Cargando…
An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks
There is growing interest in the quantification of gait as part of complex motor tasks. This requires gait events (GEs) to be detected under conditions different from straight walking. This study aimed to propose and validate a new marker-based GE detection method, which is also suitable for curvili...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9201978/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35721859 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fbioe.2022.868928 |
_version_ | 1784728434096734208 |
---|---|
author | Bonci, Tecla Salis, Francesca Scott, Kirsty Alcock, Lisa Becker, Clemens Bertuletti, Stefano Buckley, Ellen Caruso, Marco Cereatti, Andrea Del Din, Silvia Gazit, Eran Hansen, Clint Hausdorff, Jeffrey M. Maetzler, Walter Palmerini, Luca Rochester, Lynn Schwickert, Lars Sharrack, Basil Vogiatzis, Ioannis Mazzà, Claudia |
author_facet | Bonci, Tecla Salis, Francesca Scott, Kirsty Alcock, Lisa Becker, Clemens Bertuletti, Stefano Buckley, Ellen Caruso, Marco Cereatti, Andrea Del Din, Silvia Gazit, Eran Hansen, Clint Hausdorff, Jeffrey M. Maetzler, Walter Palmerini, Luca Rochester, Lynn Schwickert, Lars Sharrack, Basil Vogiatzis, Ioannis Mazzà, Claudia |
author_sort | Bonci, Tecla |
collection | PubMed |
description | There is growing interest in the quantification of gait as part of complex motor tasks. This requires gait events (GEs) to be detected under conditions different from straight walking. This study aimed to propose and validate a new marker-based GE detection method, which is also suitable for curvilinear walking and step negotiation. The method was first tested against existing algorithms using data from healthy young adults (YA, n = 20) and then assessed in data from 10 individuals from the following five cohorts: older adults, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, and proximal femur fracture. The propagation of the errors associated with GE detection on the calculation of stride length, duration, speed, and stance/swing durations was investigated. All participants performed a variety of motor tasks including curvilinear walking and step negotiation, while reference GEs were identified using a validated methodology exploiting pressure insole signals. Sensitivity, positive predictive values (PPV), F1-score, bias, precision, and accuracy were calculated. Absolute agreement [intraclass correlation coefficient ( [Formula: see text] )] between marker-based and pressure insole stride parameters was also tested. In the YA cohort, the proposed method outperformed the existing ones, with sensitivity, PPV, and F1 scores ≥ 99% for both GEs and conditions, with a virtually null bias (<10 ms). Overall, temporal inaccuracies minimally impacted stride duration, length, and speed (median absolute errors ≤1%). Similar algorithm performances were obtained for all the other five cohorts in GE detection and propagation to the stride parameters, where an excellent absolute agreement with the pressure insoles was also found ( [Formula: see text] ). In conclusion, the proposed method accurately detects GE from marker data under different walking conditions and for a variety of gait impairments. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9201978 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-92019782022-06-17 An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks Bonci, Tecla Salis, Francesca Scott, Kirsty Alcock, Lisa Becker, Clemens Bertuletti, Stefano Buckley, Ellen Caruso, Marco Cereatti, Andrea Del Din, Silvia Gazit, Eran Hansen, Clint Hausdorff, Jeffrey M. Maetzler, Walter Palmerini, Luca Rochester, Lynn Schwickert, Lars Sharrack, Basil Vogiatzis, Ioannis Mazzà, Claudia Front Bioeng Biotechnol Bioengineering and Biotechnology There is growing interest in the quantification of gait as part of complex motor tasks. This requires gait events (GEs) to be detected under conditions different from straight walking. This study aimed to propose and validate a new marker-based GE detection method, which is also suitable for curvilinear walking and step negotiation. The method was first tested against existing algorithms using data from healthy young adults (YA, n = 20) and then assessed in data from 10 individuals from the following five cohorts: older adults, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, and proximal femur fracture. The propagation of the errors associated with GE detection on the calculation of stride length, duration, speed, and stance/swing durations was investigated. All participants performed a variety of motor tasks including curvilinear walking and step negotiation, while reference GEs were identified using a validated methodology exploiting pressure insole signals. Sensitivity, positive predictive values (PPV), F1-score, bias, precision, and accuracy were calculated. Absolute agreement [intraclass correlation coefficient ( [Formula: see text] )] between marker-based and pressure insole stride parameters was also tested. In the YA cohort, the proposed method outperformed the existing ones, with sensitivity, PPV, and F1 scores ≥ 99% for both GEs and conditions, with a virtually null bias (<10 ms). Overall, temporal inaccuracies minimally impacted stride duration, length, and speed (median absolute errors ≤1%). Similar algorithm performances were obtained for all the other five cohorts in GE detection and propagation to the stride parameters, where an excellent absolute agreement with the pressure insoles was also found ( [Formula: see text] ). In conclusion, the proposed method accurately detects GE from marker data under different walking conditions and for a variety of gait impairments. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-06-02 /pmc/articles/PMC9201978/ /pubmed/35721859 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fbioe.2022.868928 Text en Copyright © 2022 Bonci, Salis, Scott, Alcock, Becker, Bertuletti, Buckley, Caruso, Cereatti, Del Din, Gazit, Hansen, Hausdorff, Maetzler, Palmerini, Rochester, Schwickert, Sharrack, Vogiatzis and Mazzà. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms. |
spellingShingle | Bioengineering and Biotechnology Bonci, Tecla Salis, Francesca Scott, Kirsty Alcock, Lisa Becker, Clemens Bertuletti, Stefano Buckley, Ellen Caruso, Marco Cereatti, Andrea Del Din, Silvia Gazit, Eran Hansen, Clint Hausdorff, Jeffrey M. Maetzler, Walter Palmerini, Luca Rochester, Lynn Schwickert, Lars Sharrack, Basil Vogiatzis, Ioannis Mazzà, Claudia An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks |
title | An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks |
title_full | An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks |
title_fullStr | An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks |
title_full_unstemmed | An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks |
title_short | An Algorithm for Accurate Marker-Based Gait Event Detection in Healthy and Pathological Populations During Complex Motor Tasks |
title_sort | algorithm for accurate marker-based gait event detection in healthy and pathological populations during complex motor tasks |
topic | Bioengineering and Biotechnology |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9201978/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35721859 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fbioe.2022.868928 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT boncitecla analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT salisfrancesca analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT scottkirsty analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT alcocklisa analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT beckerclemens analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT bertulettistefano analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT buckleyellen analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT carusomarco analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT cereattiandrea analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT deldinsilvia analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT gaziteran analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT hansenclint analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT hausdorffjeffreym analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT maetzlerwalter analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT palmeriniluca analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT rochesterlynn analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT schwickertlars analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT sharrackbasil analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT vogiatzisioannis analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT mazzaclaudia analgorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT boncitecla algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT salisfrancesca algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT scottkirsty algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT alcocklisa algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT beckerclemens algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT bertulettistefano algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT buckleyellen algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT carusomarco algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT cereattiandrea algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT deldinsilvia algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT gaziteran algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT hansenclint algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT hausdorffjeffreym algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT maetzlerwalter algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT palmeriniluca algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT rochesterlynn algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT schwickertlars algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT sharrackbasil algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT vogiatzisioannis algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks AT mazzaclaudia algorithmforaccuratemarkerbasedgaiteventdetectioninhealthyandpathologicalpopulationsduringcomplexmotortasks |