Cargando…
Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country
Diagnostics for COVID-19 detection are limited in many settings. Syndromic surveillance is often the only means to identify cases but lacks specificity. Rapid antigen testing is inexpensive and easy-to-deploy but can lack sensitivity. We examine how combining these approaches can improve surveillanc...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Nature Publishing Group UK
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9135686/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35618714 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30640-w |
_version_ | 1784714016849920000 |
---|---|
author | Chadwick, Fergus J. Clark, Jessica Chowdhury, Shayan Chowdhury, Tasnuva Pascall, David J. Haddou, Yacob Andrecka, Joanna Kundegorski, Mikolaj Wilkie, Craig Brum, Eric Shirin, Tahmina Alamgir, A. S. M. Rahman, Mahbubur Alam, Ahmed Nawsher Khan, Farzana Swallow, Ben Mair, Frances S. Illian, Janine Trotter, Caroline L. Hill, Davina L. Husmeier, Dirk Matthiopoulos, Jason Hampson, Katie Sania, Ayesha |
author_facet | Chadwick, Fergus J. Clark, Jessica Chowdhury, Shayan Chowdhury, Tasnuva Pascall, David J. Haddou, Yacob Andrecka, Joanna Kundegorski, Mikolaj Wilkie, Craig Brum, Eric Shirin, Tahmina Alamgir, A. S. M. Rahman, Mahbubur Alam, Ahmed Nawsher Khan, Farzana Swallow, Ben Mair, Frances S. Illian, Janine Trotter, Caroline L. Hill, Davina L. Husmeier, Dirk Matthiopoulos, Jason Hampson, Katie Sania, Ayesha |
author_sort | Chadwick, Fergus J. |
collection | PubMed |
description | Diagnostics for COVID-19 detection are limited in many settings. Syndromic surveillance is often the only means to identify cases but lacks specificity. Rapid antigen testing is inexpensive and easy-to-deploy but can lack sensitivity. We examine how combining these approaches can improve surveillance for guiding interventions in low-income communities in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Rapid-antigen-testing with PCR validation was performed on 1172 symptomatically-identified individuals in their homes. Statistical models were fitted to predict PCR-status using rapid-antigen-test results, syndromic data, and their combination. Under contrasting epidemiological scenarios, the models’ predictive and classification performance was evaluated. Models combining rapid-antigen-testing and syndromic data yielded equal-to-better performance to rapid-antigen-test-only models across all scenarios with their best performance in the epidemic growth scenario. These results show that drawing on complementary strengths across rapid diagnostics, improves COVID-19 detection, and reduces false-positive and -negative diagnoses to match local requirements; improvements achievable without additional expense, or changes for patients or practitioners. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9135686 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Nature Publishing Group UK |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-91356862022-05-28 Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country Chadwick, Fergus J. Clark, Jessica Chowdhury, Shayan Chowdhury, Tasnuva Pascall, David J. Haddou, Yacob Andrecka, Joanna Kundegorski, Mikolaj Wilkie, Craig Brum, Eric Shirin, Tahmina Alamgir, A. S. M. Rahman, Mahbubur Alam, Ahmed Nawsher Khan, Farzana Swallow, Ben Mair, Frances S. Illian, Janine Trotter, Caroline L. Hill, Davina L. Husmeier, Dirk Matthiopoulos, Jason Hampson, Katie Sania, Ayesha Nat Commun Article Diagnostics for COVID-19 detection are limited in many settings. Syndromic surveillance is often the only means to identify cases but lacks specificity. Rapid antigen testing is inexpensive and easy-to-deploy but can lack sensitivity. We examine how combining these approaches can improve surveillance for guiding interventions in low-income communities in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Rapid-antigen-testing with PCR validation was performed on 1172 symptomatically-identified individuals in their homes. Statistical models were fitted to predict PCR-status using rapid-antigen-test results, syndromic data, and their combination. Under contrasting epidemiological scenarios, the models’ predictive and classification performance was evaluated. Models combining rapid-antigen-testing and syndromic data yielded equal-to-better performance to rapid-antigen-test-only models across all scenarios with their best performance in the epidemic growth scenario. These results show that drawing on complementary strengths across rapid diagnostics, improves COVID-19 detection, and reduces false-positive and -negative diagnoses to match local requirements; improvements achievable without additional expense, or changes for patients or practitioners. Nature Publishing Group UK 2022-05-26 /pmc/articles/PMC9135686/ /pubmed/35618714 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30640-w Text en © The Author(s) 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . |
spellingShingle | Article Chadwick, Fergus J. Clark, Jessica Chowdhury, Shayan Chowdhury, Tasnuva Pascall, David J. Haddou, Yacob Andrecka, Joanna Kundegorski, Mikolaj Wilkie, Craig Brum, Eric Shirin, Tahmina Alamgir, A. S. M. Rahman, Mahbubur Alam, Ahmed Nawsher Khan, Farzana Swallow, Ben Mair, Frances S. Illian, Janine Trotter, Caroline L. Hill, Davina L. Husmeier, Dirk Matthiopoulos, Jason Hampson, Katie Sania, Ayesha Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country |
title | Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country |
title_full | Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country |
title_fullStr | Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country |
title_full_unstemmed | Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country |
title_short | Combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based COVID-19 detection in a low-income country |
title_sort | combining rapid antigen testing and syndromic surveillance improves community-based covid-19 detection in a low-income country |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9135686/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35618714 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30640-w |
work_keys_str_mv | AT chadwickfergusj combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT clarkjessica combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT chowdhuryshayan combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT chowdhurytasnuva combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT pascalldavidj combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT haddouyacob combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT andreckajoanna combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT kundegorskimikolaj combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT wilkiecraig combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT brumeric combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT shirintahmina combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT alamgirasm combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT rahmanmahbubur combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT alamahmednawsher combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT khanfarzana combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT swallowben combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT mairfrancess combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT illianjanine combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT trottercarolinel combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT hilldavinal combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT husmeierdirk combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT matthiopoulosjason combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT hampsonkatie combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry AT saniaayesha combiningrapidantigentestingandsyndromicsurveillanceimprovescommunitybasedcovid19detectioninalowincomecountry |