Cargando…

Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study

BACKGROUND: Human behavior is crucial in health outcomes. Particularly, individual behavior is a determinant of the success of measures to overcome critical conditions, such as a pandemic. In addition to intrinsic public health challenges associated with COVID-19, in many countries, some individuals...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Urbanin, Gabriel, Meira, Wagner, Serpa, Alexandre, Costa, Danielle de Souza, Baldaçara, Leonardo, da Silva, Ana Paula, Guatimosim, Rafaela, Lacerda, Anísio Mendes, Oliveira, Eduardo Araújo, Braule, Andre, Romano-Silva, Marco Aurélio, da Silva, Antônio Geraldo, Malloy-Diniz, Leandro, Pappa, Gisele, Miranda, Débora Marques
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JMIR Publications 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9202654/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35704360
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/34020
_version_ 1784728575813877760
author Urbanin, Gabriel
Meira, Wagner
Serpa, Alexandre
Costa, Danielle de Souza
Baldaçara, Leonardo
da Silva, Ana Paula
Guatimosim, Rafaela
Lacerda, Anísio Mendes
Oliveira, Eduardo Araújo
Braule, Andre
Romano-Silva, Marco Aurélio
da Silva, Antônio Geraldo
Malloy-Diniz, Leandro
Pappa, Gisele
Miranda, Débora Marques
author_facet Urbanin, Gabriel
Meira, Wagner
Serpa, Alexandre
Costa, Danielle de Souza
Baldaçara, Leonardo
da Silva, Ana Paula
Guatimosim, Rafaela
Lacerda, Anísio Mendes
Oliveira, Eduardo Araújo
Braule, Andre
Romano-Silva, Marco Aurélio
da Silva, Antônio Geraldo
Malloy-Diniz, Leandro
Pappa, Gisele
Miranda, Débora Marques
author_sort Urbanin, Gabriel
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Human behavior is crucial in health outcomes. Particularly, individual behavior is a determinant of the success of measures to overcome critical conditions, such as a pandemic. In addition to intrinsic public health challenges associated with COVID-19, in many countries, some individuals decided not to get vaccinated, streets were crowded, parties were happening, and businesses struggling to survive were partially open, despite lockdown or stay-at-home instructions. These behaviors contrast with the instructions for potential benefits associated with social distancing, use of masks, and vaccination to manage collective and individual risks. OBJECTIVE: Considering that human behavior is a result of individuals' social and economic conditions, we investigated the social and working characteristics associated with reports of appropriate protective behavior in Brazil. METHODS: We analyzed data from a large web survey of individuals reporting their behavior during the pandemic. We selected 3 common self-care measures: use of protective masks, distancing by at least 1 m when out of the house, and handwashing or use of alcohol, combined with assessment of the social context of respondents. We measured the frequency of the use of these self-protective measures. Using a frequent pattern–mining perspective, we generated association rules from a set of answers to questions that co-occur with at least a given frequency, identifying the pattern of characteristics of the groups divided according to protective behavior reports. RESULTS: The rationale was to identify a pool of working and social characteristics that might have better adhesion to behaviors and self-care measures, showing these are more socially determined than previously thought. We identified common patterns of socioeconomic and working determinants of compliance with protective self-care measures. Data mining showed that social determinants might be important to shape behavior in different stages of the pandemic. CONCLUSIONS: Identification of context determinants might be helpful to identify unexpected facilitators and constraints to fully follow public policies. The context of diseases contributes to psychological and physical health outcomes, and context understanding might change the approach to a disease. Hidden social determinants might change protective behavior, and social determinants of protective behavior related to COVID-19 are related to work and economic conditions. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Not applicable.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9202654
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-92026542022-06-17 Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study Urbanin, Gabriel Meira, Wagner Serpa, Alexandre Costa, Danielle de Souza Baldaçara, Leonardo da Silva, Ana Paula Guatimosim, Rafaela Lacerda, Anísio Mendes Oliveira, Eduardo Araújo Braule, Andre Romano-Silva, Marco Aurélio da Silva, Antônio Geraldo Malloy-Diniz, Leandro Pappa, Gisele Miranda, Débora Marques JMIR Public Health Surveill Original Paper BACKGROUND: Human behavior is crucial in health outcomes. Particularly, individual behavior is a determinant of the success of measures to overcome critical conditions, such as a pandemic. In addition to intrinsic public health challenges associated with COVID-19, in many countries, some individuals decided not to get vaccinated, streets were crowded, parties were happening, and businesses struggling to survive were partially open, despite lockdown or stay-at-home instructions. These behaviors contrast with the instructions for potential benefits associated with social distancing, use of masks, and vaccination to manage collective and individual risks. OBJECTIVE: Considering that human behavior is a result of individuals' social and economic conditions, we investigated the social and working characteristics associated with reports of appropriate protective behavior in Brazil. METHODS: We analyzed data from a large web survey of individuals reporting their behavior during the pandemic. We selected 3 common self-care measures: use of protective masks, distancing by at least 1 m when out of the house, and handwashing or use of alcohol, combined with assessment of the social context of respondents. We measured the frequency of the use of these self-protective measures. Using a frequent pattern–mining perspective, we generated association rules from a set of answers to questions that co-occur with at least a given frequency, identifying the pattern of characteristics of the groups divided according to protective behavior reports. RESULTS: The rationale was to identify a pool of working and social characteristics that might have better adhesion to behaviors and self-care measures, showing these are more socially determined than previously thought. We identified common patterns of socioeconomic and working determinants of compliance with protective self-care measures. Data mining showed that social determinants might be important to shape behavior in different stages of the pandemic. CONCLUSIONS: Identification of context determinants might be helpful to identify unexpected facilitators and constraints to fully follow public policies. The context of diseases contributes to psychological and physical health outcomes, and context understanding might change the approach to a disease. Hidden social determinants might change protective behavior, and social determinants of protective behavior related to COVID-19 are related to work and economic conditions. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Not applicable. JMIR Publications 2022-06-15 /pmc/articles/PMC9202654/ /pubmed/35704360 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/34020 Text en ©Gabriel Urbanin, Wagner Meira, Alexandre Serpa, Danielle de Souza Costa, Leonardo Baldaçara, Ana Paula da Silva, Rafaela Guatimosim, Anísio Mendes Lacerda, Eduardo Araújo Oliveira, Andre Braule, Marco Aurélio Romano-Silva, Antônio Geraldo da Silva, Leandro Malloy-Diniz, Gisele Pappa, Débora Marques Miranda. Originally published in JMIR Public Health and Surveillance (https://publichealth.jmir.org), 15.06.2022. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Public Health and Surveillance, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://publichealth.jmir.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
spellingShingle Original Paper
Urbanin, Gabriel
Meira, Wagner
Serpa, Alexandre
Costa, Danielle de Souza
Baldaçara, Leonardo
da Silva, Ana Paula
Guatimosim, Rafaela
Lacerda, Anísio Mendes
Oliveira, Eduardo Araújo
Braule, Andre
Romano-Silva, Marco Aurélio
da Silva, Antônio Geraldo
Malloy-Diniz, Leandro
Pappa, Gisele
Miranda, Débora Marques
Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study
title Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study
title_full Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study
title_fullStr Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study
title_full_unstemmed Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study
title_short Social Determinants in Self-Protective Behavior Related to COVID-19: Association Rule–Mining Study
title_sort social determinants in self-protective behavior related to covid-19: association rule–mining study
topic Original Paper
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9202654/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35704360
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/34020
work_keys_str_mv AT urbaningabriel socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT meirawagner socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT serpaalexandre socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT costadanielledesouza socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT baldacaraleonardo socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT dasilvaanapaula socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT guatimosimrafaela socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT lacerdaanisiomendes socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT oliveiraeduardoaraujo socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT brauleandre socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT romanosilvamarcoaurelio socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT dasilvaantoniogeraldo socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT malloydinizleandro socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT pappagisele socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy
AT mirandadeboramarques socialdeterminantsinselfprotectivebehaviorrelatedtocovid19associationruleminingstudy