Cargando…

The unnaturalistic fallacy: COVID-19 vaccine mandates should not discriminate against natural immunity

COVID-19 vaccine requirements have generated significant debate. Here, we argue that, on the evidence available, such policies should have recognised proof of natural immunity as a sufficient basis for exemption to vaccination requirements. We begin by distinguishing our argument from two implausibl...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales:	Pugh, Jonathan, Savulescu, Julian, Brown, Rebecca C H, Wilkinson, Dominic
Formato:	Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:	English
Publicado:	BMJ Publishing Group 2022
Materias:	Feature Article
Acceso en línea:	https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9132858/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35256487 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2021-107956

Ejemplares similares

Vaccine mandates for healthcare workers beyond COVID-19
por: Giubilini, Alberto, et al.
Publicado: (2023)

Is mandating elective single embryo transfer ethically justifiable in young women?
por: Tremellen, Kelton, et al.
Publicado: (2016)

Expanded terminal sedation in end-of-life care
por: Gilbertson, Laura, et al.
Publicado: (2023)

Worth living or worth dying? The views of the general public about allowing disabled children to die
por: Brick, Claudia, et al.
Publicado: (2020)

Vaccine suspension, risk, and precaution in a pandemic
por: Pugh, Jonathan, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

What is in a Mandate? Introducing the UN Peace Mission Mandates Dataset
por: Hellmüller, Sara, et al.
Publicado: (2023)

Responsibility in healthcare across time and agents
por: Brown, Rebecca C H, et al.
Publicado: (2019)

A public health ethic should inform policies on COVID-19 immunity passports – Authors' reply
por: Brown, Rebecca C H, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Should vaccination against COVID-19 be mandated in patients on the transplant waiting list?
por: Ducloux, Didier, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Sense and sensitivity: can an inaccurate test be better than no test at all?
por: Pugh, Jonathan, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

Disability, discrimination and death: is it justified to ration life saving treatment for disabled newborn infants?
por: Wilkinson, Dominic, et al.
Publicado: (2014)

SHOULD WE ALLOW ORGAN DONATION EUTHANASIA? ALTERNATIVES FOR MAXIMIZING THE NUMBER AND QUALITY OF ORGANS FOR TRANSPLANTATION
por: Wilkinson, Dominic, et al.
Publicado: (2012)

Should uterus transplants be publicly funded?
por: Wilkinson, Stephen, et al.
Publicado: (2016)

Should COVID-19 vaccines be mandated in schools? - an international caregiver perspective
por: Baumer-Mouradian, Shannon H., et al.
Publicado: (2022)

In Favour of Medical Dissensus: Why We Should Agree to Disagree About End‐of‐Life Decisions
por: Wilkinson, Dominic, et al.
Publicado: (2015)

Ethical heuristics for pandemic allocation of ventilators across hospitals
por: Palacios-González, César, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

Beyond Individual Triage: Regional Allocation of Life-Saving Resources such as Ventilators in Public Health Emergencies
por: Pugh, Jonathan, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Moral uncertainty and the farming of human-pig chimeras
por: Koplin, Julian, et al.
Publicado: (2019)

Why healthcare leadership should embrace quality improvement
por: Drew, John R, et al.
Publicado: (2020)

COVID-19 vaccine: vaccinate the young to protect the old?
por: Giubilini, Alberto, et al.
Publicado: (2020)

Which Vaccine? The Cost of Religious Freedom in Vaccination Policy
por: Giubilini, Alberto, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

What should the role of the dentist be in managing patients with eating disorders?
por: Westgarth, David
Publicado: (2021)

Should AI allocate livers for transplant? Public attitudes and ethical considerations
por: Drezga-Kleiminger, Max, et al.
Publicado: (2023)

Moral reasons to edit the human genome: picking up from the Nuffield report
por: Gyngell, Christopher, et al.
Publicado: (2019)

Genomic intensive care: should we perform genome testing in critically ill newborns?
por: Wilkinson, Dominic JC, et al.
Publicado: (2016)

Why eco-friendly dentistry should be a top priority for dental professionals
Publicado: (2022)

Settling for second best: when should doctors agree to parental demands for suboptimal medical treatment?
por: Nair, Tara, et al.
Publicado: (2017)

Training for line managers should focus on primary prevention of mental ill-health at work
por: Blake, H, et al.
Publicado: (2023)

Should Health Care Institutions Mandate SARS-CoV-2 Vaccination for Staff?
por: Kates, Olivia S, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Queue questions: Ethics of COVID‐19 vaccine prioritization
por: Giubilini, Alberto, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Prevalence and persistence of smell and taste dysfunction in COVID-19; how should dental practices apply diagnostic criteria?
por: Hopkins, Claire, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

The nature of cell-cycle checkpoints: facts and fallacies
por: Khodjakov, Alexey, et al.
Publicado: (2009)

Which factors should be included in triage? An online survey of the attitudes of the UK general public to pandemic triage dilemmas
por: Wilkinson, Dominic, et al.
Publicado: (2020)

Ethics of selective restriction of liberty in a pandemic
por: Cameron, James, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

How should we deal with misattributed paternity? A survey of lay public attitudes
por: Lowe, Georgia, et al.
Publicado: (2017)

Restoring Nature's Backbone
por: Nicholls, Henry
Publicado: (2006)

Finding comfort in nature
por: Gross, Michael
Publicado: (2020)

The scientific and ethical feasibility of immunity passports
por: Brown, Rebecca C H, et al.
Publicado: (2021)

Emotions and Incivility in Vaccine Mandate Discourse: Natural Language Processing Insights
por: Stevens, Hannah, et al.
Publicado: (2022)

Sleep softly: Schubert, ethics and the value of dying well
por: Wilkinson, Dominic
Publicado: (2021)

Cannot write session to /tmp/vufind_sessions/sess_datlg2dag6fgjegffulbs9dt71