaratne, Kapila Komboigo, Evelyne Béwendin Lara, Bredy Madziyire, Mugove Gerald Mathai, Matthews Moulki, Rachid Moutaouadia, Iatimad Munjanja, Stephen Fletes, Carlos Alberto Ochoa Ortiz, Edgar Ivan Ouedraogo, Henri Gautier Qureshi, Zahida Recidoro, Zenaida Dy Senanayake, Hemantha Soma-Pillay, Priya Tin, Khaing Nwe Sedami, Pascal Worku, Dawit Bonet, Mercedes International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
title | International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
title_full | International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
title_fullStr | International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
title_full_unstemmed | International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
title_short | International virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
title_sort | international virtual confidential reviews of infection-related maternal deaths and near-miss in 11 low- and middle-income countries – case report series and suggested actions |
topic | Research |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9128080/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35606709 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12884-022-04731-x |
work_keys_str_mv | AT okaforobiageli internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT roosnathalie internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT abdoshabdulfetahabdulkadir internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT adesinaolubukola internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT alaouizaynab internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT romerowilliamarriaga internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT assaragbouchra internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT aworindeolufemi internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT debernisluc internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT castrorigoberto internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT chrifihassan internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT daylouisetina internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT demissewrahel internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT aceitunomariaguadalupeflores internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT gadamaluis internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT gashawbezabiruck internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT kekesourougoufodji internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT govulephilip internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT gwakogeorge internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT jayaratnekapila internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT komboigoevelynebewendin internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT larabredy internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT madziyiremugovegerald internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT mathaimatthews internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT moulkirachid internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT moutaouadiaiatimad internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT munjanjastephen internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT fletescarlosalbertoochoa internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT ortizedgarivan internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT ouedraogohenrigautier internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT qureshizahida internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT recidorozenaidady internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT senanayakehemantha internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT somapillaypriya internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT tinkhaingnwe internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT sedamipascal internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT workudawit internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT bonetmercedes internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions AT internationalvirtualconfidentialreviewsofinfectionrelatedmaternaldeathsandnearmissin11lowandmiddleincomecountriescasereportseriesandsuggestedactions |